Emerald

[LadyPug]

Would this be ok as a middle name or is it crazy?

No its fine as a MN. What first name is it to go with.

If you love it then why not? It's quite pretty actually. I know of an Elodie Emerald.

I think only 5% of people in my life know my middle name...

So go for it!

We aren’t set on first name yet but funnily enough we’re thinking Elodie! Haha!

Love it. I also like Topaz and Sapphire. I don’t really understand why Ruby and Pearl are acceptable but not other gemstone names. Even quite like Diamond.

Good choice OP

One of my best friends has the middle name Amethyst. Her first name is a very popular common name. I’d say for a middle name.. go for it!!

Haha thank you GreatDuck

Totally fine as a middle name.
Elodie Emerald sounds a bit like a children's book character.

Love it

Lovely middle name !

Love it-- class

DD2 is called Esmerelda which of course means Emerald and I adore it....

Love it, but possibly wasted as a middle name? I don't know anyone's middle names (& no one knows mine, thank god)

Lovely as a middle name

I know someone with Emerald as a first name. I think it’s fine as a mn!

Don't like it, sorry - if you look at it as a word and sound instead of the gemstone association, it's not very attractive. Think it's the 'Emer' bit - reminds me of Emerson, Emeritus. It's a very staid, stern kind of sound.

Really like Amethyst though!

I like it

It's lovely