even the resource limitation is up for debate, there are many theories that peak oil is rubbish. But forget that. Would you volunteer your family for reduction, where does it go next? What if they decide that the reduction is not fast enough and should possibly be speeded up?
Consumption limitation will lead to impoverishment, falling trade etc. back to good old communism, back to rationing. Will the people put up with this? They're not sure, it is safer to have them do their own cheerleading as they voluntarily reduce their standard of living in the belief that they are preventing the destruction of the planet. They know that Guardian readers will swallow this, but they know that Mail readers are not going to swallow this. Look at the difference in the comment section of the BBC's article about Porritt's family reduction discussion and the Mail's equivalent article. Many BBC readers are willing to do it, they think it is a good idea. It is different with the Mail readers
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1133316/Call-child-limit-families-Governments-leading-green-adviser .html
In the Mail article it also tells us something that the BBC didn't mention
"The row came as the Roman Catholic Church, which views contraception as ?intrinsically evil?, compared environmentalism to Marxism.
A booklet by the London-based Catholic Truth Society, a charity under the patronage of Peter Smith, the Archbishop of Cardiff, said environmental lobby tended to exaggerate the threat to vindicate its calls for radical Government measures.
The book, Global Warming: How Should We Respond?, says: ?Just as Marxism advocated communism as the only solution to the world?s ills, so Greens warn us of major catastrophe if we do not adopt their calls for radical change.?
It says the ideology of the Green movement runs counter to Christian beliefs, because it sees ?mankind as just one species among many?.
The book says that population programmes targeting the 'supposedly feckless breeding' of the poor, especially in developing countries, were the result of racist and unfounded prejudices.
'Environmental campaigns which demand that that the natural world should be treated with greater respect imply that this is the only issue that matters, ignoring the plight of humanity or any spiritual values,' it said."
It looks like the Church will join the Mail in not lying down. It's not going to be easy for global capital. It will have a fight on its hands. Global capital can rely on its usual allies, the marxists and greens, and it is seeking to pull in as many young people as it can in the mistaken belief that they are fighting the big bad capitalist wolf, when all along they are helping all of the corporate and political forces on the planet.
They are peddling the same old Malthusian doctrines that we are all doomed and the way out of it is for us to exit the planet. I doubt they'll be reducing their families but they will be expecting us to reduce ours.