Sister for Lily - please help!

[TheBightyMoosh]

Please help - I am really struggling to find nice girls' names for a sister for Lily - well, I've got loads I like but not many that DP & I agree on.

We've got a few we're ok with, but none that are making us go 'wow'!

The ones we like so far are:
Nina
Sadie
Hazel
Zoe

I don't know if there's a pattern there, but can anyone think of any similar names? My general criteria is: not too popular but not 'out there', goes with Lily (so not Milly, Tilly etc), not beginning with 'L', and not a flower name.

Please help - thank you so much!

A few of our "rejects" (eg made the short list but we didn't go with it the end) include:
Freya
Katy
Isobella
Imogen
I also like Robyn, Romily, Faye.
Not sure if that's any help!
I like your list - Nina is cool because it makes me think of Nina Simone, would be cute on a baby.

Ruby, might be a bit popular though
Emmeline
Anna
Clara
Clarice
Eleanor
Esme
Madeline
Jane

How about:

Cara
Tessa
Sylvie
Robyn
Elise
Bethan
Seren
Naomi
Mia
Merryn

I know you said no flowers but how about Iris? Think it goes lovely with Lily.

I wanted Elspeth but my DH said it was too odd.

I like Nina best out of your list. On our list we had -:
Imogen
Caitlin
Eloise

Nina is good and I've only ever known one.

We liked:
Rachel
Rebecca
Meredith
Rhiannon
Tamsin
Corinna

I like Nina best of your list.

How about Lily and...

Sarah
Georgia
Cara
Bethan
Emma
Xanthe
Zara
Jennifer
Amber

I really like Nina, so chic! Sadie is nice too

I don't like Hazel or Zoe I'm afraid.

Alice
Beatrix
Cosima
Emma
Harriet
Jemima
Natasha
Olive
Paloma
Renee
Tabitha
Tamara
Vita

Meg
Maggie
Natasha
Penny
Cora
Cara
Merry

Angelica?

Ruby
Ava
Amelia
Alexis
Mylie
Jasmine
Holly
Aleesha
Saskia
Mia
Bethany
Libby

Don't google the lyrics of Ian Dury & the Blockheads (billericay Dickie) because then you would not choose Nina!

daisy

I would have loved a Scarlet or a Freya to go with our Lily , we chose Martha , was very hard to find a name me and dp agreed on

Nina is lovely

How about:

Seren
Megan
Manon
Tara
Sasha?

Seren
Georgia
Faye
Hannah
Anna
Katie
Florence
Elizabeth
Jessica
Imogen

I like Zoe out of your list.

Esme
Alice
Elsie
Maisie

My favourite on your list is Hazel, not sure if its too old-lady-ish though. I don't think any of the others go with Lily

Why not a flower name? Rosie goes well - and you do have Hazel in there.

Sophie?

Maddy?

Florence?

Nina - grown on me recently, I think it's really cute.
Sadie - like it. Also cute
Hazel - used to love it, now not so sure. It's fine.
Zoe - like it. Nothing special but a nice name.

Similar alternatives:
Nadia, Niamh, Nadine, Naomi, Nyah, Nia, Nikita
Sydney, Seren, Saffie, Sienna, Sana, Skylar
Hollie, Heidi, Honey, Hope, Hayden, Harper, Hallie
Zara, Zia, Zofia, Xantha

Other names I think go well with Lily personally:
Amelia, Alannah, Abigail, Charlotte, Erin, Francesca, Georgina, Imogen, Juliette, Matilda, Rosa, Sophia.

Cecile or Cicely

Maude
Kate
Alice
Winnie
Claire
Maisy

Annabelle
Karina
Sophia
Angel
Savana
Melodie
Hana

Marnie
Bella
Aoife
Eva