Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the slebs on most of comic relief are a bunch of self promoting arseholes?

160 replies

ssd · 13/03/2009 08:13

they are just doing it to get on the telly - AGAIN

that lot on the apprentice last night
Jonathon Ross
Carol Voderman etc etc

is there anything they wouldn't do?

bet most of them give hee haw to charity the rest of the year

wish there was another way to put forward this cause without making it an ego trip for all the eegits

OP posts:
VanillaPumpkin · 14/03/2009 21:38

How depressing for you to be living with such a cynical, miserly view of life.
I feel sorry for you.

I have enjoyed all the Comic Relief stuff I have seen.
It has been incredibly effective to have raised over £57 MILLION in the middle of a recession. Bloody good job done if you ask me.
I fail to see that you and I 'Joe Bloggs' on the street could have come close to raising a fraction of that amount. It needs the profile the celebrities bring. That is the way it has always been.

Davina and Claudia dancing to what ever that Number 1 song was on Top of the Pops made my night Xmas Smile.

As I said it must be so depressing being such a cynic, unable to see the good in people.

2shoes · 14/03/2009 21:39

I loved the dancing show

HerBeatitudeLittleBella · 14/03/2009 23:38

"they are in it foir self promotion, plain and simple"

Really? are you that well acquainted with them? Do you know for a fact that the fearsomely irritating Ms Cotton, Cole et al went to those hospitals, watched those babies having convulsions and thought "ah, this'll be good for my profile"?

Do you honestly believe that they are so different from the rest of us? Because if so, that's kind of like the different side of the coin to thinking that they're somehow more beautiful, more blessed, more charmed than the rest of us. They're not. They're just people, just like us, some of them will be arseholes, some of them will be exceptionally nice. Unless they are psychopaths, most of them will have been traumatised and moved by watching babies die, FFS. Fearne C may have fainted because she needed a good meal, or because watching a baby die is an unbelievably distressing, traumatising experience for any human being, particularly one from the cossetted West, to witness. Do you people who say they are only in it for self-promotion, honestly believe that these slebs are made of such different DNA to us, that they would respond differently to the way we would?

Oh and btw, it seems to me that people like Cheryl Cole have such a positive press, that she really doesn't need to put herself through the shit of climbing a mountain, to raise her profile. She could easily have simply offered to sing one of those mediocre songs she goes in for, for free, and she would have got rounds of applause. Her paparazzi appeal is high enough right now, not to need to climb a mountain. Same for that Take That bloke.

BecauseImWorthIt · 15/03/2009 00:12

Great post, HBLB.

Divineintervention · 15/03/2009 07:25

Great post HBLB

cocolepew · 15/03/2009 08:58

Well said HBLB. The slebs help raise the profile of Comic Relief, it helps get people behind it and to join in. My DD is 11 and I wouldn't let her watch some of the footage, it's just too disturbing. But I heard her and her 2 friends talking about CR and they had taken a lot on board.

I would have pushed Cheryl Cole off the mountain though.

57 million pounds who really cares if they are self promoting?

QuantitativeMeasure · 15/03/2009 09:02

I want to see some footage of Davina and Cladia danicing to Flo-Rida, was it funny??

I absolutely howled at French & Saunders and Joanna Lumley doing Mamma Mia. Briliant!

Wigglesworth · 15/03/2009 10:22

Good on them for doing the mountain climb etc and they did raise loads of money BUT, all Chris Moyles went on about on his radio show is how hard it was for HIM and how difficult HE found it, which I am sure it was. He hardly mentioned the reason why he was doing it which surely is the whole point for walking up the mountain in the first place.

chegirl · 15/03/2009 12:31

I dont object to comic relief etc. They are all fun and do raise money which I do not feel would be otherwise raised. They remind people of what is going on in the world and at that moment make them reach in their pockets.

In this total sleb crazed culture they could also ligitimise caring if you see what I mean. Its seems that some will only think somthing is ok if they have had it ok'd by OK magazine.

But I do question the whol mountain climbing thing. It must have cost a lot of money to put on.

I am still pissed off about that woman kissing MY David Tennent though.

NotPlayingAnyMore · 15/03/2009 12:52

"an excuse for essentially humourous, self-righteous, stupid people to annoy and inconvenience others (barging into workplaces wearing red noses and rattling collecting buckets, blocking the traffic by pushing a bath of baked beans with a wanker in it up the road, etc) cos it's 'all for charidee.'"

That's the point. It is inconvenient for much the Western world to think about this so doing this raises a lot from people who wouldn't normally take the initiative to donate.

I'm not saying that we should completely overlook the controversy of who does what. I personally think it would've been more of a challenge for Jonathan Ross to get up Kilimanjaro than sitting on his arse for most of the Apprentice but then again, he led the presentation and partly co-hosted the night because that's where his strengths are.

My son was born around the time of Comic Relief and although I wasn't in the best of financial situations, I felt that I should go out of my way to donate for someone even less fortunate than himself. This year, he was old enough to donate money himself through buying a Red Nose, paying to wear red to school and the cherry bakewells cooked by parents, etc. so I feel that the lesson of giving to charity is a very worthwhile tradition to pass on to our children

New posts on this thread. Refresh page