Help and thoughts with my baby girl name list please- Inca/Eden

[Potteryprincess30]

This is my first post but I have been struggling with opinions on my baby girl names.

Partner and friends are very sweet by saying they like them all or that they are 'ok' but it means i'm probably not getting honest reactions to them. Most people I know are from a alternative place/background so they are also very used to hearing/having weird and wonderful (or awful!) names.

I have 3 months to go on this pregnancy but time seems to be going so fast so here goes:

Inca/ Inka
Eden
Marlowe
Shiloh
Cherish

Just as a point of reference 'Inka' (can also be spelt Inca) is a Scandinavian baby name but I also have no issues if people associate it with the South American Inca's/Inka's.

Any ideas or opinions welcome

Inca/ Inka - sounds cool, but I totally can't disassociate it from the Inka's!
Eden - LOVE this. Met a little girl called Eden and thought it was just a fab name, and underused too.
Marlowe - Nope. Dated and clunky.
Shiloh - to me more a pet name.
Cherish - NOPE.

Inka. This spelling.

Not a fan of the rest. Cherish is really, really bad.

Eden is OK.

I don't like the rest of the list at all. Sorry.

As previous poster said, Inga is a traditional Scandinavian girls name.

Inka is a name used in Scandinavia also. Not Inca.

Eden, maybe Inka.

Eden

Eden is 100% chav, Shiloh is copycat celeb, Cherish would be fine in an African country or the Deep South, Marlowe’s ok but another celeb baby name (Sienna Miller) so that leaves Inca - which is orginal but odd.

What about Katinka - Inka for short?

Katinka ?! God thts even worse ! But, other than that, what th last poster said !

Don't like Inca/Inka or Marlowe.

I like Eden and Cherish.

Any but Cherish.

Eden is beautiful... if I had another girl that would of been her name x

Thank you everyone so much! I really needed some honesty and its given me much more clarity. Cherish is forever off the list now so do not fear! Shiloh is probably equally a no from the sounds of things, and probably was a moment of brangelina pregnancy mania.

Eden and Inka/Inca have made the grade, even though I know they havn't and won't please everyone, I think they are the most acceptable for a baby through to adulthood and socially ect form your comments.

All the best to all of you

Inka (with a k) is the only one I like, but I do really like it.

How about Katinka to give her more options, you can call her Inka from the start, but she has something else to use if she so chooses?

P.S. I really like Inka! :)

But Katinka does give her options like Kat, Kati, and Tink! :D

Marlowe is very cool.

Love Eden

I had Skye on my list

Inca/ Inka - like the Mayans or the Aztecs. No. Absolutely not.

Eden - it's ok.

Marlowe - also ok

Shiloh - Brad Pitts daughter. No.

Cherish - no. Some virtue names are nice and I like this as a middle name, but it's too much as a first.

Didn't the Incas make human sacrifices?

Eden