Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be fed up with people saying " how do you cope, I couldn't you must be really special"

270 replies

2shoestrodonalltheeggs · 11/04/2009 17:26

ok so dd is severley disabled but that doesn't make me specail, and what am I suppsed to do......not cope!!!

OP posts:
busybeingmum · 11/04/2009 18:35

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

chegirl · 11/04/2009 18:37

onthepier burden? shame? How do you keep your hands off your FIL?

I am glad to hear your DS is coming on so lovely. Shame his granddad isnt eh?

swampster · 11/04/2009 18:40

I think people often want to open a conversation but aren't sure how to broach it. Without offending you. And they genuinely do think you are amazing. And wonder how they would cope if it was them in your situation. Someone posted this to group I'm on. I think it says it much better than I could ever hope to.

The Mother at the Swings

by Vicki Forman

It's a Sunday afternoon. My nine-year-old daughter Josie is at home drawing
cartoons with my husband and I'm swinging my six-year-old son Evan at the
park. Evan laughs and giggles and with each wide arc of the swing, his smile
grows ever larger. The mother next to me smiles herself and says, "Boy, he
really loves that, doesn't he? I mean, kids just love to swing, don't they?"

Yes, I think, kids do love to swing. But the reason my son loves to swing
isn't the same reason her daughter, in the swing next to us, loves to swing.
My son loves to swing because he is blind and non-verbal, because he has
what is termed "sensory integration dysfunction" and requires enhanced
"vestibular input." Swinging gives my son the kind of stimulation other
kids, those who can see and talk and run and ride a bike, get by simply
being and doing.

And, yes, he also loves to swing because all children love to swing.

I smile back at this mother and I swing Evan higher and he laughs louder,
his squeals of delight growing bigger with every push.

"He really loves to go high," the mother at the swings says. "He's not
afraid at all."

"He's not afraid because he can't see," I say. "He has no idea how high he's
swinging."

"Well, he must have other ways of knowing," she says. "Because he definitely
loves it."

My son was born at twenty-three weeks gestation, weighing only a pound. His
twin sister died four days after birth when we removed her from life
support. Evan was hospitalized for six months and came home blind, with
feeding difficulties, chronic lung disease and global developmental delays.
Soon after that, he developed a serious seizure disorder and was on
medication until his fourth birthday. He did not walk until he was five,
still does not eat anything other than pureed baby food and formula from a
cup, and has only a word or two variations on "muh muh" which he uses
indiscriminately for "more" or "mama" or "open."

I have watched my friends' newborns become toddlers and school-age children
who can walk and laugh and talk and read, all while my son continues to
function at the level of a two-year-old.

And yes, he has a beautiful laugh and a beautiful smile which grow only
louder and wider on the swings.

When Evan was still in the hospital, a social worker gave us a handout, a
road map for the potential reactions of friends and family members to our
new status as parents of a super preemie. Potential support people came
divided, according to the handouts, into the following categories: the
rocks, the wanna-be-theres, and the gingerbread men. It warned us that
people we might think were "rocks" could unexpectedly turn out to be
"gingerbread men." Just like the story, they run, run as fast as they can
from you when they hear of your baby's birth.

I quickly found that the guide was right, that I was supported by only one
or two rocks, and that the rest of my friends and family members had become
gingerbread men. As Evan's disabilities became more obvious, after he left
the hospital and in the time that followed, I found new rocks and said
goodbye to the gingerbread men. And I found a new category for the
characters in the social worker's handout: the mother at the swings.

The mother at the swings wants to know. It's why she makes her observations,
and why she pretends there is nothing different, nothing dissimilar about
her child and mine. All kids love to swing.

The mother at the swings would like for me to tell her what it's like, how
my son is different, and how he is the same. She wants to know about the
cane he uses, and the challenges of having a non-verbal child, and how I
manage to understand my son and communicate.

She'd like to ask, What does his future look like? And How are you with all
this?

