Please or to access all these features

Antenatal/postnatal depression

Our Antenatal and Postnatal Depression forum is a supportive space where you can share your postnatal depression experiences.

Mum guilt and breastfeeding

7 replies

MumYouMatter · Yesterday 08:45

You might feel guilty because you didn't breastfeed, or because breastfeeding didn't work out.
The "Breast is Best" Pressure: Societal expectations, cultural narratives, and well-meaning messaging often equate breastfeeding directly with "good mothering". When it does not work out—due to a baby's tongue-tie, low milk supply, or overwhelming pain—it is easy to internalise that difficulty as a personal failure.
Shift the Focus to "Fed is Best": Formula milk provides complete, safe nutrition for your baby. Transitioning to formula or combo feeding means your baby is getting fed and thriving, which is the ultimate goal.

OP posts:
LemonDrizz · Yesterday 13:01

Fed isnt best. Fed is the bare minimum. Breastfeeding is best, of course it is. However it is really tough and there is SO little support in the NHS im not surprised so many people struggle.

But we need to be honest, there is no way formula can replicate a mothers milk, which is made exactly for their baby and continuously changes depending on what they need.

I have combi Fed, im not against formula feeding clearly, but I am sick of hearing people shot down for saying breastfeeding is best/better. It's not an attack on those who can't do it, its the truth. But everyone has a choice and if you choose to use formula then thats your choice and no one should comment on it.

People need to be made aware of the facts and not fooled by advertising rubbish. That includes being informed about how tough breastfeeding is, and just because its natural, doesn't mean its easy.

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:43

But we need to be honest, there is no way formula can replicate a mothers milk, which is made exactly for their baby and continuously changes depending on what they need.
You can't tell which children have been breast or bottle fed so can't make much difference.

DeepVioletSky · Yesterday 13:46

I breast fed mine as that what was best for us. I never once felt even slight pressure to do so.

SaffronsMadAboutMe · Yesterday 13:50

I formula fed all 3 of my now strapping adult DS.

Not once did I ever feel guilty for even a split second.

But then I've always been a woman who doesn't particularly care for other mother's opinions.

Shiningtwinklinglights · Yesterday 13:59

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:43

But we need to be honest, there is no way formula can replicate a mothers milk, which is made exactly for their baby and continuously changes depending on what they need.
You can't tell which children have been breast or bottle fed so can't make much difference.

You can’t. But at population level, science can.

When I was really struggling with breastfeeding, and I’d see these threads it made me want to cry because why was I wasting my time, putting myself through so much for what other people were saying was pointless anyway.
Breastfeeding is so hard, I sacrificed so much for it. I don’t judge any woman who decided not to do it, and there are pros and cons to both and dc can turn out lovely and healthy from both. Either is fine.
but I do find it so grating that in an attempt to make people who formula fed feel better, breastfeeding is often diminished

Chunkybabythighs · Yesterday 14:01

Breast IS best though. That can be true without shaming anyone who chooses not to.

OneNoisyScroller · Yesterday 14:04

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:43

But we need to be honest, there is no way formula can replicate a mothers milk, which is made exactly for their baby and continuously changes depending on what they need.
You can't tell which children have been breast or bottle fed so can't make much difference.

That’s not really a good point, because the effects are seen at a population level. When an adult develops IBS, for example, you’ll never be able to determine whether the lack of breastmilk may have caused it, but at a population level, you can see the effects. I think formula is incredible, and I’ve given plenty of it to my child; but that doesn’t take away from the fact that breastmilk is objectively better, scientifically speaking.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page