If we like these names....

[Scoopmuckdizzy]

Barnaby
Edward
Theodore
Rafferty
Rudyard
Sebastian
Frederick
Charles
Nathaniel
Quentin

..what else would we like?

Jonathan
Rupert
Alexander
Alfred
Dominic
Benedict
Oliver
Nicholas

Gabriel
Gideon
Julius
William
Tobias

Archibald
Albert
Tristan
Rufus
Felix
Bertram
Hugo
Miles
Milo
Jasper
Fenton

Zachary
Solomon
Lawrence
Christopher
Alistair
Henry
Leopold
Caspar
Leonard
Edwin

Stanley
Clement
Wilfred
Barnabas
Claude
Edwin
Clarence
Franklin
Laurence
Gregory
Hugh
Jeremy
Kester
Joscelin
Morris
Patrick
Reid
Tobin
Alastair
Redmond
Vincent
Walter
Edmund
Alec
Hallam
Byron
Justus
Michael
Thaddeus
Wilbur

Lucas
Orson
Tristan

Timothy
Jeremiah

Marmaduke

You don't need any more please call your baby Rudyard - I love that!!! (stealing it)

Thanks so much for your suggestions everyone! We had names for our other DC picked from the beginning but really not sure with this one!

OP I basically have exactly the same question! I already have a DS with one of your names, and lots of the subsequently suggested names are also on our list, but there's just nothing that feels like the perfect fit. I love Rudyard but it doesn't go with our surname at all. Can't use Lawrence, which I love, and husband doesn't like Theodore.

Our current list:

Gwilym
Hallam
Cassian
Eldon

My favourite is Gwilym but husband unsure (and we have no Welsh heritage). I like Eldon but slightly worry that people will think we called him Elton...and Cassian is a bit poncey. Yesterday I thought I liked Hallam but have since gone off it...I still like Orson but no good nn. Aargh it's harder than you think!!

Reuben
Nate
Owen
Gabriel
Frank
Tobias
Jonas/Jonah

We also have a ds with one of your names (Quentin) and also like
Frederick
Rafferty
Dominic
Reuben
Clement

Rudyard is nice too but the short form Rudy sounds quite 'rude' .

Christopher
Dominic
Quentin
Edmund
Austin
Elliot

I also like the suggestion of Orson.

Henry
Julian
Julius
Russell
Theodore
Miles

Roland
Laurence
Jude
Percival (wow I love this!)
Sylvester
Axel

Thaddeus
Hadyn
Edmund
Cassius
Saul
Lucius

Atticus
Sylvian
Claude
Auberon
Maddox
Clarence
Lucien

Lysander
Magnus
Samson
Roscoe
Sullivan
Cyrus

Darius
Tristan