Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair at the crap some people feed their kids

641 replies

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 09:20

Currently watching a kid who can’t be more than age 3, tuck in to a packet of ‘squashie’ sweets on the bus. No sign of a tantrum, kid seems perfectly happy looking out the window, but out come the sweets. And to pre empt the ‘snobbery’ thing, the parent seems middle class to me and certainly eloquent.

I regularly see kids tucking into chocolate bars, packets of crisps, lollies, all on the school run. Many of them toddlers in their buggies dropping off older siblings. Parents meeting kids at the school gate with full packets of Oreos, bottles of pop, doughnuts.

I’ve been trying not to judge for years and have been repeatedly told it’s ’just one snapshot of their day’ but honestly, I feel like the time for judgement has entered. I have never fed my toddlers crap like that, let alone just after breakfast. My 3 year old has never had a fizzy drink.

Why, just why! AIBU to feel there needs to be some kind of very direct public health campaign at this point? Maybe even a ‘no sweets at the school gate’ rule?

OP posts:
ItalianChineseIndianMexican · Today 13:49

PancakeCloud · Today 12:47

i mean something had to be the leading cause of hospital admissions, and isn’t it good it’s not something more serious?

to be clear, I don’t think tooth decay is good and we ought to be working to reduce it, but I don’t find this fact sad at all. In fact it seems like a good thing it’s not something less treatable.

You don't think tooth decay is serious?

And you don't think it's sad that the leading cause of hospital admissions for that age group is something that is preventable?

Tooth decay causes pain, missed days from school (life), disrupted sleep, can affect learning/confidence/self esteem, can lead to nutritional problems, can lead to speech difficulties, can cause infections / abscesses, negatively impacts adult teeth so the issues continue... I think it's fairly serious - and can be prevented by consuming less sugar and brushing teeth.

user987362547 · Today 13:49

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:49

Public health epidemics are absolutely society’s business. Do you have an overweight child?

So what are you planning to do to help, OP? Or is this it?

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:50

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 13:46

It’s absolutely fine to discuss neglect in all its forms, but what constitutes neglect for some people on this forum is utterly ridiculous, and yes shaming of other parents.

Just on here we’ve had “squashies, no; chocolate buttons, yes”, demonising anything that isn’t houmous and apple, and children described I horrible terms. How is that in any way contributing to a discussion about how, as a society, we help to change eating habits?

Demonising people doesn’t inspire them to change their behaviour - even if you wouldn’t behave in the way they do there are usually reasons for what they do, beyond can’t be arsed.

Are you incapable of properly following arguments? Nobody said ‘chocolate buttons fine, squashies bad’. We’ve said food is on a spectrum with stuff like squashies - where you can’t name a single ingredient and there is no nutritional value bar UPF garbage - and chocolate buttons (not great, too much sugar, but some dairy and cocoa powder and some nutritional value, fine as a treat).

OP posts:
MrsBananaman · Today 13:50

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:29

Do you have an overweight child?

Don’t look up you might see the point you just missed

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:52

MrsBananaman · Today 13:50

Don’t look up you might see the point you just missed

I assume you do then, hence all the projection and outrage

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · Today 13:52

muggart · Today 13:44

She’s just educating her child! her kid has a right to know about her own body and parents should not gatekeep information about how to be healthy.

I think she did well.

Ffs my kids are well educated on healthy eating and know very well what constitutes a balanced diet. I don’t, as I hand them a biscuit, remind them it’s junk. I can’t imagine that someone telling you you’re drinking poison every time you had a glass of wine would enhance your enjoyment of it.

Lottie6712 · Today 13:52

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 13:38

Christ on a bike, have a treat after gymnastics with a side order of “it may be delicious, but it’s shit”.

It was a Twix! It was absolutely delicious - and its 14 ingredients mainly were shit. I'd rather she grows up knowing what she's eating.

SixtySomething · Today 13:53

GoodGirlFaith · Today 09:55

Why do children need food at school pick up? Genuine question! Does this really happen? Could they be going straight on to after school clubs?

I admit that I was always ravenous after school and would usually make a sandwich when I got home (had a long walk home from school). But most parents seem to pick their children up in the car these days.

My own children are young adults now and I definitely never saw anyone give their child food at pick up.

Me too,
If A Mum had turned up with sweets. cake etc, . there would have been a lot of meaningful looks being passed between the other Mums!
You bet.
I just can't imagine it!

