a sister for Max

[KatAndKit]

Looking for a girls name, must not be too cutesy, fairly traditional non faddy names are what I usually prefer. I like Sophie and Isabelle but can't use either of those thanks to family and close friends. Surname ends with er so wary of names ending in a. Surname begins with r and am wanting to avoid an alliterative name.

Charlotte?

Another Charlotte here too.
Do you like Beth?
Hannah and Emily are both non faddy,lovely names.

Like Emily, that can go on the shortlist.
I like Charlotte but I'd be worried about it turning into Charlie which we don't like.
Not sure about beth. Would probably have to be Elizabeth officially which is a nice classic name but I don't love it.

Like Emily, that can go on the shortlist.
I like Charlotte but I'd be worried about it turning into Charlie which we don't like.
Not sure about beth. Would probably have to be Elizabeth officially which is a nice classic name but I don't love it.

Charlotte could be Lottie?
Alice? Eve?

Erin
Emma
Holly
Eloise
Lucy
Anna, Annie

Ruby, it definitely works ??.

Matilda was the first name that came to mind but then Matty and Max.

Or in a similar vein Maddie and Max? Madelene.

Louise
Seren
Xanthe
Ivy
Josephine
Hermione
Juliet
Violet
Darcy
Miriam
Rachel
Annabel/Annie
Beatrice
Stephanie
Pearl
Adele
Jasmine
Genevieve
Bethan(y)
Isis
Florence
Harriet
Nicole
Penelope/Penny
Anneliese
Corinne
Ruth
Willow
Skye
Katherine/Katie
Melanie
Natalie

Mmmm Alice is quite nice.that can go on the list. Not keen on Alex for a girl. Can't have any eve type names as a close friend and a cousin both have. I like Madeleine but dislike Maddie. Perhaps my problem is just that I don't like nicknames! Lucy can also go on the shortlist. Thanks for suggestions.

Milly

Jessie

Lottie
Annie

Catherine

Dinah

Elizabeth

Sarah

Rachel

Celeste

Naomi

Margaret

Susannah

Josephine

Alexis Alexa

Lily
Tess Tessa

Polly sprung to mind, but maybe fails your criteria of not being too cutesy?

Jemima
Tess(a)
Georg/ie/ia/ina

Pippa