James/Jimmy or Theodore/Teddy?

[DoubleMintGum]

Would be Jimmy/Teddy, day-to-day and James/Theodore, on BC. Please don't say you prefer Jamie/Theo, etc. as we have chosen the NNs we like, but he can pick when he wants to, but while he can't, we have decided on Jimmy/Teddy. Can people also not start with the "I don't get the picking NNs thing, I think that's odd, etc." thank you!

Which would you pick???

I'd go with James/Jimmy.

I like Teddy or Theo as nicknames for Theodore, but the full name makes me think of Alvin and the Chipmunks! Every time I hear it I sing the theme song in my head (sorry!)