TeawithMeerksy · Today 13:53

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 13:52

Ffs my kids are well educated on healthy eating and know very well what constitutes a balanced diet. I don’t, as I hand them a biscuit, remind them it’s junk. I can’t imagine that someone telling you you’re drinking poison every time you had a glass of wine would enhance your enjoyment of it.

This is how I feel reading a menu with the calories on it 😂

Sillyme1 · Today 13:53

I grew up in the 1960s. I had sixpence a day for sweets every day. It was safe then for children to walk to school on their own. How I wish now my mum had not given me that sixpence! I have had a lifetime of bad teeth, fillings,pain, expense, root canals, etc etc. it’s not judgemental to comment on excessive sweet consumption, it’s common sense and the children who grow up with good teeth will thank their parents for it

MrsBananaman · Today 13:54

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:49

Public health epidemics are absolutely society’s business. Do you have an overweight child?

One child eating one packet of sweets on the bus is not a public health epidemic!

A public health epidemic is a systemic problem, stop trying to make it an individual one.

Frustrateddiva · Today 13:54

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 10:15

Agree. I see the same parents feeding their kids this rubbish at the school gate almost every day. It’s not an emergency situation or a treat

Then you should approach the parents OP! Call them out! There and then! That’s the only way. Go OP! Go OP!

MrsBananaman · Today 13:55

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:52

I assume you do then, hence all the projection and outrage

When you assume you make as Ass out of U and Me. But mainly you.

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · Today 13:55

Bimblebombles · Today 12:02

I think its a waste of a good appetite giving kids junk straight out of school - my DD is the most hungry of all the day at that point so I bring her fruit. She will eat it on the way home as she's famished. Whereas if I brought her a bag of crisps or sweets she'd eat that and then would refuse fruit later on if I tried to offer it.

Its one of the most important things I can do for her laying down good eating habits. I imagine some of the mums think I'm uptight and rigid but I'm not bothered.

Its also interesting that the idea of being hungry now is an unthinkable crisis. Their last meal was 3 hours ago, it doesn't hurt them to be hungry for a while.

The amount of time my DC is "starving".. until we pass the park and then suddenly she can wait 🤨

Its perfectly fine to be hungry for a while, especially if the alternative is junk food.

Eta, I wasn't disagreeing with you, I was agreeing on the point that junk is a waste if appetite.

TeawithMeerksy · Today 13:57

I think people can disagree with aspects of this post regardless of the weight of their child.

I do genuinely worry this is why so many parents don’t engage with education/support and suffer in silence over other things… for fear of the shame that gets piled on as soon as they are seen to do anything less than perfect

5128gap · Today 13:57

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:49

Public health epidemics are absolutely society’s business. Do you have an overweight child?

They are indeed everybody's business, and our job in that business is to look after our own health and that of our own children. Are you getting it perfect for yourself OP? Are you the ideal weight, highly active, avoid alcohol, eat only whole foods, menus perfectly planned to maximise nutrional benefit? Because if not, you could improve on that. Its far more productive than moaning about things you have no power to change.

user987362547 · Today 13:58

muggart · Today 13:48

I live in portugal which is one of the poorest countries in western europe and the children here aren’t constantly given sugary foods.

I was shocked (in a good way) to see the nurseries provide lunch every day of vegetable soup, plus something like fish + rice. plain yoghurt and fruit for dessert.

The population here has an amazing attitude towards nutrition and food despite not having the wealth of the uk.

The problem is cultural.

Perhaps, but the child poverty rate is closer to 18% in Portugal, so just over half of the UK.

A quick look at obesity rates in school age children - these aren't perfect statistics, obviously, and aren't all like for like - the rates for Portugal include some children over age 11

UK: 35% age 10-11
Portugal: 31- 40% school aged children
Sweden: 6-10% school aged children

Poverty is the biggest factor. And what you see isn't always an accurate reflection - I live in zone 1 and very rarely see an overweight child.

Frugalgal · Today 14:01

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 09:20

Currently watching a kid who can’t be more than age 3, tuck in to a packet of ‘squashie’ sweets on the bus. No sign of a tantrum, kid seems perfectly happy looking out the window, but out come the sweets. And to pre empt the ‘snobbery’ thing, the parent seems middle class to me and certainly eloquent.

I regularly see kids tucking into chocolate bars, packets of crisps, lollies, all on the school run. Many of them toddlers in their buggies dropping off older siblings. Parents meeting kids at the school gate with full packets of Oreos, bottles of pop, doughnuts.

