Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say unsolicited advice is unhelpful for new mums?

4 replies

Pellig · Today 14:04

If there is a new mum in your life, please don’t send her unsolicited “helpful advice”. By all means, if she asks for help, give it; if she asks for advice, get stuck in and fill your boots. Offer help.
But if she’s getting on and doing her best, unsolicited advice can feel like overstepping. Sending an article, an Instagram reel or a list of things she could be doing differently isn’t really that different from being the person who says the baby looks cold or asks why they can’t have a kiss.
And honestly, at 7am, after being up all night, opening a message with some Instagram woman explaining the thing that “saved her sanity” is not what anyone needs.
It’s not that the advice is necessarily bad. It’s that nobody asked for it.
And I don’t care if you’re her best mate, her mum, her mother-in-law, or an aunt or uncle who desperately wants the best for their niece or new nephew. The best thing you can do is make Mum feel supported, not undermined, by sending advice out of the blue.
There’s a difference between being there for someone and constantly offering your opinion on how they could be doing things differently.
If she asks, help. If she says she’s struggling, offer something practical. But if she’s getting on with it, trust her to ask when she wants your input.
Sometimes supporting a new mum means knowing when not to offer advice.

OP posts:
OtterlyMad · Today 16:48

I agree, especially in this day and age where you can just Google problems and instantly get dozens of different ideas - the likelihood is, whatever unsolicited advice someone is about to give me, I’ve already heard/read it!!

Error404FucksNotFound · Today 16:52

Well yes, 'beak out' is just good advice generally.

Mycatisreal · Today 16:55

Totally agree. Butt out unless you’re asked something specifically.

Bumble2016 · Today 16:59

Forever remember that you're an expert in how to raise YOUR OWN children. Consider yourself a novice with everyone else's 👍

New posts on this thread. Refresh page