Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that my mum is out of order

86 replies

brook1 · 03/12/2009 19:43

Ive just rang my mum to ask if she can dig out my old gold (from an ex-boyf 20yrs ago) so that I can sell it. I cant remember exactly what there is but I definitely recall a gate bracelet.

Anyway, she hesitates and tells me that she sold the bracelet a few months ago. I asked her why she had done that because it wasnt hers to sell. She tells me she didnt think I'd mind because it was broken. Now I know she sold some jewellery a few months ago because she told me how many hundreds of pounds she got for it. I didnt think to ask if any of it was mine. And to be honest, I wouldnt be surprised if my gate bracelet wasnt the only thing of mine that she sold.

My mum has no money worries, I know that for a fact, and my dad doesnt bat an eyelid with what she spends. Although I am not broke, the money would have been nice for xmas.

I know she felt embarrassed on the phone. I asked her to look in my old box for the jewellery & she did this and then rang me back to tell me there were a few things there. I said I would call round in the next few days to collect.

Now, I think she is totally out of order. But she is being arsey with me because I have pulled her up about it. She even asked how I could be so bothered after all that she does for my DC. Admittedly, she buys things for my DC and has given me some money towards their xmas clothes, but I think she is missing the point. I dont think the fact that she helps us out makes it ok for her to have a reward from the sale of my gold jewellery behind my back. If she had sold it and then said "Oh I bought the DC this with the money from your bracelet" then that would be different.

Even if she had sold it without asking I would have thought she would have given the money to my DC. Its not really about the money, its about what she has done, and why?? for heavens sake.

OP posts:
frogetyfrog · 04/12/2009 19:54

You had £2000 of your own money earlier in the year for a holiday. Doesnt sound like you are short to me (goes off wishing she had even £1000 for a family holiday).

brook1 · 04/12/2009 19:58

Well we arent short, but thats not really the point is it?

OP posts:
frogetyfrog · 04/12/2009 20:01

But surely it is. You are not short. She gives you thousands of pounds, buys clothes for the kids etc etc. And you begrudge her a few pounds of gold money when she obviously had a silly moment or needed to sell. It certainly doesnt sound like she would do it maliciously or purposely steal from you as she gives you loads of money anyway. So why resent her her few quid for a mistake or to help her out.

optimistletoemumma · 04/12/2009 20:25

I don't think YABU.

If she wanted you to take your stuff out of her house she could have asked you to take it. As it is your bracelet she should have asked you first before selling it. She is being defensive because she knows she is in the wrong. Have you asked her why she thought she could sell it without saying anything?

I would have another go at sitting down and asking her to see the principle of the thing.I personally wouldn't ask her for the money as it's done now.

If she can't see it from your point of view (which I would be surprised at once she has calmed down) you'll have to put it down to experience. Don't let it ruin your relationship. Some parents don't want to ever admit to being in the wrong as they feel it somehow makes them less of a parent ( I have this all the time with my Dad)

Hope you're feeling a bit better about this....

brook1 · 04/12/2009 20:26

So what you are saying really is that the fact that she has been so generous with her money means it is fine what she has done. Whereas if she hadnt been so generous to us then she would have been out of order.

I dont resent my mum a few quid, I resent what she has done behind my back. It wasnt her bracelet.

OP posts:
brook1 · 04/12/2009 20:30

Optimistletoemumma - thanks. I have no intention of letting this ruin our relationship. And I have no intention of asking for the money.

I will however, ask her why she did it. FWIW I wont even take the money if she offers it to me. This whole thing is not about the money.

I am beginning to wonder if it is her age, she's only mid 60s but I think she's turning into my nan, god rest her soul.

OP posts:
frogetyfrog · 04/12/2009 20:33

No, what I am saying is look behind what she has done as it appears totally out of character. Why has she done it. The fact that she gives you so much could be used to justify it in your mind to aid forgiveness, not justify it to her. Personally even if she wasnt generous, I would still think it was a silly mistake or done through need. After 30 years or so (presume you are in your 30s) of being her daughter, you would know if she is a malicious sort or would steal from you willingly. Given you seem close I presume that is not the case. Therefore there is more to it which deserves forgiveness and support if there is a problem. I do know mums who would willingly take what isnt theirs - indeed my own mother threw all my stuff away while I was at uni! That was through nastiness and was in character. However, I did forgive her and have maintained a loving relationship with her - she wasnt well as I later found out.

kinnies · 04/12/2009 20:46

So if I do some nice stuff for people then I can sell their unwanted gold and pocket the money?

I wouldnt row with your mum over this although you are rightfully miffed by it.
I'll also bet that she will make it up to you and feels bad. She prob didnt think about it before she did it and now feels guilty (& too bloody right!!)

All the posters that think the mums NBU would you steal from someone? family?

frogetyfrog · 04/12/2009 21:37

Its not stealing if its left in our house for 20 years! Broken! And unwanted. And its not stealing if I have given the person huge amounts of money (thousands) over the years, or if I use it to get myself out of trouble bearing in mind I have housed it for 20 years. Even if it was stealing (and I dont think it is), I would happily let my mum steal from me in this way if it helped her out. Or if she made an error of judgement. Especially if it was out of character and therefore indicated a bigger issue or a genuine mistake.

brook1 · 04/12/2009 22:10

Frogety, it is starting to irritate me now that you keep suggesting that my mum used the money to get herself out of trouble.

Why you think she has money troubles is beyond me, I have already said that my parents have no money troubles. And my mum has access to any amount of money each week that she needs. My dad wouldnt have a clue what she takes out of the bank. And I know there is plenty in there because they give me their bank books to look after when they are on hol. Trust me, frogety, there are no money problems involved in this.

OP posts:
frogetyfrog · 04/12/2009 23:12

Fine there are no problems at all. You obviously have a fantastic relationship with your mum and she has absolutely no reason to have taken your bracelet and sold it when she knew it belonged to you. But, oh yes. Thats exactly what she did. For no apparent reason. Anyway, am off to bed. Goodnight and please forgive your mum. She sounds lovely and you seem very fortunate to have her.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page