which do you prefer?

[ditsydoll]

Ella Rose

Scarlett Rose

Oh that's a very tough choice for me. They are both gorgeous names.

I think for me it would be Ella Rose.

But it is a tough choice.

Tough one - both are pretty names but Ella is ubiquitous and Scarlett Rose sounds a bit twee. I would use a different middle name with Scarlett (one that isn't a noun) as Scarlett Rose sounds a bit like a description.

Thanks ladies, I can't actually think of a middle name for scarlett other than rose. Any ideas?

Scarlett rose for me.

Ella is a little overused round here, I'm afraid. Scarlett is more interesting but always makes me think of a little scar.... So I'm not that keen on either, sorry.

I think With Ella rose they same length and syllables can sound a hit choppy

What about:
Eliana rose
Elisa rose

Ella rosemary
Ella something rose

I know a few children called Scarlett rose. So it's v common combination I that bothers you

Scarlett theodora
Scarlett iris
Scarlett elsa

Scarlett does make me think Scarlett fever though! Sorry..

Prefer Scarlett too. Also Stella and Serena if you're interested in other S names. Don't think Scarlett Rose is great. How about
Scarlett Jane or Scarlett Hope?

My friend called her daughter Scarlett Jane which I think it's very nice.

X post. Great minds :)

Prefer Scarlett, but not with Rose, agree it sounds like a discription!

Alternative middle names that work with Scarlett:
Scarlett Ruth
Scarlett Grace
Scarlett Hope
Scarlett Jane
Scarlett Marie

Thanks for the advice ladies, would Scarlett Ava sound ok? Our surname is a common 3 syllable surname.

Scarlett Ava is lovely. Heaps nicer than Rose. As long as your surname doesn't start with a D!

Scarlett Rose is lovely. Ella is so popular, Scarlett is a bit different.

Scarlett Ava makes me think of Scarlett anus, 'red anus'. sorry

Why can nobody think of any middle name other than Rose these days? Get yourself a baby names book OP.

Scarlet hope is nice

Elina rose I like if thats any good for you?

I think Rose is a beautiful name. At least it's not as common as May/Mae!!

I prefer Ella despite its popularity. I really dislike Scarlett.

Aren't Scarlett and Rose both the colour red?

Ella Rose (as RG said, despite its popularity)

People can think of other middle names puff but rose is very pretty and goes with a lot. I think they are all nice names op, depends if you are planning on calling her by full name or mainly first name. I really like Scarlett, good strong female name but pretty. No need to buy a name book when you can come here for advise!

Thanks everyone. I'm still stuck on which to choose, maybe we will have to wait and see what baby looks more like when he/she arrives. I may never have to choose as we already have a boys name. I am aware that scarlett rose basically means red rose but I don't think that's the worst thing in the world and I never even really use my middle name. The only thing putting me off scarlett is if anyone shortens it to scar. X

I prefer Scarlett too - although Ella is nice.

Scarlet Iris or Scarlett Grace is lovely.

Ella Rose is beautiful.

Ella Rose
Eliza Rose
I know of 4 Scarlett's, Ella not so popular round my way
Selina Rose
Serena Rose