She wants to know but she doesn't know how to ask. And so she tells me that
all kids love to swing.

It has taken me years to know what to say to the mother at the swings, and
how to say it. To reveal the truth, graciously. To let her in and help her
understand. To tell her that yes, all children love to swing, and my son
loves to swing and the reasons are both the same and different. That it's
hard to watch her daughter, with her indelible eye contact and winning
smile, and not mourn for what my son can't do. That some days my grief over
my son is stronger than my love.

It has taken me even longer to appreciate the mother at the swings, to know
that she and I have more in common than I once thought. To know that her
curiosity is a mother's curiosity, one borne out of love and tenderness and
a desire to understand a child, my son, one who happens to be different.
That she will listen and sympathize when I offer my observations. That her
compassion and thoughtfulness mean she will take the knowledge I share and
use it to understand other mothers like myself, some of whom could be her
neighbor, her cousin, her sister, her friend. And, finally, that she wants
to know so that she can teach her own child, who also loves to swing, how to
embrace and treasure what makes us all different. And the same.

Vicki Forman teaches creative writing at the University of Southern
California. Her work has been nominated for a Pushcart and has appeared in
the Seneca Review and the Santa Monica
Review , as well as the anthologies, Love
You to
Pieces: Creative Writers on Raising a Child With Special Needs, This
Day:
Dairies From American Women, The
Spirit
of Pregnancy and Literary
Mama:
Reading for the Maternally Inclined. She lives in Southern California with
her husband and two children, one of whom is multiply-disabled. You can
contact her at vickiforman(@)gmail.com or visit her
blog.

busybeingmum · 11/04/2009 18:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

SugarSkyHigh · 11/04/2009 18:50

YANBU

i have had this said to me a couple of times by one particular [very priveledged] friend. At the time I couldnnt put my finger on why it annoyed me so much. I don't think she meant anything by it but I do remember saying to her "I don't have any choice, I HAVE to do it." She's just never been tested, that's all.

She has also said "yes, I've been so lucky" (because she married a rich man). I did actually say "are you saying I'm unlucky then? I feel quite lucky too".

2shoes YANBU - you are just doing what any loving mother would do - would HAVE to do

SugarSkyHigh · 11/04/2009 18:55

Reflecting further, I almost feel there's a kind of thinly disguised smugness to their attitude. Unlike the mother at the swings, swampster, who genuinely wants to reach out

Biscuits4cheese · 11/04/2009 19:03

Completely understand why those comments to Chegirl are grating (to say the least).
WRT OP's gripes I think this is more to do with your own outlook and agree completely with Bitoffunnybunny.

verygreenlawn · 11/04/2009 19:04

chegirl, sorry to hear of your DD's death. I think several people on here have correctly identified the problem with "I don't know how you do it" - it assumes a choice. When one of my little boys (twins) was stillborn, lots of people said "aren't you doing well!" because I didn't fall to pieces - but I had no choice, I had a newborn to look after. Then when I was ready to talk, ready for the support, suddenly everyone had melted away and forgotten what had happened - or they didn't want to raise it for fear of upsetting me. Like it wasn't on my mind all the time anyway!

I also had a lot of "aren't you brave" for not terminating the life of my surviving son. Again, I felt it wasn't a choice - it was just the right thing for me. My MIL was horrified by that choice, and often says how "cruel" it is to bring children with disabilities into the world, and how we were "lucky" that ds1 survived everything that happened unscathed. I often wonder how she would've coped with the disabilities he was "meant" to have suffered - I actually think she would've been very ashamed of him.

Having said all of that, I would still rather have an awkward,clumsy comment from someone than have the situation completely ignored. I really identify with what Swampster has posted - I think at heart most people really do want to help, they want to identify with you - it just doesn't come out right. All part of being human I'm afraid - I've learned so so much from what happened to me, but would never dare to presume I "know" how someone else would feel even in a similar situation.

swampster · 11/04/2009 19:04

I just think people are often very clumsy when they try to reach out.

