Help with boys names!

[Gimmeallthecoffee]

We are expecting a little boy in January and are struggling to find a boy's name we love. I don't want something too popular, nor do I want something very unusual.

I like ...
Theo (getting very popular)
Finlay / Finley or just Finn
Max
Alfie (was very popular not so long ago!)

I don't think I've found "the one" yet though! Any thoughts on anything I might like?

I love all those! Other suggestions:

Hugo
Dexter
Wilfred
Freddie
Jonah
Gabriel
Jude
Elijah
Dylan
Zachary
Arthur

Also

Rafferty
Barnaby
Hamish
George
Kai
Liam
Alexander
Luca
Arlo
Xavier

Gus
Eric
Ivor
Cameron
Hector
Jonas

Love some of the suggestions you've already been given. I'd also add:

Jago
Nathaniel
Harvey
Milo
Alistair

Love Max.
How about ;
Rex
Rory
Rudy
Adam
Joseph
Leon

Flynn
Samuel
Alexander
Hugo
Barnaby
Edmund
Thomas
Benjamin
Robert
Kyle

Flynn
Milo
Leo
Hugo
Dexter
Rex
Louis
Alex
Axel
Zachary
Luke
Henry
Ethan
Sebastian
Tobias

We have very similar taste in names. My DS is Max and Finn was also on our list, and currently expecting baby number 3 and Theo is top of my list if it's a boy!

Others on the list are:
Leo
Jonah
Luke
Jude
Tristan
Aaron
Nico (needs a fuller name I think)
I also like Dominic but really dislike Dom as a nickname. Nico could work but there's still the risk that someone else calls him Dom and it sticks!

Arnie
Fintan
Ferdinand / Ferdie
Judd

Lance
Daniel
Matthew
Nathan
Joel