Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ru Paul

15 replies

Catarinabella · Today 20:06

I’m prepared to be shot down in flames, but is RubPauls drag race the equivalent to the black and white minstrel show? maybe I should have posted this on the feminist board. Feel it’s just such an awful parody of women.

OP posts:
maowmaow · Today 20:14

I think it’s past its sell by date for sure

whiteroseredrose · Today 20:24

In my opinion, yes.

JHound · Today 20:26

Catarinabella · Today 20:06

I’m prepared to be shot down in flames, but is RubPauls drag race the equivalent to the black and white minstrel show? maybe I should have posted this on the feminist board. Feel it’s just such an awful parody of women.

A minstrel show, also called minstrelsy, was an American form of theater developed in the early 19th century.[1] The shows were performed by mostly white actors wearing blackface makeup for the purpose of portraying racial stereotypes of African Americans. Minstrel shows stereotypedblack people as dimwitted, lazy, buffoonish, greedy, cowardly, superstitious, and happy-go-lucky.[2][3] The shows aimed to confirm racist perceptions that black people were not civilized enough to be treated as equals.

To answer your question no, no it’s not.

Blackface - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackface

Nothavingfunrightnow · Today 20:28

I agree 100% and have had this opinion for years.

JHound · Today 20:29

(Also to be clear not all drag performers are men who wear feminine attire. There are Drag Kings and Femme Queens (female drag queens)).

I guess you could argue that Pantomime is the same as Black and White minstrels…

Petrolitis · Today 20:29

JHound · Today 20:26

A minstrel show, also called minstrelsy, was an American form of theater developed in the early 19th century.[1] The shows were performed by mostly white actors wearing blackface makeup for the purpose of portraying racial stereotypes of African Americans. Minstrel shows stereotypedblack people as dimwitted, lazy, buffoonish, greedy, cowardly, superstitious, and happy-go-lucky.[2][3] The shows aimed to confirm racist perceptions that black people were not civilized enough to be treated as equals.

To answer your question no, no it’s not.

And Ru Paul's show aims to present cartoonish stereotypical views of women to confirm misogynistic perceptions.

It is exactly the same.

It is just less acceptable to be rascist these days, but misogyny is still very much supported.

Drag is womanface.

KnickerlessParsons · Today 20:31

I think it’s been axed, hasn’t it? About bloody time too.

Shedmistress · Today 20:31

Id be happy if I never saw a drag queen again in my life. Horrendous 'entertainment' for misogynist fools.

JHound · Today 20:32

Petrolitis · Today 20:29

And Ru Paul's show aims to present cartoonish stereotypical views of women to confirm misogynistic perceptions.

It is exactly the same.

It is just less acceptable to be rascist these days, but misogyny is still very much supported.

Drag is womanface.

If you think that’s what the show does you should try watching it. Drag, specifically male drag queens is NOT about “presenting and reinforcing stereotypical views of women”. It’s art, performance and in many (though not all cases) feminine expression. Which has nothing to do with depictions of women.

JHound · Today 20:34

KnickerlessParsons · Today 20:31

I think it’s been axed, hasn’t it? About bloody time too.

It hasn’t been axed. It’s been dropped from the BBC due to lack of budget but will be on WOW presents. RuPaul’s paid for streaming service.

MaybeSheBoughtIt · Today 20:35

JHound · Today 20:32

If you think that’s what the show does you should try watching it. Drag, specifically male drag queens is NOT about “presenting and reinforcing stereotypical views of women”. It’s art, performance and in many (though not all cases) feminine expression. Which has nothing to do with depictions of women.

Edited

That’s exactly what it is though Confused
I’ve watched it.

Always baffled by those who see it as a progressive art form, when in reality it’s so regressive and sexist.

jeaux90 · Today 20:36

Agree it’s sexist and outdated

singthing · Today 20:38

"It’s art, performance and in many (though not all cases) feminine expression."

Yes, I find stage names like "Anna Bortion", "Miss Carriage" and "Amber Alert" so artistic and feminine.

Also when they liken women to "fish" or "fishy" in reference to vaginas.

It's all so heartwarming and arty, fun for all the family!

putyourshoesonnow · Today 20:50

Yup totally agree - it’s womanface.
I don’t understand the blindspot that allows drag to remain mainstream entertainment, whilst imitating any other group with protected characteristics is so unacceptable. Pure misogyny.

Waitingfordoggo · Today 20:52

YANBU, it’s insulting.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread