Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to complain about my DD's punishment at school

82 replies

magentadreamer · 26/11/2009 23:19

My DD is in yr8, not a known trouble maker and most of her teachers state she is a hard working quiet child.DD doesn't push the uniform rules or any other school rules to the limit and has yet to get the "teen attitude". She also knows I'd be livid with her should she back chat teachers etc.

DD unfortunately left both her keys and her school shoes at her Dad's yesterday and as he'd already gone to work this morning I was unable to drop her off there to get her school shoes. I told Dd to wear a her plain black trainers instead and wrote a note in her planner explaining why she was wearing a banned item of footwear. Dd was told at the Breakfast club she would have to go see her Head of Year regarding her trainers, the teacher in charge didn't want to see my note nor did the Head of year. Dd after explaining I was at work and she couldn't get her shoes was sent to the school isolation unit because she was wearing a pair of black trainers! DD did ask if she could wear the pumps she has for drama but since they were grey she was told she couldn't - these pumps aren't a uniform item and were bought at the bequest of the drama teacher. At no point was I contacted regarding her being put into the isolation unit. If I had I'd have left work driven the 20 mile round trip to get her Dad's house keys and retrived her school shoes so she could have attended lessons.

I could understand this punishment if she was always in trouble but she isn't. I'd have even supported the school if she was forever flouting school rules but she's the kind of child who goes to school, does what she is asked and avoids any kind of trouble by behaving herself. I'm not one of those Mums who thinks their Dc is an angel who can do know wrong.

I have written a letter to school tonight and her Dad is going to ring first thing but I now feel like going into school tomorrow and camping out till someone will explain why my Dd was put into the isolation unit for wearing a pair of plain non flashy trainers!

OP posts:
LittleAngelicRose · 28/11/2009 14:28

Schools are fully aware of what every child is like, whether they are known troublemakers, whether the parents give a damn or not, and the home situation of each. Yes rules have to be respected, but in a case where a mistake has been made and can't be put right, every school is in a position to be reasonable. What should you have done, kept her off? "Sorry my daughter won't be in school she hasn't got the right pair of shoes today". Like THAT would go down well. Try it next time, ring them beforehand and ask what you should do. And make sure you take them to task. Sometimes they can be made to see reason.

hocuspontas · 28/11/2009 14:33

I don't have a problem with school rules as long as all the children (and parents) are aware of them. What I DO have a problem with is the wishy-washy way that they are upheld.

If the rule is no make-up then anyone caught wearing make-up needs to suffer the consequences. Not have half a dozen teachers upholding the rules and the rest not bothering. Dd2(14) wears make-up "because everyone does". If ever she's been made to remove it at school she comes home all indignant that her friends in other classes haven't. Although I have no sympathy for her I do think it's a bit ridiculous that on any day, 10 girls are told to remove their make-up but 200 aren't.

Either have the rule or don't!

The one rule that I have a REAL problem with at this school is that girls are not allowed to wear tights under their socks during the winter! I have asked for the reasoning behind this and have yet to hear a reasonable answer. It's either socks or tights. WHY??? WHY???

But in answer to the op I would be annoyed.
She came in with a good reason and it was a one-off

nickelbabe · 28/11/2009 15:45

hocus: what about socks under the tights? then noone will be any the wiser.

SolidGoldBangers · 28/11/2009 18:20

I don't have much of a problem with approximate uniform for schools (school jumper, grey/black trousers/skirt, no high heels or open sandals (except for medical reasons eg foot with dressing/plaster cast/swelling that makes normal footwear impossible). It's the emphasis on pissy little details and the fuss made over infringements that would make me think a school had the wrong ethos.

Heated · 28/11/2009 18:34

It's an OTT reaction. My school are traditional and strict on uniform but would make an allowance until the weekend to have shoes replaced, as long as it was accompanied by a letter or phone call and it wasn't a repeat excuse.

ravenAK · 28/11/2009 20:32

Cor, is this still going? Thought I'd bored everyone to a standstill last night...

Sorry I pissed you off, Vicar. I still don't quite see how I wasn't quoting you - maybe I somehow misinterpreted you.

Anyway, I think there's a consensus that the school was way OTT.

wizbitwaffle · 28/11/2009 22:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

New posts on this thread. Refresh page