I am rather that this has turned into any sort of debate, let alone a heated one. I killed my dog yesterday, this morning we are best friends again - although i did have to laugh when he was on the bed this morning and DD came in and jumped on him - perhaps she didn't appreciate her wake up call yesterday either - lol, he jumped out of his skin. Blimey oh riley i can't believe anyone actually has taken this thread seriously.
Korma, i would never train a dog with fear i totally agree with you. I was being flippant when i said about battering my rottie and kind of trying to inflame the deabate a little. The thing is you can't be namby pamby with a dog who thinks its OK to launch himself at passers by, so one day when he did this, i had to make it clear that this wasn't acceptable - definately not a situation for shaking a coke tin full of stones or clicking a clicker. I very much did get more than i bargained for with that dog - he came to me with serious aggression issues, but he ended up a beautiful loving family dog who i finally didn't have to take out with a muzzle on. I am very proud of how things worked out with Yazz, i am certainly happy to admit that he had a few smacks but definately not done out of cruelty and i probably whacked him a bloody site harder whenever we were messing around.
So, can i just clarify - i have NEVER hit my dog for pissing in my bed. When we came home and our rottie had literally decorated the entire bathroom with shit (he had locked himself in there and clearly upset himself) he did not get even told off, in fact i made a fuss of him and told him it was OK it wasn't his fault that his dopey owners left the bathroom door open and then he locked himself in it - honestly, i have never seen so much shit in my life (and as an ex vet nurse ive seen quite a bit!) it was everywhere, all over the floor, all up the walls, in the bath (i still don't know how he managed that).
Nekabu - no one on this thread, really thinks that their dogs do slimy poos to piss them off (least of all jooly!!!) but it just feels like it sometimes!
What i find really interesting is that people are up in arms because i wanted to murder my dog. They took me seriously? Surely not? But when i mentioned that i might murder DP too, eveyone was like, yeah, put the fucker in a stew!!!
over sentimentality with animals winds me up - i have seen more animals neglected if that is the right word, because of owner ignorance rathr than cruelty. So their negligence isn't deliberate, but it equals the same result for the animal.
Korma - i do know what you mean about the outside thing, i was thinking about that last night - my two rabbits had the thickest coats around and were tough as old boots - had they been indoor rabbits and i put them out on a cold night, i daresay they would have popped their clogs.