Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is a ticking time bomb (people priced out of housing)

604 replies

Batmanisreal · 25/10/2026 10:07

It’s becoming clear that there is a problem with people not being able to afford housing like they used to be able to. This has been made worse by the introduction of right to buy by Thatcher in the 80s which reduced the numbers of council houses. The price of housing is going up and up, so more people are having to rent on the private market.

So what happens to these people who are privately renting homes, when they get to retirement age? If they can’t afford their rent?

I was lucky enough to be able to buy my house. I have young children who, by the time they get to the age I was when I bought my house, will probably not be able to afford to buy like I was. There’s a very big chance they will have to rent, possibly for the rest of their lives.

People who rent on the private market are at the mercy of whatever rents the landlords want to charge for those properties. And with more properties being rent out as short-term lets this is only going to make the situation worse.

I worry that we are heading for a situation where elderly people will end up on the streets, because there won’t be enough affordable or social housing to supply them with housing if they become homeless in the event of them not being able to afford their private rent anymore.

As a parent, I just find the whole situation so depressing.

OP posts:
mrsm43s · Yesterday 18:53

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 18:39

During Covid Channel 4 news did a report on a care worker who was living in an HMO and how it made it more of a struggle with infection control.

But she couldnt afford better so thats ok right? you would have been happy with her caring for your elderly mum.

Right, but we're not in a pandemic, so no concerns about infection control right now. Oh and my Mum's dead.

We need to provide more, high quality affordable accomodation.

We need new, innovative solutions for the increasing numbers of private renting single/couple pensioners to have affordable ways to live in their later years.

You don't seem to want any affordable solutions to exists, just for tax payers living in bedsits to pay more and more taxes so that older people who failed to make provision for their retirement can be subsidised to live in lovely houses with gardens by themselves. That's unaffordable snd completely unfair to the young tax payers of today who aren't able to afford that for themselves.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 18:56

ExpectMore · Yesterday 18:51

Why would they be evicted and told to pay someone’s mortgage? That makes zero sense.

Think about it. They, after having had the benefit of cheap accommodation for 3 years and thus preparing for having to leave it, could do as they choose, either:
A) buy a house
B) rent privately

If by “pay someone else’s mortgage” you mean rent privately, remember:

  1. The landlord may not have a mortgage, so there might be no mortgage to pay
  2. even where there is a mortgage to pay, it’s only part of the costs of property ownership
  3. it’s not like they’re getting nothing out of the transaction, they’re getting a roof over their head for the duration that they pay their rent for. Surely that’s a good deal?

What do you mean by preparing to have to leave it? People in council/social housing have an assured tenancy. As long as they pay the rent and don't breach the terms, they can stay.

I think you forget that when someone moves in to social housing, they get a bare shell. They have to buy carpets, vinyl, wallpaper etc. They are lucky if there is lightbulbs when they move in.
Why would anyone spend £££ to make a place their home if they are going to be turfed out in 3 years?

ExpectMore · Yesterday 18:56

Yellowshirt · Yesterday 17:43

I live in a 6 room ensuite hmo. We are treated atrociously.

Absolute minimal heating. A kitchen which has a cleaner for 10 minutes a week. An oven not cleaned for 5 years. No money spent on the kitchen ever. So very few basic essentials like chopping knives and pans with lids for cooking.

The landlord has just put my rent up to £630. So he is getting approximately £4000 per month from his 6 tennants. He has another 5 houses. So he will own all these houses having made substantial profits for minimal work.

He also turns a blind eye to overnight guests. And yes the walls are extremely thin. He allows partners and children to stay.
I wouldn't want my elderly parents staying in a hmo . Surely they deserve better than this .

The government should be making hmo accommodation illegal, forcing these cowboy landlords to sell.

Why can't they build affordable 1/2 bedroom flats with balcony or garden space and make them freehold not leasehold. Service charges of £150 per month are stopping people like myself getting on the property ladder.

It sounds like your landlord could do better.

Out of curiosity, why is a cleaner needed to clean the kitchen or oven? Why don’t residents just take turns at cleaning it?

I know in any house share I’ve lived in that’s what we’ve done. There’s generally been the odd person that needs reminding more than the others but it tends to work!

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 18:57

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 18:39

During Covid Channel 4 news did a report on a care worker who was living in an HMO and how it made it more of a struggle with infection control.

But she couldnt afford better so thats ok right? you would have been happy with her caring for your elderly mum.

