I read a message from a few years ago about someone's home made play dough going horrible and sticky when left overnight in a plastic bag. This happens to mine as well. I follow the recipe precisely, it works brilliantly and after one night in a plastic bag it's too sticky and horrid to use any more.
The replies to the previous message all said it's fine in a plastic bag.
Why is mine not fine - do you keep yours at room temperature or in the fridge? I use all the right ingredients as in the Mumsnet recipe.