I’ve been trying not to judge for years and have been repeatedly told it’s ’just one snapshot of their day’ but honestly, I feel like the time for judgement has entered. I have never fed my toddlers crap like that, let alone just after breakfast. My 3 year old has never had a fizzy drink.

Why, just why! AIBU to feel there needs to be some kind of very direct public health campaign at this point? Maybe even a ‘no sweets at the school gate’ rule?

I've seen this a lot but it's not just about people who feed their kids crap. People who don't feed their kids sweets, sugar fizzy pop etc but naice healthy snacks never seem to let up with trying to stuff them with snacks between meals.

I've seen relatives gathered at the in-laws for meals and their little kids are constantly handed tipperwares of snacks, yoghurts, rice cakes to eat while waiting for the meal to be served. Then when the meal is served they are only able to pick at it. As soon as the meal is done out come the snacks again. There is never a time when they're not having things shoved under their noses to eat. I don't know how they are ever meant to work up an appetite.

Munchie1965 · Today 14:04

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · Today 13:55

Its also interesting that the idea of being hungry now is an unthinkable crisis. Their last meal was 3 hours ago, it doesn't hurt them to be hungry for a while.

The amount of time my DC is "starving".. until we pass the park and then suddenly she can wait 🤨

Its perfectly fine to be hungry for a while, especially if the alternative is junk food.

Eta, I wasn't disagreeing with you, I was agreeing on the point that junk is a waste if appetite.

Edited

Reading the thread I was just thinking back to when I was at secondary school. I used to be hungry after school but do not remember buying anything to eat on the way home. Dinner was not until 6 ish. I just stayed hungry most of the time - it didn't cross my mind to eat a load of sweets or biscuits or crisps. Same in Primary. If I wanted something to eat I was told that it would spoil my appetite for my dinner which was true!

Jellycatspyjamas · Today 14:05

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 13:50

Are you incapable of properly following arguments? Nobody said ‘chocolate buttons fine, squashies bad’. We’ve said food is on a spectrum with stuff like squashies - where you can’t name a single ingredient and there is no nutritional value bar UPF garbage - and chocolate buttons (not great, too much sugar, but some dairy and cocoa powder and some nutritional value, fine as a treat).

I’m laughing at the idea of chocolate buttons being less UPF than a packet of sweets, or containing any dairy worth considering - assuming we’re talking cadburys which is more palm oil than anything else.

It’s the classic what I do is ok, what you do isn’t.

Missey85 · Today 14:07

😂😂😂😂

ShanghaiDiva · Today 14:07

ItalianChineseIndianMexican · Today 12:42

I agree with you OP.

One of the saddest statistics for me is that tooth decay requiring extractions under general anaesthetic is the leading cause of planned/surgical hospital admissions for children aged 5 to 9 in the UK. I wonder what causes the tooth decay...

Yes, it’s depressing. My dentist told me 98% of children in Cornwall don’t have access to an nhs dentist.

ShanghaiDiva · Today 14:10

PancakeCloud · Today 12:47

i mean something had to be the leading cause of hospital admissions, and isn’t it good it’s not something more serious?

to be clear, I don’t think tooth decay is good and we ought to be working to reduce it, but I don’t find this fact sad at all. In fact it seems like a good thing it’s not something less treatable.

But it’s completely preventable so it’s not in any way good, is it?

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 14:12

Frugalgal · Today 14:01

I've seen this a lot but it's not just about people who feed their kids crap. People who don't feed their kids sweets, sugar fizzy pop etc but naice healthy snacks never seem to let up with trying to stuff them with snacks between meals.

I've seen relatives gathered at the in-laws for meals and their little kids are constantly handed tipperwares of snacks, yoghurts, rice cakes to eat while waiting for the meal to be served. Then when the meal is served they are only able to pick at it. As soon as the meal is done out come the snacks again. There is never a time when they're not having things shoved under their noses to eat. I don't know how they are ever meant to work up an appetite.

I also agree with this.

OP posts:
muggart · Today 14:13

Also, this is partly why state healthcare doesn’t work. People aren’t taking responsibility for their health and, when those who do support healthy living complain, we are told “don’t shame people!” or “it’s none of your business!”.

Well if it’s none of my business then why should I have to pay for your decisions via taxation?

The NHS can’t cope with the status quo, as we all know, so maybe private healthcare is part of the solution.