I just can't name this baby girl! It's impossible.

[MilkyWayHeyHey]

If she was a boy, I have 2 names sorted (4 - 2 first and 2 middle!)

I'm very happy though, but just can't name her. I hate names that I used to like and I just don't know what to call her. I'm just bored of the ones I loved.

I'm very keen on Dorothy! I don't even know why! I do prefer it for a middle name though. Madeleine Dorothy? Eh, I'm just not keen. Really like Maddie though. Just don't know really.

I hate this.

Nathaniel was on my boys list

I have an Eliza Dorothy - it's a great middle name

To continue with the biblical feel of your chosen boys names, how about:

Amaris/Amarys
Ruth
Lillian
Leah
Lois
Miriam
Martha
Adriel
Julia
Esther

Love Nathaniel James that was on my boy list! If you love Dorothy just go with it!
My Nathaniel however was a girl called Louisa Connie x

Cynthia
Blanche
Miriam

Dorothy is a fabulous name. Loads of nice nn and wasted as a middle name IMO

I'm not personally a fan of Dorothy but I can see it's a nice name.

How about Madeleine with a different nn to Maddie, like a pp said. Linny (pn like 'tinny' or like 'Lie-ny', depending on how you pn Madeleine).

Otherwise how about,
Victoria
Bethan
Florence
Polly
Coral
Jasmine

I like Dorothy.

Nit a fan of Maddie/Madeleine/Madgalene at all, tbh.

What about
Elizabeth
Victoria
Josephine
Natalia
Serena
Julia
Annabel
Daphne
Claudia
Rosalie

But seriously, Dorothy is awesome imo! :)

Dorothy is great. I like Dorothy Jane

Also Millie (Millicent but known as Millie)

Phoebe
Heidi
Arabella
Marianna
Emelda

Bethany
Abigail
Harriet
Freya
Hannah
Amelia

I like Dorothy, much more than Madeleine and Maddie

Haven't read whole thread but read your title and thought -

Maisie or Marcy/Marcie.

As you were.

Dorothy is lovely. Dottie or Dolly for short.

Surely Adriel is a boys name?! Dorothy is gorgeous. Be brave! Dorothy Susannah?

Mabel
Felicity
Agnes
Agatha

I really like Dorothy.
Dorothy Rose, Dorothy Ann, Dorothy Maya, Dorothy Anna, Dorothy Jo, Dorothy Beatrice, Dorothy Mirabelle...

Or Rose Dorothy, I suppose :)

But Dorothy is a really lovely name:)

I like Dorothy :) Also think Dorothea is wonderful. If you like Maddie how about Marnie? Or something that can be shortened to Mattie?

Dorothy is lovely!

Delilah - Dilly
Penelope - Penny
Andrea - Andie
Francesca - Frankie

Eleanor Dorothy. Dorothy Emma. Dorothy Elise. Clara Dorothy. Clara Penelope.

Clara Dorothy

That's beautiful.

Don't think I've seen a name I like this much in quite some time...

DD2 was also going to be Isaac. She's Philippa Imogen

Philippa Dorothy

Pippa Dorothy?

Any closer to deciding OP ?

I really like Madeleine (Maddie) Dorothy

Dorothy is a great name. What about Theodora? Has lots of lovely nicknames too.