Another boy - help!

[TeaMakesMeHappy]

I am currently pregnant with our third DS. We managed to agree on a name for our first which we both liked. We had slightly different opinions for our second DS and ended up using both names (one as first name, the other for middle name). Anyway, we are now expecting another boy and are really struggling for names. We have names that one of us like and the other thinks is ok but not overly thrilled with. We have literally looked through 1000s of names!
So what names do you like and think go with our other two DSs names. We already have Joshua and Toby.
Names on our list include:
Louis
Ethan
James
Oliver (I like but really don’t like Ollie)
Edward (with Teddy as a nickname but this is the middle name for DS1)
William (but don’t really think it fits surname)
Nathan
Benjamin
Isaac
Matthew

I love Benjamin and Matthew from your list. Suggestions:

Henry
Lucas
Reuben
Max
Joseph
Milo
Felix
Sebastian
Harry
Arlo

Maxwell?

James is perfect. Both classic vintage yet still modern. Suits all stages of life.
Louis is fine for a baby child and teenager but not so much for a grown man.
Ethan see Louis.
If you don't like Ollie avoid Oliver.
Nathan is Lovely but a tad dated.
Matthew really dislike this sorry. However there'snothing wrong with it as name. Like James it suits all ages plus Matt is a good strong nn.
William. Well you've answered your own question if you don't like it with your surname.
I don't like Benjamin but quite like Ben.
I don't like Isaac although I think it goes perfectly with Joshua and Toby.
I don't think Edward really fits to be honest and I wouldn't use it as first name if one of your other boys has it for a MN as some people choose to go by their MN don't they if they don't like their first name. Therfore by calling this new baby Edward, youre taking that option away.

Thanks for the input ladies. Re: other suggestions.
Henry - I really like it, DH doesn’t at all sadly
Lucas - can’t as DN is Luke
Reuben - not a fan
Max/Maxwell - again, I really like Max (not so keen on Maxwell) but DH really doesn’t.
Joseph - not sure on this one. Might have a think about it though.
Milo - not a massive fan plus I taught a really obnoxious Milo who had a personal hatred of me (and told me so!) so that puts me off too.
Felix - when I hear this name I just think of cats - silly I know.
Sebastian - not my thing. It’s a nice enough name, just not one I would choose myself.
Harry - too common (as in, there are loads of Harrys in this area)
Arlo - can’t explain why without giving yet more identifying information away but we definitely can’t have this name.

I like Ethan, James, Benjamin and Matthew from your list. Benjamin goes well with Joshua and Toby.

@Awwlookatmybabyspider with regard to William - I guess I have just been reluctant to rule it out as it’s one of the few both DH and I like. But you are right, it should come off the list.
And you make a good point re: Edward.

Theodore to call him Teddy?

I like Benjamin from your list. Benji is cute for a little boy.

Sorry, is Edward the middle name for your other child or is it Teddy?

James because I have a Joshua and James :)

Love Louis, it is perfectly fine as an adult name, know loads in their 20’s. And Matthew (if you like Matt)

Daniel
Alexander
Samuel

Agree with above poster re Theodore then either Theo or Teddy

Love Joshua, Toby and James personally 😊 Although Isaac is my favourite from the list due to the meaning.

Other suggestions:
Jack?
Artie/Arthur?
Callum?
Lewis?
Ethan?

Sorry, to clarify Edward is DS1 middle name and Theodore is DS2 middle name.
I really like James too, DH doesn’t mind it but says “we can’t have two J names” not sure where he has got that idea from!
DH likes Samuel, I’m not so keen although not sure why.
Alexander I like as a middle name but not as a first name (again, not entirely sure why)
Daniel is DSs uncle and want to avoid any uncles names (they have four) as it might seem like favouritism.

I feel like every suggestion I’m just saying no too! Don’t mean to. I have liked a few of them but DH doesn’t. And there have been a couple DH likes but I don’t so you ladies seem to “get” our taste.

James. It doesn't even need a reason

Nicholas
Barnaby
Freddie
Charlie

joshua, toby and ethan sounds perfect.

Or

Jonathan
Andrew
George
Michael
Peter
Noah
Luke
Matthew
William

Edmund nickname Teddy?

David

Adam

What about Lucas?

Out of your first list I love Louis. I’d go with that.

Not a man’s name? Tell that to all the kings of France!

Joel
Arthur
Caleb
Daniel

Sorry, not Daniel!

Jacob?

Arlo - can’t explain why without giving yet more identifying information away but we definitely can’t have this name.

Ooo. Curious. Is your surname Barlow? Or Marlowe? Or Guthrie?

FWIW I like Louis best.

Patrick
Benedict (bit more inventive than Benjamin, plus you can use Ben or Ned as nickname)
Thomas - a classic because it's a lovely name
Peter
Adam
Jacob