Help me pick a boys name

[SweetPeaPods]

Please.
Really struggling to name ds2
What do you think of these? Any you prefer or really dislike? Ds1 is F inlay surname begins with A (5letters ).

Kai
Reuben
Lewis
William
Rory

Possibly John as mn but don't like it with Kai or Rory think they need a longer mn.

Any other suggestions welcome.

I love William and Rory.

Quite like Kai.

Dislike Reuben and Lewis.

How about;

Rufus
Alexander
Edward
Kit
Otto
Lucas

Rory

I like Lewis and Reuben.

Rory, definately!

Love Rory

I like William and Reuben.

Rory and Lewis both go really well with your other DS's name.

I think John would be perfect as a middle name for either of them.

I really like Rory and quite like William.

I dislike the others particularly Kai.

Interesting lots of mixed opinion. Why do I find this so difficult ?!

Rory goes best with your DS's name. I also like William.

William is the nicest by far especially with Bill as nn
Rory is ok
Dislike the rest

Sorry missed Lewis altogether when first reading your post that's ok too probably goes best with your ds1 name

My friend's DS2 has the same name as your DS1. Her other DS is called Max.

I like all your suggestions except Kai and Lewis.

Rory is lovely. Lewis is nice but overused ( i have one and it's all I ever hear)
I really dislike Kai. It's an alsatian's name in my opinion. Sorry.
Your son's name is lovely and Rory would compliment it.

Like William and Rory from your list (but I really like traditional names). Kai means food in Maori here in NZ, so just reminds me of that, sorry!

Kai is hideous. The Rooneys chose it. Think that would be enough to downgrade even a decent name.
The others are fine.

Didn't realise the Rooneys have a Kai.
Like Rory but really not sure on mn not sure John is long enough?

Rory

Now also considering Ruairi.
I have also liked it but think it must be growing on DH