DS 9 Wants a TV in his bedroom.

[essexgel]

'All my friends have one!. DS 1 & 2 watch tv downstairs. I can keep an eye on what they watch and don't want them disappearing upstairs?AIBU?

yanbu

Yanbu, I think once you start giving into that it is the end of family life, in the sense that it only takes two people to want to watch differnt things on tv to get the family scatterd all over the house in differnt bedrooms.

I am totally opposed to Tv in Dcs bedrooms for the above reason but also because I think that up to a certain age TV has to be "filterd" for DCs. I do not mean by that that everything needs censoring, but I would rather watch TV with my Dcs sometimes, to be able to discuss some of the issues discussed/shown in programms ( even in programms direcly aimed at children sometimes) that not knowing what they are watching.

I am very old fashion maybe but no amount of my DCs asking for a tV in their room would make me change my mind.

YANBU. We don't do TV in bedrooms - there is one set in the living room that everyone shares. DD1 is 11 and I would say very few of her friends have TV in bedrooms so don't fall for the 'all my friends' line, IME it is usually not true.

YANBU - I do agree with you that you are the adult and should be there supervising the TV programmes ...

Also, I read somewhere that one of the things to cure insomnia was to take the TV out of the bedroom !!

yanbu.totally agree.

ive only just got one in my room and im 30(its for in evening if dh is watching bullcocks).

also when they are 18 you need an incentive to get them to leave hom

so you can say 'well you can have a tV in your room wheh you have your own place'

All my DC's friends do have TVs in their bedrooms, I know this for a fact, but I absolutely refuse.
YANBU- if you don't like it don't get swayed.

home

Very true, Compo.

Somehow , hen I tried that argument with my mum, the standard 'well, if they all jumped into the fire, would you?' counter argument always used to be wheeled out!

My eldest did for a while (when she was little) it was a nightmare, she wouldn't sleep, would insist on watching unsuitable c*ap etc. When we moved house it went and has never been replaced. It is so hard to get them to do other things without them going upstairs after school and not coming down again!

Also - when they are teenagers, they will spend almost all their time in their room anyway, at leaset if they have to come down to watch tv, you will see them once or twice a day!

(My dc friends "all have them" too, my line for this is "so?" my dc have now given up on that line for the time being although I am sure they will try it again sometime )

oooh brilliant idea compo. I will remember that one.

OP - yanbu- He can come and be friends with my sons, 9 & 10, they dont have a TV either!!

LOL Nagpie, our mums had the same view on this sort of argument . "If everybody threw themself in the Rhone would you do it?" was her line.

Thanks everyone for taking the time to reply...I'm not going to cave in. DCs are such tv heads...There are some really good things on TV for them to watch but I have to say enough..go and play with lego/read a book/go outside nad play!
Thx

Thanks everyone for taking the time to reply...I'm not going to cave in. DCs are such tv heads...There are some really good things on TV for them to watch but I often have to say enough!Go and play with lego/read/play outside. If I give in I'll never see them.