Hmm. We need some clues.
For me, 'old fashioned' = the ones that are now back in fashion : Alf, William, Reg, Stan, Bert
then you go down a generation and hit those that are probably still 'old fashioned to new parents : Alan, Derek, Ray, Geoff
next generation you have the : Kevin, Gary, Philip, Mark, Richard, Steve, David
and so on.
"Cute" ?? This baby you are looking forward to will not appreciate that as a 14 yr old / 18yr old, or even as a man
"Unique" ? Well, if we've heard of it, then it won't be unique if you then give it to your child.
We need clues as to the sorts of names you like or don't like.