Eden, Edie or Edith?

[HalfPintPickle]

Really stuck with which one i prefer - middle name would be Rose.

Oh I just love Edie. It sounds awful with my surname so we couldn't use it, but I think it's by far the prettiest of the three.

I like Edith best but that might be down to repeated viewings of Despicable Me.

I think of Edie as a nn of Edith so the two go together in my mind. I think of Edith as part of the early C20 vibe.

Eden has a completely different feel to me. Much more hippy/nature inspired.

I think they both sound lovely with Rose, but you end up with two very different feeling names.

If you were to have subsequent children can you see yourself calling them things like:

Violet, Mabel, Albert,

Or

Skye, River, Rowan

We have a Daisy already if that helps.

hmm, I was going to say Edie but not sure if that goes with Daisy.

Daisy is a very pretty name and you need a pretty one to match. Edith is nice but Edie is in the same style.

Eden doesn't sound right at all.

Edie. Love it and Edie Rose is beautiful

Eden or Edie, I think Edith sounds too old fashioned.

Edith with Edie as a nickname.

Eden - I absolutely love the name Eden!

Edith is a bit too old lady for me.
Eden is lovely.
Daisy is an awesome name - you have great taste.

Edith. Fabulous name

Not Eden. It's a fictitious garden, not a person's name.

I love Edie, don't like either of the others.

Edie

We know we are having a DS but if we were having a DD, she would have been called Eden, it's a beautiful name. I was very surprised by how much both parents like it too they've been brutally honest about some of our other choices.

Edith.

Eden is a boys name, or a temptation.

My favourite is definitely Eden. I don't mind Edith, wouldn't use Edie on it's own.

Love Eden.

If I ever have another it'll be
definitely on my girls list

Edie vote!

Eden Rose is nice.
Not keen on Edie or Edith tbh, they're so old lady.

I know two male Edens though.

Edith is lovely. Edie is nice as a nn (but my phone wants to autocorrect to Eddie).

Whilst Eden is really hippy and doesn't go with daisy.