Eden or Ellen

[FlowerBellll]

Edie or Ellie?

Eden.

Ellen/Ellie

(I'm not wild about boys names on girls)

Ellen

Ellie.

Edie but short for Edith.

It's funny, I'm not that keen on Edith, so it is def between Eden or Ellen

Eden

Ellen - no contest.

Ellen or Edie not Eden or Ellie!!!!

There are ALOT of Edens here but haven't met a little Ellen

Ellen but not Ellie! Ellie is so overdone. Does Ellen really need a shortening? All the Ellens I know are just Ellen, and it's a lovely little-used name :) don't know any little Ellens.
Eden is pretty too though but more popular IME!

Eden definitely

Ellen because the Ellen I know is one of the most lovely people I know. Whereas the Eden I know is a bit of a cow. Illogical reasoning but I've had some wine.

In contrast to pancake, the only Ellen I know is a total bitch
I like Eden. Ellen is a bit drab in my opinion...and I thought that before I met the wagon.

Eden is lovely. And it's not a boy's name (I mean I know it sometimes is, but it sounds a lot more feminine to me).

Ellen is nice enough though, although I prefer Eleanor or Helena, or even Helen. Ella is pretty too, though a bit over-popular.

Ellen. Eden sounds like a tiresome teenage boy band member.

Ellen or Edie.

I love Edie short for Edith

I always think Ellen sounds like Helen with the 'h' dropped (Essex so inevitable).

I like them both. Probably Eden for me tho; never met anyone called Eden.

I love them both but for different reasons. Ellen to me is very traditional, classic and elegant whereas Eden is a bit more edgy and "out there." I agree with others though that Edie is a lovely nn for Eden but Ellie is very overdone.

Ellen. We know one (clever, nice, Queen Bee) who is 14.
Eden sounds hippy or religious. Are you hippies?

(having said that, I know a 16 year old Eden from a very "hoity-toity" UC family who chose it because of the family's roots in Eden Valley in Cumbria)

I like them both :) I think I prefer Eden, but prefer Ellie... I'd go with Eden!

Eden but edie is ruining the name.

Ellie, eden is awful

Ellen

I like Edie but not Eden