Shortlist for baby number 3

[excitedfirsttimer]

Would really appreciate some thoughts on our shortlist. It's a bit of a compromise on the girls, as the list does not contain either mine or my husbands favourites. But we have tried to do it fairly. ( my favourite is Meredith and his is Imogen but neither of us really loved the other ones top pick)

Boys
Charles Edward
Oscar David

Girls
Darcey Grace
Georgina Grace

Eliminated in the drawing up go shortlist but still not forgotten (at least by me)
Rory
Felix
Max
Robert
Tabitha
Emma
Phoebe
Isabelle
Martha
Meredith
Imogen

I like both your boys names although I prefer Rory, Felix and Max.
Georgina Grace is pretty, really dislike Darcey though.
I prefer Imogen, Meredith, Martha and Emma to both the girls names though

I like Charles Edward and Georgina Grace best. Oscar David is nice but Oscar is very popular at the moment. Not keen on Darcey at all.

I also like Max, Robert, Tabitha, Emma, Isabelle and Martha.

I like Isabel and Max.

Charles Edward and Georgina Grace.
I don't like Oscar or Darcey.

I like Robert, Emma, Phoebe and Martha.

From your boys list I prefer Charles Edward (though I actually think Edward Charles sounds great too) and Felix from your eliminated list and from your girls list I prefer Georgina Grace and Imogen and Phoebe from your eliminated list. Good luck!

I love Oscar, Georgina and Darcey. Less keen on Charles but it's nice enough.

From your 'rejects' I love Felix and Isabelle. Also like Phoebe, Martha and Imogen.

I like Darcey and Oscar...both Charlie and Oscar are v popular though so much of a muchness between them there.

I love Meredith and Rory.

Love Oscar Edward (even though that's not a choice).
Prefer Georgina to Darcey.

Actually my favourites are Felix and Tabitha - fantastic!

From your boys I actually like David as a first name best - you don't get many any more and it's simple and well known.

and it would have to be Georgina as I dislike Darcey though I prefer Meredith, not keen on Imogen.

Marissa would fit with your list or maybe Melissa fits inbetween Imogen and Meredith in style?

I only really like Edward from your boys list.

Love both girls names although I'm not mad on Grace. I'd probably choose Darcey though as I don't like George /Georgie for a girl

Oscar David is perfect!

Really like Georgina (but not Darcey) and Oscar. Meredith would've been a top choice for me for a girl - nn Merry is lovely!

Max, Martha and Tabitha also nice. Imogen I find pretentious. What about Iona as an alternative?

Charles Edward or Georgina Grace.