Matilda or Rosie

[RR530]

Having a name nightmare! Have a son and daughter called Amelia and William. Who we sometimes call mills and wills as nn. New baby daughter has been named Rosie Isabella however it doesn't seem to fit with the other children's names and not sure if it suits her or whether we should change it to Matilda emily rose. My husband is not keen on Rosie and likes the name Matilda. I always liked the name emily as it is my great grandmothers name. I'm worried that she may end up with nick name tills then it would be mills, wills and tills, and non sure if mills, wills and Tilly works either . Love the names Charlotte and Florence but can't use either of these as have a niece named Charlotte and Florence is my daughters middle name. Any thoughts on this?? Or suggestions. Many thanks!

Mafalda?

Rose is beautiful imo. Or what about Rosalie?

Amelia, William and Matilda Rose.
Mills, Wills and Tills ! 😂

I would have said Matilda, but if you don't like Tills. I'd avoid it. I don't like Rosie which is strange as it was on my short list for dd.
I think you need another long classic and pretty name to match Amelia and William.
Harriet
Vivienne
Annabelle
Katherine
You were going to Isobelle as a mn. If you'd gone with Rosie. Would you have not use it as first name.
Francesca
Alexandra
Jessica
Melissa
Elizabeth

Rosa rather than Rosie as it will suit an adult better than Rosie would

Matilda
Lydia
Meredith
Eloise

Rose or Rosie, Matilda reminds me of mildew.

Rose or Rosie definitely.

Don't like Matilda at all

Rosie!

(Although I may have a vested interest ...)

I think Matilda goes better with your other children's names. Rosie is really lovely too.
I quite like Mills, Wills & Tills. ... It's like it's meant to be.

I prefer Rosie.

I think Matilda goes with your other children's names and also quite like Mills Wills & Tills

Rosie. I've known an adult Rosie and child Rosies (my DD is one) and it's suited them all perfectly well.

Congrats!

I love Matilda! I think it goes well with Amelia and William (and I like Mills, Wills and Tills!)
I prefer Rose to Rosie. Probably sounds daft but I always think of Rosie as a nickname not a real name.

Matilda Rose is nice

I love both names, but think I'd go for Rosie, just because Amelia and Matilda sound a bit similar.

Rosie is really popular, Matilda is good and there are less of them about in my area.

Rosie is gorgeous. So pretty

Definitely my favourite of the two

Thank you for your help so far. It's really hard trying to choose a name when you can't use your two preferred names and I think I've spent so much time thinking about names and going round in circles!

Matilda rose is very nice i think.

But mable is my new fav at moment.I am not having more kids but if i had a girl it would be mable

Rose is very special name to me you hardly here it these days .

I love both, but in this case I prefer Rosie Isabella over Matilda Emily Rose.

Rosie Isabella is such a gorgeous combination.

Matilda Rose is a beautiful name.

(Sorry to be a pedant, but Mabel is spelt 'el' not 'le' like table).

Rosie is beautiful 😊

I love Rosie. Rosalie, NN Rosie might be good choice?

Rosalie Matilda sounds lovely.

I think Matilda is lovely.

Rosie doesn't have enough gravitas for me so I would pick a longer Rose type name on the birth certificate: I like Rosalind and Rosanna.

Rose or Matilda. Love both.
I really dislike Rosie!
I have a No and a Ro by accident! I quite like Mills, wills and tills

I like Matilda but she will inevitably get called Tills/Tilly. I would use Tilda as a NN but other people may not. I like the name Rose but more so Primrose.