Nicholas or Josiah

[poppylip]

Hello! So struggling with names and he's due in two weeks!!
So either

Josiah salvatore
Josiah Antonio
Or

Nicholas Antonio

??

Nicholas, by far. Josiah makes me think of an elderly Amish gentleman in dungarees and a wide-brimmed hat

Haha thank you!
Didn't think of that...but you're right 😂

I love Josiah but then I have a Jedidiah and DB has Obediah so I guess we are a bit closet Aimish

Still love the name but I see the Amish thing!

DS's best friend has just had twins Sirus and Duke (Marmaduke)
Tres cool!

Nicholas.

Josiah is so Bible belt American.

Nicholas for sure. Josiah sounds a bit common tbh.

Nicholas 100%

Absolutely no to Josiah. Nicholas maybe, what about Joseph?

Nicholas. But I do like Josiah too.

Nicholas is a great name.

Josiah 100%

Biblical names are cool now. Nicholas is so boring.

Nicholas. Josiah is so stuffy.

I like Nicholas Salvatore

Josiah is too Duggar

Love Nicholas. So far from my usual style, don't think I would ever use it. Also like Nikolai.

Nicholas.
With either nico or Cole as a nn.

Josiah is too "bibley " for me.

Nicholas, definitely.

Nicholas is a bit boring and dated. Josiah is different and can also be shortened to Jos or Jo. Nicholas will be...Nick.

Both are nice but I really like Nicholas (Cole)

Josiah is fab. Nicholas is fine but I don't like Nick and it's inevitable.

I prefer Nicholas. You could go for Colas or Nico, both normal French diminutives, and there are lots of others, too, like Nils or Claus. I like Cole, too.