Niall or Tobias?

[Icloud54]

Which do you prefer? I like them both equally.

I'm Irish, the Niall/Neil I know is late forties living in the West of Ireland.

All the Neils I know are in their late forties! It's too soon for a revival.

Niall! Great strong classic.

Toby sounds cutesy and will date.

Niall isn't pronounced Neil!

It's Nee-al in Gaelic, hence Neil in Scots. It's interesting to read that Niall is pronounced "Nye-al" in Irish, I didn't know that.

I'm not keen on the "Nile" pronunciation OP, but also not wild about Tobias. Tobin, perhaps?

I have a nephew Niall, pronounced Neil in Ireland. In irish Neil is spelled Niall but in english it's not.

Niall definitely. Can't move for Tobys at the moment...

Tobias just reminds me of Tobias Funke from Arrested Development and Niall was a chav at high school!

Niall, pronounced Nile. I like Neil and Toby.

Tobias nn Toby is lovely! but Niall is still al lovely name too

Niall is nice but only with the Nile pronunciation. Not liking the other.

Tobias is a bit wet imo.

Tobias 100%
Niall is too...boybandish!