Opinions on.....

[mylittleprincess3455]

Brainstorming names for new baby boy - could you choose your favourite from the list.
Any other suggestions welcome.

Otto
Phineas
Arlo
Percy
Eric
Arthur

Love Otto.
Hate Phineas.It has an ugly sound.
Arlo is ok.
Percy is awful.
Eric is great.
Arthur is ok.

Eric

Love Arthur and know a few babies and toddlers with that name, think its quite 'in'. Like Arlo and Eric too.

Not keen on Phineas but only because of the Disney show Phineas and Ferb, not mad about Percy or Otto.

DS is Arlo.
It's a brilliant name.

Otto - like, and would be great with a Germanic surname
Phineas - personally I'd swerve anything that can rhyme with 'arse'
Arlo - quite like
Percy - lovely name, but also slang for penis, and the HP character isn't the nicest
Eric - a bit too old man for me, prefer Erik (again better with Germanic surname)
Arthur - ok

Love Otto, quite like Otis as well if you haven't already thought of that :)

otto and arlo are ok, nothing special though
what about
oscar
raphael
Good luck, and as long as you like a name, don't worry about our views!

Otto - awful and comical
Phineas - lovely name but would be a shame to shorten to Phin/Fin
Arlo - ok
Percy - lovley
Eric - ok
Arthur -ok

How about
Thaddeus
Milo
Sebastian
Quentin

You will never please us all!! Choose a name YOU love!!

I do agree with Scummy, I would NEVER ask MN to vote on my baby's name, But that said, since you asked:

Big fat NO: Otto, Arlo, Eric
Ok: Percy, Arthur
Kinda cool: Phineas (must use Finn as nn)

I like Eric and Arlo. Arthur is OK. The others are OTT and vaguely comical.