Biscuits4cheese · 11/04/2009 19:09

We all, at some points, say the wrong thing.
We can all be clumsy and inappropriate because we are human and fallible.
It has to be pretty draining to be determined to see perfectly normal, if sometimes irritating, interactions in such negative terms.

Tryharder · 11/04/2009 19:12

I said something similar the other day when i met a women with 7 children. And when i met a woman with triplets....

swampster · 11/04/2009 19:14

Would an appropriate response be: "Some are born special, some have specialness thrust upon them"?

onagar · 11/04/2009 19:15

It's an attempt to be friendly/nice to you, but clearly wasted.

slightlycrumpled · 11/04/2009 19:19

Perhaps biscuits it is more draining to have to try and see it as a positive if it happens so frequently.

I would agree that at times everyone is guilty of saying the wrong thing however. Usually we learn from the experience and try very hard not to say it again.

Biscuits4cheese · 11/04/2009 19:25

Meh.
I guess my point is that some people wouldn't find it an effort to see the comment as positive. Most, i imagine, would at least recognise the intention as positive.
Some clearly dont.
it's clearly in the eye of the beholder and i know how i'd prefer to view other people.

SugarSkyHigh · 11/04/2009 19:26

They are indeed

slightlycrumpled · 11/04/2009 19:27

Oh I do agree with you in a way, it is much nicer to see the good in people. Sometimes I just want to stick two fingers up though!

isittooearlyforgin · 11/04/2009 19:29

YANBU I really would not like to offend anybody but think I probably might have unintentionally. In the same way that I would chat to any mother i met at a toddler group, or in the park I would try and find common ground or some kind of empathy. If i thought this was upsetting for a parent, then the alternative would be not to chat to a parent, which i think offend more, to be ignored.

chegirl · 11/04/2009 19:33

I can see both sides of this. I can understand why some may think the OP is being over sensitive or determined to see the worst. But try and imagine it happening all the time, every day, every time you venture out with your child. You are going about your normal daily business and are constantly being reminded that you are not 'normal'. You could be having lunch with your kid and be told by three differnt people how flippin marvy you are.

You are no longer having lunch with your kid, you are now managing to cope with your little burden - how wonderful.

I do agree that possibly the majority of those who say these things are trying to be nice. Thats why most parents of kids with SN dont snap and shout at them. Usually its a nod and a half smile. So surely its ok for the OP to have a bit of a moan on here and say how she feels about being told she is special?

katiestar · 11/04/2009 19:33

Well I can see how it is annoying for you to hear it time and time again.
But people are just trying to be friendly.unfortunately this thread could well turn many well- meaning people who could potentially become 'rocks', into gingerbreadmen.

vjg13 · 11/04/2009 19:38

My daughter has severe learning difficulties but I have never had that comment so I musn't be very special!

I think the majority of people have the capacity to cope with all kinds of things but not the confidence or insight to realize it.

kettlechip · 11/04/2009 19:43

It's so difficult and I don't think YABU as I appreciate it must be wearing to constantly be told you're saintly for doing what you need to for your dc's. I think there is a massive fear of saying the wrong thing, which ironically makes us say the wrong things more. I think it depends on the tone of how these things are said, but generally I'd rather assume the intentions are good. I think they usually are.

Ds has language disorder/ HFA, and his speech is very noticeably behind for his age (3.8)- it doesn't help that he's tall and looks older than he is. I'm happy for people to talk to me about it, the vast majority have been really receptive when I've explained his condition.

kettlechip · 11/04/2009 19:45

Love the mother at the swings story btw.. that sums it up perfectly imo.

warthog · 11/04/2009 19:50

people just don't know what to say, so they try and say the first what-they-think-is-positive thing that comes to mind.

what would you like them to say?

vjg13 · 11/04/2009 19:50

Yes, I like the mother at the swings thing too and I HATE the Amsterdam/ Italy one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread