If we like ...

[Reiltin]

We have a Harriet and a Nathaniel. We like Georgina or Elizabeth for a girl. But no ideas for a boy! We kinda like Jasper, Benjamin, and Jeremy. What else should we consider?

Sebastian or Adam?

Fratercula, good start! I do quite like Adam, though it's an ex's name. And we think Sabastian may be too gay for a kid with lesbian moms! But you're on the right track

Leonard or Dexter?

I love Jasper, haven't heard that name in ages.

I like Georgina and Jeremy.

How about...

Conrad
Alistair
Arthur
Dominic
Christopher
Edward
Frederick
Barnaby
David
Edmund
Gregory
Hector
Franklin
Laurence
Patrick
Matthew
Francis
Joseph
Marcus
Michael
Peter
Robert
Vincent
Theodore
William
Casper
Isaac
Louis
Nicholas
Seth
Thomas
Zachary
Raymond
Andrew
John
Charles
Owen
Miles
Timothy

Alexander
Oscar
Calvin

Sebastian too gay? That made me chuckle although I don't think it is,
I do love the name.
How about Alexander?

Samuel?

Dexter
Quentin
Edmund

I also like Jeremy.

Jerome
George
Joel
Grayson

Benedict
Lawrence
Jensen
Alexander
Joseph