What name goes with Polly?

[Phoebe47]

Just that really. I have a three year old daughter called Polly. I love her name and it really suits her. DD2 is due in three weeks and DH and I are really struggling to decide on a name. Names I like are Nina and Isla and DH likes both these names (prefers Nina as he thinks it is less popular than Isla) but also likes Rosie and Anna. I like his choices too but we are both unsure which of these names fits with DD1's name. Maybe that doesn't matter? Opinions welcomed.

Rosa?

.....I think they all go well with Polly.

Thanks for the replies. We are going to eliminate Isla from the list as there are three Isla's at the toddler group I go to with DD1 so seems quite popular. I want to eliminate Rosie too (I like it but don't think it fits that well with Polly) and DH has gone off it a bit. I am veering towards Nina at the moment and DH seems quite keen on the name now. He really likes Anna but we both now agree that we won't use it as we can see them getting a combined nickname of Pollyanna which would be awful.

Ruby
Lucy
Josephine/Josie
Natalie
Susanna/Susie
Rowan
Emma

Dont go for Anna - Polly Anna!

I like Nina from your names, can also suggest Erin.

Nina goes well with Polly.

Nina's a great name & goes well with Polly.

Polly is on my list but DH does not like:-( I love Polly and Anna :-) i agree Isla is becoming very popular where I am too! what about nancy? X

I've been thinking about the name Polly as it goes well with our dd's name- Alice

My friend has twin daughters called Polly and Olivia, shortened to Livvy. It's a nice combo I think!

May is lovely and sounds right with Polly. Both names I love.

No, not Anna. The Pollyanna thing would happen all the time.

Polly and Nancy
Polly and Ruth
Polly and Harriet (Hattie)
Polly and Susanna
Polly and Lucy
Polly and Flora
Polly and Edith

Maeve

What about Annie rather than Anna?

Maria
Ruby

I think Nina goes well. Love the suggestion of Rosa up the thread though, that sounds perfect with Polly.

Polly and Tess?

Agree Rosa is beautiful.
Isla and Nina are nice.
Jemima?
Jessie
Genna
Maddie? (Madeleine)
Bella (Isobel)
Sophie/Sophia
Sylvie

Polly and Dinah

I think Polly and Sylvie sound lovely together.

Nina is lovely.