Brother for Chester

[MelodyYowl]

We are expecting DS2 in a couple of weeks and have no idea for a name!

I've name changed so I can give all the details! DS1 is Chester John Derrick

I quite like
Percy
Ellis
Elliot
Rudi (maybe a bit chavvy?! )

DP likes
Arthur
Albie
Wilfie

We don't really like each other's choices! And both prefer names that don't have an obvious / easy shortening, and not too common but not too weird! Any ideas?!

Frodsham?

From all of these, Elliot. Dut you need to find something you both like if possible!

Percy is the worst.

I like Elliot, Arthur is on our short list but I'm not convinced.

From all of those I'd pick Elliot, Ellis or Arthur.
Wilfie, Percy and Albie are dreadful on anyone over 2.

Suggest: Ezra, Leon, Jude, Frank or Francis, Daragh, Milo, David, Leo, Enda, Isaiah, Rohan, Pascal, Joseph.

I like your dh choices the best sorry OP but his are lovely and really go with Chester more IMO but 2/3 of his choices are on my list for dc2 so I am biased :)

Leighton?

Ellesmere? Helsby?

Thank you for your comments! I'm not 100% on any of the names so it's good to gauge opinions, we have most of the other names you've all suggested in our immediate family anyway which makes it more tricky! :)

I love Arthur. I'd also like to suggest Ford.

Don't go with something ending in an -ie sound. Its too cutsie.

Wilfred rather than Wilfie
Albert rather than Albie

You can always shorten anyway.

Same vibe as Chester:

Beckett, Buster, Everett, Otis, Winston, Laurence, Hector, Walter, Clark, Vincent, Buddy, Hugh, Woody, Kit, Franklin, Edison

Drawers

I like Elliot from your selection. I'm with you regarding not liking your DP's selection. How about

Felix
Digby
Lance

Franco you beat me to it.

Charlie
Buster
Edward
Baxter