Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at the crap some people feed their kids

617 replies

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 09:20

Currently watching a kid who can’t be more than age 3, tuck in to a packet of ‘squashie’ sweets on the bus. No sign of a tantrum, kid seems perfectly happy looking out the window, but out come the sweets. And to pre empt the ‘snobbery’ thing, the parent seems middle class to me and certainly eloquent.

I regularly see kids tucking into chocolate bars, packets of crisps, lollies, all on the school run. Many of them toddlers in their buggies dropping off older siblings. Parents meeting kids at the school gate with full packets of Oreos, bottles of pop, doughnuts.

I’ve been trying not to judge for years and have been repeatedly told it’s ’just one snapshot of their day’ but honestly, I feel like the time for judgement has entered. I have never fed my toddlers crap like that, let alone just after breakfast. My 3 year old has never had a fizzy drink.

Why, just why! AIBU to feel there needs to be some kind of very direct public health campaign at this point? Maybe even a ‘no sweets at the school gate’ rule?

OP posts:
CanterThroughChaos · Today 10:18

I’ve never seen this, could be the area you live in?? I’m rural so less people. But if I did see someone give their child sweets before school I wouldn’t automatically assume they did it regularly…….unless they were grandparents. My child won’t eat sweets or chocolate but is a fiend for crisps. They will be happily playing and my mum out of nowhere will ask ‘can I give them a packet of crisps?’ 🤦‍♀️. Absolutely fucking not!!! Why are you asking?!?! It drives me bonkers 😵‍💫

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:18

MrsBananaman · Today 10:17

Seriously expecting a toddler to eat a packet of plain chicken?! Is he a mini gym bro 😂

Kids need carbs and calories. I’m not saying a packet of pastries a day obviously but it’s really not that big of a deal in isolation.

The problem with this kind of judgment is people don’t realise or don’t know how often this type of food is given. I’m sure people were horrified to see 3yo DS tucking into his once-a-month doughnut from the bakery while in his buggy on the school run. They didn’t see the porridge with fruit all the other days did they.

Edited

Sweets will provide neither. Seriously why do you think people were healthier and slimmer without this crap? How did Stone Age kids survive without Haribo to prop up their calories?

OP posts:
CraftySeal · Today 10:18

For me this would fall into the category of maybe not ideal but also not worth getting worked up about. When it's put into perspective of all the less than ideal things that can and do happen to kids. Seeing kids eat sweets on the bus and at the school gates...meh.

SomethingYum · Today 10:18

Summerhillsquare · Today 09:54

All of you with clever ripostes to the OP, who are you expecting to pay for and provide health care including dentistry for kids with poor diets? No one's teeth rot overnight, nobody becomes obese spontaneously. It starts somewhere, and ends somewhere.

Truly ridiculous responses to a well recognised issue.

Sadcafe · Today 10:19

We drop off and pick up our grandkids from school, they never get food on the way to or from school rather at home. Always start with fruit after which they will often ask for crisps/ biscuits which we let them have, they rarely eat sweets but that’s their choice not because we won’t let them. As long as the diet isn’t 100% so called junk food,does it matter so much if they have some of it

x2boys · Today 10:19

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:18

Sweets will provide neither. Seriously why do you think people were healthier and slimmer without this crap? How did Stone Age kids survive without Haribo to prop up their calories?

Well a lot didnt...

Sweepingthetide · Today 10:19

If we want to talk about long term health and evidence, then we need to also mention that research shows demonising food or labeling food good and bad leads to eating disorders. So why choose to act that way OP when we know it leads to bad health outcomes?

ihateprobability · Today 10:19

When I think of how much NHS os spending on “lifestyle “ illnesses I do very much think it is something to get worked up about

we have normalised junk eating habits, harmful eating habits as “there’s worse things could happen”

SoftSpotForDandelions · Today 10:21

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:14

Absolutely, it’s now a societal issue. A quarter of the kids look like James Cordon at his biggest. It’s shameful. And this ‘be kind, dont judge’ is just permissiveness that allows it to be acceptable.

Was this kid in question overweight? Wouldn't that be the thing which made you notice what they were eating? I'm no saint and probably would have noticed this too but I bet I also wouldn't have thought much of a healthy-sized child eating sweets in the days after Halloween. It wouldn't register so my brain would be creating this bias that I'm always seeing bigger children eating sweets, crisps, etc.

MrsBananaman · Today 10:21

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:18

Sweets will provide neither. Seriously why do you think people were healthier and slimmer without this crap? How did Stone Age kids survive without Haribo to prop up their calories?

