Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect people NOT to buy things for DS2 that I've explicitly asked them not to???

89 replies

VictorianSqualor · 09/07/2008 12:25

DS2 is DP's first child, and his parents first grandchild.
I get it, he is their PFB/PFGB, and as such I make allowances.
I think I'm a pretty good daughter in law, I always make the effort to go and see them, make sure DP puts effort into their relationships, and overall, I butt out of their relationships with him and my children.
As PiL's go, they're great, Dp's dad makes some cringeworthy comments sometimes but who doesn't? His mum never ever interferes and would help at the drop of a hat.
This isn't a MiL bashing, I like her, a lot.

But I really hate Winnie-the-Pooh. (There is a reason behind it, someone very hurtful as I was growing up was obsessed, so not nice connotations for me)

When I was pg, MiL and I went into toys 'r' us and I was buying baby bits, didn't know the sex so could only buy cream, and she pointed out the WTP stuff. I told her how much I hated him, and had never dressed my other two in it for this reason. She told me she had already bought some WTP stuff so I said, Ok, we'll use it, thanks very much, don't want to seem ungrateful, she said not to worry in future she won't buy it.

When I'm in hospital DP's Dad looked after the older DC's and when they came to visit me DD told me FiL has bought baby some WTP stuff and she told him I didn't like WTP. When he gave me it he said 'I know you don't like WTP but I do so I bought it' jokingly. Rather than say anything I just smiled, and said to DP that as he may have bought it before he knew I wouldn't mention it and just dressed the baby in it if we went to their house.

MiL's sister also bought all WTP as presents. Again, gave benefit of the doubt, her DC's are the same age as my eldest two and she likes WTP, so no reason why she wouldn't buy it if she didn't know.

Now they ALL know I really don't like it.

DP comes back from work the other day and had popped into his mums on the way home. There were clothes there apparently from his Dad. I think it's really lovely the way they buy the stuff for DS2 and am grateful they care, but it was winnie the fucking pooh, again!

After the comment dp's dad had made I wasn't impressed, seemed like a 'I don't care what you like, I'm buying my grandson whatever'. So DP calls his mum about something else, and just drops into conversation about the WTP thing and the comment his Dad had made. Turns out she bought it not his Dad, and I know she knew how much I disliked it. If I had a girl and said I really hate pink can you buy purple, she would, so why can't they go into the mothercare superstore (where they shop) and get one of the other 50 outfits in there for DS2 that aren't wtp???

I know it seems ridiculous, but IMO it's not about WTP anymore, more the lack of consideration. One thing I ask them not to buy and they keep on buying it.

AIBU

OP posts:
VictorianSqualor · 09/07/2008 21:28

Really chickenburger?
What I have said is that it's not about WTP, it is about me not liking something and not wanting it bought for my child.
It's not about how 'rational' I;m being, it's about not having my wishes respected.

OP posts:
cheeset · 09/07/2008 21:39

VS, accept the WTP crap and flogg it on ebay.

YANBU. It's a twisted world out there, they are all barking mad

daffodill6 · 09/07/2008 22:06

VS - total agreemt. IMO it gets worse. My DD is 9yo - recently 74yo MIL has been shopping with DH and bought 4 items which I had already suggested were not appropriate for her ie I did not wish her to have them ---and brokered alternatives!

But apparently the word no cannot cross her lips. All 4 have been purchased - and 3 confiscated - not DDs fault but how do I make the point? ( I have shouted !!)

Alderney · 10/07/2008 08:56

I think you, or your DH needs to tell them that there is an actual reason, almost a phobic reaction that you have to WTP, rather than them being left to think that you "just don't like it"...

I used to dislike WTP (dislike, nowhere near the severity of your reaction) but we received a lot of really cute WTP baby things (including our favourite item of baby clothes ever) and that mellowed me and now, I'm happy with it all in my house..

HOWEVER, you won't be like that....I don't think its as much of a powere struggle about your wishes being disregarded as you seem to think it is - thats a bit over the top I have to say. I think its just that they don't get that its not just a "slight dislike" in your case..

I know that my ILs only shop in Woolworths because thats the only chain store their town has and it was completely impossible for them to buy children's clothes in their for babies that DIDN'T have WTP on them - some were nice, some were returned...but it may be that they are suffering from a mixture of not understanding that its not just a "dislike" and also being very limited in what other choice they have.

hunkermunker · 10/07/2008 08:57

Call him Neigh the Shit.

Worked for me.

Flashman · 10/07/2008 10:24

Twelvelegs - I know how tacky am I!

VictorianSqualor · 10/07/2008 15:12

Neigh the shit

OP posts:
hunkermunker · 11/07/2008 13:16

Knew you'd like that

Onestonetogo · 11/07/2008 13:23

Message withdrawn

ipanemagirl · 11/07/2008 13:33

I sympathise with both sides. But I do think it smells of petulance on their part, why not indulge you?

I had to really be strict with my miil and fil about what they fed ds, they would add sugar and stuff like that to his food unless I swooped and tried, politely, to say that he didn't need it. He's 7 now and still doesn't add sugar to cereal.

I would just never ever put the clothes on them and lose it at the back of a drawer. Eventually they'll have to get the message!

If you were really bold you could ask them outright in a very loving way "I find it odd that you both keep buying this when I've made it so clear how much I dislike it? It would be really gracious of you to just be indulgent with me about this. I really really dislike the stuff! Might you consider inuldging me in future?"

But I know it's easier said than done! Better still get bl**dy dp to tell them to stop!

hunkermunker · 11/07/2008 13:35

Can you just say "Really? Again? Which part of I fucking hate Neigh the Shit isn't getting through to you?"

mum2oandh · 11/07/2008 13:49

IMO Mil's, even much loved ones (as mine was) can start some seriously weird behaviour along these lines once the dgc begin to turn up. I agree with custardo, it's something to do with being the head female, they made all the decisions for their ds and now they are going to try and do it with you. The amount of things I have specifically asked my Mil not to buy, that she has then gone ahead and brought anyway is astonishing, and would be taking up a lot of space............if I hadn't given them all away

TinkerBellesMum · 11/07/2008 14:51

I love WTP (prefer the classics to the Yankee Disney version though, but I do like the more recent sketch and watercolour versions) but I do understand because there are things I don't like.

I don't like Bratz (didn't think about them till I had Tink, I used to buy it for my niece) or baby dolls that have dummies, bottles or weaning sets, especially if they are important to the working of the doll (Tesco have a cheap doll she loves, I just threw the bottle out) and I've made sure that people know that. However, considering my SIL's previous attempts to sabotage my beliefs (she doesn't like BFing, can't wait to start solids at 8 weeks - my niece wasn't term and she wasn't as prem as Tink - loves the latest pushchairs and passes her children around so she can go out or have time off) I can't see her respecting my views on toys.

hunkermunker · 11/07/2008 16:08

PS - I guarantee that if you do say something polite and fluffy yet firm about not wanting any more NTS stuff, you'll have my last post going round your head as you do

New posts on this thread. Refresh page