Found it · 27/07/2020 19:01
Channel 4 news did some pieces on care workers living in cramped shared dwellings and having to share kitchens with several other families.
Channel 4 news did a huge segment on care workers. And how they are under paid , under valued, classed as low skilled and why they cant socially distance due to the appalling places some of them live in.
Bookmark
Add message | Report | Message Thu 14-May-20 19:14:10
A care worker interviewed lives in one room with her son and they share bathroom and kitchen facilities with ten other families
Hardly an ideal living situation to cook healthy meals
A care worker was ill with Covid for 28 days and was brought a hot meal every day by Hare Krishna She has to walk an hour to get to work and same to get home because she cant afford public transport
www.channel4.com/news/charities-demand-care-home-workers-are-paid-a-living-wage
www.channel4.com/news/charities-demand-care-home-workers-are-paid-a-living-wage
Then on another date they interviewed another zero hours care worker in poor housing.
www.channel4.com/news/nearly-a-third-of-people-have-suffered-health-problems-during-lockdown-because-of-poor-housing

Charities demand care home workers are paid a living wage

They are dying at roughly twice the rate of the general population and are struggling with a lack of protective equipment putting them in harm's way every day they go to work.

https://www.channel4.com/news/charities-demand-care-home-workers-are-paid-a-living-wage

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 18:59

mrsm43s · Yesterday 18:53

Right, but we're not in a pandemic, so no concerns about infection control right now. Oh and my Mum's dead.

We need to provide more, high quality affordable accomodation.

We need new, innovative solutions for the increasing numbers of private renting single/couple pensioners to have affordable ways to live in their later years.

You don't seem to want any affordable solutions to exists, just for tax payers living in bedsits to pay more and more taxes so that older people who failed to make provision for their retirement can be subsidised to live in lovely houses with gardens by themselves. That's unaffordable snd completely unfair to the young tax payers of today who aren't able to afford that for themselves.

Younger people that can only afford bedsits are not going to be net contributors, so them paying for pensioners rent is a moot point, because they are not.

Typical MN though to have such distain for pensioners.

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:02

mrsm43s · Yesterday 18:53

Right, but we're not in a pandemic, so no concerns about infection control right now. Oh and my Mum's dead.

We need to provide more, high quality affordable accomodation.

We need new, innovative solutions for the increasing numbers of private renting single/couple pensioners to have affordable ways to live in their later years.

You don't seem to want any affordable solutions to exists, just for tax payers living in bedsits to pay more and more taxes so that older people who failed to make provision for their retirement can be subsidised to live in lovely houses with gardens by themselves. That's unaffordable snd completely unfair to the young tax payers of today who aren't able to afford that for themselves.

I gave you an example of a friend of mine who did make provision. How do you know other pensioners in SH didnt do the same thing but were penalized for it. Do you know them all personally

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:07

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 18:56

What do you mean by preparing to have to leave it? People in council/social housing have an assured tenancy. As long as they pay the rent and don't breach the terms, they can stay.

I think you forget that when someone moves in to social housing, they get a bare shell. They have to buy carpets, vinyl, wallpaper etc. They are lucky if there is lightbulbs when they move in.
Why would anyone spend £££ to make a place their home if they are going to be turfed out in 3 years?

Funny how @mrsm43s wants all things "equal" and everybody to have to live in HMOs (apart from those who have reproduced natch) but i would bet money she wouldnt say Oh private tenants get a place thats already furnished so social housing tenants should too

Pureshores11 · Yesterday 19:08

Ifailed · 25/10/2026 10:43

Meanwhile there are over 1,000,000 empty properties in the UK. I see the Government have tried to change Empty Dwelling Management Orders (EDMOs) to make it slightly easier for councils to take them over, but it's still a long and costly process.

If parts of the 2012 act around squatting was amended I suspect this would force landlords to move quicker when faced with an EDMO

A lot of them are uninhabitable.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 19:16

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:07

Funny how @mrsm43s wants all things "equal" and everybody to have to live in HMOs (apart from those who have reproduced natch) but i would bet money she wouldnt say Oh private tenants get a place thats already furnished so social housing tenants should too

I bet they would be the first to complain if a social housing tenant was given a furnished place. Why are tax payers giving people seating to sit on, and fridges?

My mum is in a council house. When she dies, I will have 2 weeks to erase her entire life and existence from the place. Wont even be allowed to pay the rent to have longer.

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:20

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 18:56

What do you mean by preparing to have to leave it? People in council/social housing have an assured tenancy. As long as they pay the rent and don't breach the terms, they can stay.

