Sister for Lucy and Chloe..

[PopcornFiend]

Need ideas please!

I love Phoebe or Betsy but DH doesn't, sadly.

Any ideas? What do you think of Jane, Emily, Harriet, Cecily, Polly?

Middle names likely to be Evelyn Hannah or other way round.

Annabel
Flora
Caroline
Laura
Amy
Ruby

I like Harriet best from your list.
Others I can imagine:
Lucy, Chloe and Esme
Lucy, Chloe and Martha
Lucy, Chloe and Clara
Lucy, Chloe and Anna

Emilia
Grace
Ruby
Mia

Your DDs have Lovely "ageless names" so what about these

Emily,
emma,
Hannah,
amy,
Alice,
Claire
Sophie
Katie
Grace

I know two sibsets of Lucy, Chloe and Sophie.

From your list, Emily and Polly are the two more "matchy" names in my opinion, whereas Harriet and Jane are a different kind of name. Jane is a lovely name when used as MN - Polly Jane? Harriet is one of those names I really want to like, but like Felicity, it just doesn't sound nice to me...
Cecily and Cicely are lovely too.

Lucy, Chloe and Molly
Lucy, Chloe and Sally
Lucy, Chloe and Isla
Lucy, Chloe and Alice

Good luck

Freya
Esme
Eloise
Saskia
Annalise
Holly

Wow, thanks all for the responses!
I think my shortlist is now:
Emily
Polly
Hannah (was planning as middle name but actually warming to it as first name)

DH has made a cats bum face at Cecily & Harriet 🙄

I wouldn't go for another y or ie sounding ending. Lucy, Chloe and onesyllable or Lucy, Chloe and somethingette maybe.

Lucy, Chloe and Juliette
Lucy, Chloe and Olivia
Lucy, Chloe and Belle

Sophie
Rebecca
Emma
Emily
Hannah
Katie
Eliza
Jayne
Sarah
Bethany
Elizabeth
Victoria
Isobel
Grace
Alexandra
Caitlyn
Jenny

Hannah is lovely :)

I really like the sound of Lucy, Chloe and Jane.

How about
Alice
Tessa
Madeleine
Stella or Estelle
Greta
Rosalie
Romy
Rowena
Daphne
Helena
Annabel

Peony
Emmie

Not another "EE" ending.
Lucy, Chloe and Emilia/Emma if you like Emily