Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your dad didnt bother with you, then showed up 20 years later asking for a kidney for his child - would you say yes?

163 replies

hotmumshit · Today 15:55

Not a real scenario, watching eastenders, and have thought about being asked to donate something to an unknown sibling

I dunno, I dont know if I would 🤔

OP posts:
ClearFruit · Today 19:04

No

godmum56 · Today 19:07

Becuriousnotjudgemental1980 · Today 18:51

In the case of eastenders. It’s literally a cheek swab and and a blood draw. I’d do that. I’d do bone marrow as well. Or liver. I’d be hearty with kidneys because what if my other one failed??

that's the screening process, not the donation.

HollyhocksandPeons · Today 19:07

Ladywindermeresbroom · Today 15:58

Nope, I'm not a source of spare parts for anyone.

US of A and Canada beg to differ - I just watched a horrid podcast about the US and their hospital 'donation teams'.....
Thank God for UK, thank God for the NHS and even thank God for the private sector nephrologists, for it was one of them who threw the evil plan of corrupt Nigerian minister to rob a poor Nigerian of a kidney (transplantation were to be in Wellington Hospital).

GingersOwner26 · Today 19:10

NotAnotherScarf · Today 16:24

Storyline stolen from Rizzoli and Isles. Isles discovered her biological mother who rejects her, then comes back for a kidney...all her friends say no

I was thinking Lost, Anthony Cooper reaching out to Locke for a kidney and then pissing off.

lisaloo88 · Today 19:12

Absolutely not

MaidOfSteel · Today 19:14

I am close to 3 people who have received organ transplants and think donation is such an important thing. But in the scenario the OP has described, even I would struggle to say yes.

I’d absolutely do a live donation of a kidney to my loved ones. I think there’s also a scheme where a non-matching relative of someone waiting for a transplant can donate to a stranger and the patient can receive a donated from elsewhere. Like an organ swap, I guess. It’s hard to explain!

Becuriousnotjudgemental1980 · Today 19:15

godmum56 · Today 19:07

that's the screening process, not the donation.

Maybe a blood draw is simplifying it. I think you have to take medicine a few days and then it’s just a blood donation. A friend did it and said it took about 5 hours.

musicforthesoul · Today 19:21

I'd donate stem cells, but I'd do that for a stranger anyway and have been on the donor register since I was 18.

Kidney absolutely no way.

Uricon2 · Today 19:23

Snippit · Today 18:45

No way! The only people I’d help are my hubby and daughter. After my late father died an autopsy and a coroner was involved, after having a massive stroke whilst being given anaesthetic. Unfortunately he had conditions we weren’t aware of and these were the issue.

I found it very hard to accept that his body had been violated during the autopsy, it freaked me out. I’m not religious by a long shot, but I’ve made it known to everyone that I don’t want ANY of my organs donating to complete strangers. I can’t explain why I feel like this. My husband has an organ donor card, I’ve explained to him I still have to give permission regarding his organs, and I highly doubt I could do it, there is something that stops me that I can’t quite explain 🤷‍♀️

You are of course entitled to your feelings. I agreed to a medical post mortem for my late DH and it was hard but I did it for what they could find out to help others. After death (and I really think it would be properly certified in this country) I see me as spare parts and if they can save someone, great. I don't think though that most of mine would be much good to anyone now, but I carried a donor card from the age of 5 (and I did understand what it meant)

70isaLimitNotaTarget · Today 19:52

hotmumshit · Today 16:46

And I bet you didnt think your health condition would have any upsides!

(Hoping this comes across in the lighthearted way i intend to!)

I cannot donate anything due to a blood transfusion I had.
I feel like going into the Blood Donations with a Brian Blessed Voice saying "What do you MEAN you won't accept my blood - it is quality" but obviously they have rules and thems the rules .

I used to donate blood back in the day

70isaLimitNotaTarget · Today 19:56

bananaobama · Today 18:39

Non, nein, no, nao, nope,

So can we say that's a "no" or d'you want a bit of time to think 😉

Bogliasco · Today 19:58

Nope!

Ladywindermeresbroom · Today 20:06

HollyhocksandPeons · Today 19:07

US of A and Canada beg to differ - I just watched a horrid podcast about the US and their hospital 'donation teams'.....
Thank God for UK, thank God for the NHS and even thank God for the private sector nephrologists, for it was one of them who threw the evil plan of corrupt Nigerian minister to rob a poor Nigerian of a kidney (transplantation were to be in Wellington Hospital).

😮

New posts on this thread. Refresh page