Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse Christmas visits because of the family dogs?

105 replies

Xmasinkennels · Yesterday 17:35

So the Christmas plans have started. MIL thinks she is in charge of everyone’s schedules and movements 24-26 dec.

Last year we declined as they all have dogs!

This year she is trying to insist on various times at various peoples houses and I’ve said no ! We can’t be around any of the dogs!

We’ve offered to host here on Xmas eve or Boxing Day but that’s an absolute no as nobody can leave their beloved pets.

She can’t/wont accept that we just don’t like their dogs. MIL has two yappy snappy yorkies. SIL has four dogs. BIL 1 has three. BIL 2 has one. None are well trained and they all smell and it’s just not festive to me at all!!!

We offered alternatives! AIBU to stick to my guns on this

OP posts:
Metalmotha · Today 09:47

BakersKitchen · Today 06:55

I think a lot of the points is that it’s not reasonable to expect the OP to tolerate 10 dogs and yes, it would be kinder to leave them at home so everyone can participate and enjoy Christmas.

And you can’t get away from the fact that 10 dogs in any confined space will stink to high heaven.

Dogs can only be left for a max of 4 hours. And the smell will depend on the dogs and how small the house is. OP has said MziL and BIL have large houses

BakersKitchen · Today 10:21

Metalmotha · Today 09:47

Dogs can only be left for a max of 4 hours. And the smell will depend on the dogs and how small the house is. OP has said MziL and BIL have large houses

They can absolutely left for longer than this particularly as a one off. Dog owners can pop back and let out for wee etc if they are worried.

BakersKitchen · Today 10:21

Metalmotha · Today 09:44

But pets have needs and they can’t be left alone lone for more than 4 hours. Everyone else is ok with the arrangement and wants the dogs there. What’s sad is the OP thinks she can control the situation because she hates the dogs. Maybe the rest of the family prefer the dogs. DH is going don’t really does seem an OP issue this one

Bringing pets should be a 100% yes situation otherwise they don’t come. If someone is not comfortable the polite thing to do is not to bring it, not to make that person feel unable to attend.

Balloonhearts · Today 10:28

Absolutely not. I love dogs and have dogs but that many untrained dogs in a confined space, plus children is a recipe for disaster.

Obviously I get that they can't be left all day and they can't get a dog sitter over Christmas day and boxing day but I'd rather just not go, and see them in between Christmas and New year for lunch out or something.

ThatIsABigSon · Today 11:58

How far away do you live from each other? Could someone go and let the dogs out half way thro8gh the day if needed?

It's a shame the dogs aren't well trained enough to be left alone for the day.

I love dogs and everyone in my family has a dog but they are trained to within an inch of their lives and are able to spend a whole day alone if needed incase of emergencies.

YANBU to not want to be around badly trained dogs

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread