Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be utterly devastated that my middle aged, middle class sister has just revealed to me

138 replies

shockedsister · 07/07/2009 16:25

... that she was held for two nights in a police cell four years ago, on suspicion of the attempted murder of ex DP? I can't believe that she has carried this secret on her own and not told anyone in our family until last night.

She's now in pieces since discovering that a new change in the law (brought in in response to the Soham murders) means that this charge will appear on her CRB disclosure - and she's a teacher who is totally devoted to her work.........

Apparently the incident happened a year after they got together, after he discovered she was planning to leave him. The family knew she'd been the victim of domestic violence, as the police had been called to her flat several times in the first few months of their relationship. He'd broken her nose and pulled clumps of her hair out, threatened to burn her flat down. I also suspect that he sexually abused her, but I haven't had the courage to ask her. We were desperate for her to leave him but instead they moved away to the coast and things seemed to go quiet. She told us that he'd got counselling and was determined not to do it again.

What I now know is that although he'd stopped physically abusing her he'd carried on bullying her in other ways, and she'd decided to leave. When he found out he locked her in their flat and launched a sustained attack on her through the night. She insists that he got stabbed by accident, that the knife was stuffed down the side of the sofa - she was intending to open the door with it when he was asleep, and that it injured him in the middle of the night when he jumped over the back of the sofa, head butted her and bit her face.

I'm not sure what to believe. I wouldn?t blame her if she had stabbed him. He?s a horrible, horrible man, with a history of abusing women (though no charges or convictions - which means he can continue to practice as a lawyer). His ex wife used to sleep with a claw hammer under the pillow, and when she finished the relationship she had to leave her house under police escort.

After what happened with my sister he ended up in intensive care for 3 days but refused to bring charges against her. The police documented her injuries and wanted her to bring charges against him for assault but she also refused.

Apparently he used this incident to stop her leaving him for the next four years, while he spent his way through the equity of her flat which she?d sold when they?d moved away from London. He told her that if she left him he?d tell my elderly parents (who my sister adores) that she?d been arrested for attempted murder.

Over those four years she turned from a slim, beautiful, successful woman of independent means (she was earning 40K a year as a senior teacher in London and owned her own flat), into an overweight drinker with terrible low self-esteem.

She did finally work up the strength to leave him last year, and he didn?t tell my parents about what had happened. He didn?t care any more ? he?d used her up and lost interest.

But my poor sister has carried this burden on her own all this time. And now she is terrified her career as a teacher ? the only thing in her life which she still has which is important to her can?t continue.

Sorry for the long post and I?m not sure what response I?m looking for. I just feel so sad that my sister has carried this worry on her own all this time.

OP posts:
mehimandthekids · 08/07/2009 20:24

Here Here.
I came acroos this post last night and was disgusted at some of the posts. Jokes, jibes and general b*tchyness.
There are plenty of other threads that call for a joke and a poke.
Sometimes just understanding and compassion go along way.

RumourOfAHurricane · 08/07/2009 21:11

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Momdeguerre · 08/07/2009 21:35

I think it is unfair to say that Shines questions regarding this story were uncompassionate. The OP says she does not know whether to believe her sister and I certainly am dubious as to the validity of the version of events that her sister has told her. Different frces work in different ways but some ofences are so serious, particularly those associated with domestic abuse, that certainly find it hard to believe that her sister has told her an accurate version of events.

I feel really sorry for the OP - she is obviously distressed but I don't think it is wrong to suggest that she may have been misled.

RumourOfAHurricane · 08/07/2009 22:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Momdeguerre · 08/07/2009 22:08

It sounds terrible but I can't see any how the above circs would not result in a remmand/charge? Appreciate she may well be the victim of some horrific DA but, as I am sure you know, she would still be dealt with - especially if it was att.murder - very least they would have charged s.18 or s.20 which would remove the need to prove intention to kill???

tennisaddict · 08/07/2009 22:11

I do not think that shiney raised a question about the validity of the story in a nasty way

she was quite kind about it, and only meant "are you sure you have the full story, or is there more to it?"

she wasn't the only one to do that either, so not sure why she has been singled out

RumourOfAHurricane · 08/07/2009 22:15

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

RumourOfAHurricane · 08/07/2009 22:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

tennisaddict · 08/07/2009 22:20

exactly, just not sure why you were singled out

Momdeguerre · 08/07/2009 22:21

It does not make you self righteous imo and you don't come across that way.

Anyway, if you are then so am I.

ilovemydogandmrobama · 08/07/2009 22:24

Haven't read full thread, but what are the changes to the CRB check? Enhanced disclosure has always meant that any entries, whether charged or not, would be on the record including, 'informal chats.' It's all relevant if one is going to be working with children.

Even if there had been changes, post Soham? I don't know what this means. And that was something like 15 years ago

RumourOfAHurricane · 08/07/2009 22:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

tennisaddict · 09/07/2009 07:00

shiney, tis AnyF by the way

New posts on this thread. Refresh page