I think you forget that when someone moves in to social housing, they get a bare shell. They have to buy carpets, vinyl, wallpaper etc. They are lucky if there is lightbulbs when they move in.
Why would anyone spend £££ to make a place their home if they are going to be turfed out in 3 years?

yes, that’s the current model. I was discussing the proposed model… see the quote thread if helpful…

I’m not sure what you mean re. shell? That’s how houses come no? Unless the previous occupier has left carpet etc

As to why anyone would spend £££ to make a place their home, because exactly that? They want to make it a home?

My last rental I was in for less than 2 years and paid to decorate it top to better so it was better to my tastes and thus felt more homely rather than living in someone else’s taste.

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:24

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:02

I gave you an example of a friend of mine who did make provision. How do you know other pensioners in SH didnt do the same thing but were penalized for it. Do you know them all personally

Your point is irrelevant which I suspect is why it’s being ignored.

All is demonstrates is the inherent risk in investing (in pensions in this case) which is widely known. There is also of course the flip side opportunity, which many benefit from.

Most things in life carry risk. Doesn’t mean they aren’t worth doing.

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:24

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:20

yes, that’s the current model. I was discussing the proposed model… see the quote thread if helpful…

I’m not sure what you mean re. shell? That’s how houses come no? Unless the previous occupier has left carpet etc

As to why anyone would spend £££ to make a place their home, because exactly that? They want to make it a home?

My last rental I was in for less than 2 years and paid to decorate it top to better so it was better to my tastes and thus felt more homely rather than living in someone else’s taste.

But ppl on here love to remind us that it isnt our home

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 19:26

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:20

yes, that’s the current model. I was discussing the proposed model… see the quote thread if helpful…

I’m not sure what you mean re. shell? That’s how houses come no? Unless the previous occupier has left carpet etc

As to why anyone would spend £££ to make a place their home, because exactly that? They want to make it a home?

My last rental I was in for less than 2 years and paid to decorate it top to better so it was better to my tastes and thus felt more homely rather than living in someone else’s taste.

If you buy a place, and the carpet is left, then that is a bonus (if it is to your taste).

Council/social housing is stripped when someone leaves. Someone could have had new carpet put down 6 months before, but it will all be taken out when they leave. The new tenant has to fork out for flooring.
I remember when my family moved into a council house. Someone had gone in and pulled at the wallpaper. Not removed it totally, but took strips off to make it look shabby.

No one private renting is expected to fully replace flooring and repaper/paint walls when they pick the keys up.
But you would be ok with people in social housing having to spend serious money doing the same, only to be evicted 3 years later. That makes no sense.

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:26

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:07

Funny how @mrsm43s wants all things "equal" and everybody to have to live in HMOs (apart from those who have reproduced natch) but i would bet money she wouldnt say Oh private tenants get a place thats already furnished so social housing tenants should too

I guess that’s because private tenants can fundamentally get anything they’re prepared to pay for?

Furnished
Concierge
24/7 gym
etc

Just because it’s available on the private sector market doesn’t mean it should be on the social market. That wouldn’t make sense would it?

Yellowshirt · Yesterday 19:27

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 18:32

That sounds awful

I briefly went out with a man who lived in an HMO. There was no shared communal area or even a kitchen. He had a little counter top fridge and a microwave in his room. Had to use the taps in the bathroom if he wanted any water. Two bathrooms between 10 people. He joined a gym so he could shower, as both bathrooms were full of bicycles. It was fucking grim.

I'm lucky as we have our own bathrooms.

Thankyou for sharing your experience as people need to understand what hmos are really like and how unsuitable they are for pensioners like someone earlier suggested.

You hit the nail on the head . They are grim and depressing.

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:29

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:24

But ppl on here love to remind us that it isnt our home

Come on, you’re going to listen to what folk on MN tell you to the extent you’d let yourself live somewhere that doesn’t feel homely?!

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:30

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 19:26

If you buy a place, and the carpet is left, then that is a bonus (if it is to your taste).

Council/social housing is stripped when someone leaves. Someone could have had new carpet put down 6 months before, but it will all be taken out when they leave. The new tenant has to fork out for flooring.
I remember when my family moved into a council house. Someone had gone in and pulled at the wallpaper. Not removed it totally, but took strips off to make it look shabby.

No one private renting is expected to fully replace flooring and repaper/paint walls when they pick the keys up.
But you would be ok with people in social housing having to spend serious money doing the same, only to be evicted 3 years later. That makes no sense.

Its because of attitudes like that that i never bought the "all in this together" shit during Covid. I predicted that it would be back to the default setting soon enough and i was proved right.