I wasn’t talking about sweets. I was replying to the poster who mentioned pastries. Hence my comment about pastries.

MrsBananaman · Today 10:22

Bottom line here is unless you’re that child’s parent, mind your business.
It must be exhausting being so judgemental.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:22

It's horrible. People are lazy don't even bother with a proper breakfast. I saw a schoolchild eating a bag of crisps on the way to school.

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:24

MrsBananaman · Today 10:22

Bottom line here is unless you’re that child’s parent, mind your business.
It must be exhausting being so judgemental.

No it's everyone's business .it's right to call it out.
Always crap never fruit.

x2boys · Today 10:24

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:22

It's horrible. People are lazy don't even bother with a proper breakfast. I saw a schoolchild eating a bag of crisps on the way to school.

So your assuming they havent had breakfast,?

MrsBananaman · Today 10:24

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:18

Sweets will provide neither. Seriously why do you think people were healthier and slimmer without this crap? How did Stone Age kids survive without Haribo to prop up their calories?

Also baffled that you think sweets don’t contain calories or carbs? Sugar is a carb, and contains calories. I’m not saying it’s healthy but your comment that they contain neither is wrong. As for the Stone Age kids, well they coped without haribo but the life expectancy was like 30 so…

professionalcommentreader · Today 10:26

I remember 20 years ago a mum pouring a bottle of Dr Pepper into a babies bottle, her child was 10 months old because she said the baby bottle was better for her child’s teeth!

I didn’t know what to say I was so shocked.

A healthy balance is best with some treats but no one needs sweets everyday or at 9 in the morning.

FallenNight · Today 10:26

Bringbackbuffy · Today 09:35

My mum said about my three month old last week “I can’t wait to give him his first piece of cake” when we were in a cafe. Really??? Of all the foods to be looking forward to and yet that’s where her mind jumps

I love baking, I like cake, I couldn't wait to share something that i enjoy with my kids. It doesn't seem that odd to me to be looking forward to seeing if a child enjoys something that is generally considered to be enjoyable.

Sweets before school does seem a bit off though.

That said my secondary age DC bakes a cake weekly and has a slice a day for snack. Some would perhaps consider this to be unhealthy.

x2boys · Today 10:26

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:24

No it's everyone's business .it's right to call it out.
Always crap never fruit.

How is it everyones buisness
What difference do you think the Ops silent judging will to the child?

Kirbert2 · Today 10:26

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:24

No it's everyone's business .it's right to call it out.
Always crap never fruit.

Of course it isn't everyone's business and OP is simply making a post about it on the internet. It's hardly calling anything out as people will continue to feed their kids how they like.

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:26

MrsBananaman · Today 10:22

Bottom line here is unless you’re that child’s parent, mind your business.
It must be exhausting being so judgemental.

It’s exhausting paying taxes to an NHS which is pulling out kids teeth and wrangling our obesity crisis!

OP posts:
DustyMaiden · Today 10:26

So close to Halloween I’m sure lots are trying to spread the sweets over weeks and not gorge them all in one day.

MrsBananaman · Today 10:26

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:24

No it's everyone's business .it's right to call it out.
Always crap never fruit.

Being weird and judgemental
about food is why we have Orthorexia now and eating disorders have the highest mortality rate of all mental health issues.

Sweepingthetide · Today 10:27

Netcurtainnelly · Today 10:22

It's horrible. People are lazy don't even bother with a proper breakfast. I saw a schoolchild eating a bag of crisps on the way to school.

If this was a secondary school child, maybe they bought them on the way in as they aren't allowed 'junk food' at home and therefore gorge on it now they have freedom. They may have had breakfast. You don't know so it is impossible to judge.

Weeelokthen · Today 10:27

Leavemetonguetied · Today 09:43

It's probably Halloween leftover that they were promised. I try and avoid sweets etc but I'm not going to pretend my DC have organic root veg as a treat.

I would wait until your child is in secondary and they have access to shops without you and see what happens. Go to our town at 4pm and the coffee shops are full of children from 'naice' backgrounds guzzling back 3000 calories of cream lattes and bubble teas.

This is the mistake I made with my boys (men) I was so paranoid about tooth decay that all they drank was water/milk & sometimes diluting juice. As soon as my eldest was earning his own money, he started buying Monster drinks, he still has an addiction to that vile drink years on.

MrsBananaman · Today 10:27

x2boys · Today 10:26

How is it everyones buisness
What difference do you think the Ops silent judging will to the child?

And then slagging them off online about it! I’m sure that’s made the world of difference and the NHS is counting their riches now.