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:30

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 19:26

If you buy a place, and the carpet is left, then that is a bonus (if it is to your taste).

Council/social housing is stripped when someone leaves. Someone could have had new carpet put down 6 months before, but it will all be taken out when they leave. The new tenant has to fork out for flooring.
I remember when my family moved into a council house. Someone had gone in and pulled at the wallpaper. Not removed it totally, but took strips off to make it look shabby.

No one private renting is expected to fully replace flooring and repaper/paint walls when they pick the keys up.
But you would be ok with people in social housing having to spend serious money doing the same, only to be evicted 3 years later. That makes no sense.

It’s a rabbit hole. If the system was changed to something different there’d be opportunity to change the “rules” re. furnished or not.

Yellowshirt · Yesterday 19:30

ExpectMore · Yesterday 18:56

It sounds like your landlord could do better.

Out of curiosity, why is a cleaner needed to clean the kitchen or oven? Why don’t residents just take turns at cleaning it?

I know in any house share I’ve lived in that’s what we’ve done. There’s generally been the odd person that needs reminding more than the others but it tends to work!

Because basically tennants sign a contract which states a weekly cleaner will be provided along with cleaning products for the kitchen so won't lift a finger. Even getting people to empty the bin is virtually impossible and putting the wheelie bin out for a weekly collection is also seen as below most people.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 19:32

Yellowshirt · Yesterday 19:27

I'm lucky as we have our own bathrooms.

Thankyou for sharing your experience as people need to understand what hmos are really like and how unsuitable they are for pensioners like someone earlier suggested.

You hit the nail on the head . They are grim and depressing.

I wish more people would speak out about it. It is not acceptable.
My partner used to live in a 2 bed flat. The landlord wanted to sell up, and the new owner turned it into an HMO. 6 beds. All shoebox rooms, what was the lounge is now 2 bedrooms.
It is like living in a shitty hotel. But without the lounge and bar downstairs.

ExpectMore · Yesterday 19:32

Yellowshirt · Yesterday 19:30

Because basically tennants sign a contract which states a weekly cleaner will be provided along with cleaning products for the kitchen so won't lift a finger. Even getting people to empty the bin is virtually impossible and putting the wheelie bin out for a weekly collection is also seen as below most people.

Wow. Thats incredible. I’d have thought they’d want to do it and look after their own private and common living spaces given it’s literally where they live!

TurquoiseDress · Yesterday 19:44

YANBU

I’m wondering what we’ll do for our DC, they are early secondary/late primary age and we still cannot ‘upgrade’ to a 3 bed semi

Live in SE London, property prices are bloody mental

It would be wonderful to offer them to continue living with us in their late teens/early 20s so they are not paying extortionate rent in some crappy rental

But the reality we don’t even really have the space for all of us now (2 bed split split level maisonette)

Depressing all round

mrsm43s · Yesterday 20:31

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:02

I gave you an example of a friend of mine who did make provision. How do you know other pensioners in SH didnt do the same thing but were penalized for it. Do you know them all personally

Your example was of someone who had £29k (total, not per annum) in a pension. That's not making sensible provision for maybe 30 years of retirement! It's just over 1 year of minimum wage. That's an example who hasn't made adequate provision (or even close) for retirement. Why do you keep bleating on about this as some kind of 'gotcha', it isn't

mrsm43s · Yesterday 20:34

JenniferBooth · Yesterday 19:07

Funny how @mrsm43s wants all things "equal" and everybody to have to live in HMOs (apart from those who have reproduced natch) but i would bet money she wouldnt say Oh private tenants get a place thats already furnished so social housing tenants should too

Could you please quit accusing me of thinking or wanting random things that I have not said or even shown any indication of thinking.

I've said I don't think that benefit claiming pensioners can expect to have a better standard of living than the tax payers that are supporting them can afford. That is all.

3DPrintedDragon · Yesterday 20:37

mrsm43s · Yesterday 20:31

Your example was of someone who had £29k (total, not per annum) in a pension. That's not making sensible provision for maybe 30 years of retirement! It's just over 1 year of minimum wage. That's an example who hasn't made adequate provision (or even close) for retirement. Why do you keep bleating on about this as some kind of 'gotcha', it isn't

Many people can't make what you consider sensible provisions.
Some people will never earn more than minimum wage.

Yet you expect people on NMW jobs like carers, HCAs, the people delivering your food/parcels etc to put up with the bare minimum of a teeny room in an HMO where they are expected to share a toilet with 8 other people.