Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you have ds back in this situation?

17 replies

Pizzard · 07/08/2026 17:09

This may be long but don't want to drip feed

My DS is 17. He’s 18 right at the end of the month. It's been a hard few years with him

He always struggled in school and was eventually diagnosed with dyslexia and dyscalculia which took a while as he would often mask it by messing about and just refusing to do the work, all through primary this was missed but in year 7 he was diagnosed and things got a bit better until he was bullied and school didn’t do anything as the boys said it was banter I think it affected him much more than he let on

At 13 that's when I first noticed a change but it may have been before that. He was just angry all the time and sneaky and hanging around with older lads then things escalated and he was school refusing into drugs and verbally abusive to me and his younger siblings. I took him to the gp when he’d agree incase he was depressed but nothing was done i felt like o was time wasting if anything.

At 15 he was permanently excluded for having weed in school- in his jacket pocket. He said he didn't know it was in there and he wasn't purposely taking it to school and I asked them for another chance but they said no and reported it to safeguarding SS (who were also useless tbh) and police who had a talk with him about dealing and county lines just a warning, it was only a big not a dealer amount but school were doing it as a just in case. He then went to a PRU and was around other troubled children and his issues got so much worse

He stole my card and spent it all on weed, he began self harming (both home and school) if I said no to giving him money and sometimes I just did so things didn't esculate. He punched holes in walls, wouldn't shower, threw things and trashed his room and broke his tv by throwing something at it, he hit me etc probably more too that I don't know about bur he said things I don't know if to shock me for a reaction or if it was true

I was constantly anxious around him and felt he was ruining my younger childrens childhood and sending the wrong message to dd about having a violent man around even though he was my son he was 6ft from being 15 and probably teller now

For months last year I was begging everyone for help and thus time last year he went into supported living with support workers around at all times and strict rules. The first few months were awful but he later bonded with his keyworker and he's been a positive male figure which he didn't have before.

He's went to the GP and has anti depressants and he's also stopped the drugs, he says he's not done them for 3 months and I believe him just because of how he is now he's a different person to him a year ago. He comes over now and he's just do much calmer and no longer angry at me for “getting rid of him” which he was before. He got himself a shelf stacking job at tesco and he's worked there for a month or so and loves it

His support workers have mentioned him possibly having a learning disability just because of things he does for example when he cooks he just grabs the hot food with his hands and burns himself despite being told to use other things many times this is just one example. I don't know how to go about him getting a diagnosis as all I've found on Google is for children and his support workers have said it's mostly diagnosed young and then I feel guilty as his sister is only 11 months younger so may have taken attention from him somehow but I had no concerns when he was young bar speech delay and he was late potty training but that's it

They have said though that typically these placements don't last longer than a year or 2 usually until they're 18 unless it's really needed like if they have SEN at 16/17 it's usually for life skills then they move on. They've said the council will house him but as a single man it will take a while and will probably be in a hostel before then or they'll recommend a shared house

DS doesn't want either a hostel or a shared house he doesn't want to share a space with people he doesn't know, atm he has his own room with a bed and kitchen appliances etc and a small bathroom but its just him in the space.
i also don't know how capable he’ll be living on his own if he did have a flat and I just worry he goes completely back to how he was before

Would you have him back in this situation if it came to it? wwyd?

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 07/08/2026 17:18

No.

because at the moment he is out and us supported and is being independent.

a shared house or a hostel will have a private bedroom for him and shared spaces and he will begin to learn to get along with others that are not his family.

my dd had this when at uni and it really does help them grow up. There are arguments about keeping things clean but it’s not his mum nagging him. He’ll see others leaving dishes not washed and feel how annoying it is and want to tell them off.

it’s genuinely a really good personal growth situation and if there are people the same age in the shared house maybe he’ll make some friends.

it might not work out. But try it first.

Curleywoo · 07/08/2026 17:23

No I think you need to push for as much as you can.
Too easy for this to be handed back to you.
You have had years of abuse and your other children deserve to continue to have peace.
I would say No.

FaceIt · 07/08/2026 17:40

It sounds like he’s come a long way.

I would have him back purely based on the fact that he will be back to mixing with a lot of undesirables and it’s very likely he will be back to square one.

BUT if he doesn’t conform he is out. You’ve done that before so he knows you could easily do it again.

LemmyNa · 07/08/2026 17:45

I work in London in health and often work with young people similar to your son. The people suggesting he has learning needs (and if suspected an intellectual disability), this needs to be referred on to paediatrics/ CAMHS or the transitions team (who may be able to do an assessment in the context of highlighting what support will be needed as he gets older.) Reading your post before you said LD, I was actually wondering about ADHD as a possibility, if learning doesn’t seem a global difficulty for him it is possible that impulsivity may be driving some of that behaviour. Learning disability can be diagnosed at any age but it is generally picked up in childhood because school would be very difficult and /or usually they may be co-inciding health concerns.

You need to be under a team within health (which presumably you are already given the level of input), he needs a medical health review - if you have nobody to speak to about this currently go to the GP and explain the situation.

havr you been offered NVR courses etc before the suggestion your son moves home? Has his social worker spoke with you and him about how moving home could work, particularly with other young people in the house? I’m so shocked if not, because this is the basic responsibility of the SW to determine if he is safe enough to come home given the potential risk to other children on the house, it’s not supposed to be just your/your sons decision without input from other services.

WhatNoRaisins · 07/08/2026 17:45

I'm not a great believer in the idea that you can help a child by letting them use you as a punching bag whether that's physically or emotionally. In the long run this sort of placement is likely to be the best option for him and for your family relationships in the future.

Cactus09 · 07/08/2026 17:51

Yes I would have my son back at home in those circumstances. You've both had a really rough time but he is a young adult who has had difficulties and is trying to recover. (I've gone through 5 years with a psychotic young adult but we have come out the other side. It was hell. But he's a decent young man now and I'm proud of us both for surviving)

Eviebeans · 07/08/2026 17:56

No because if you house him now there is no pathway for him to move on to independent living

Thepeopleversuswork · 07/08/2026 17:56

I don’t know the answer OP but credit to your son, it does sound like he has come a long way. Hope he continues to improve and best of luck.

saraclara · 07/08/2026 18:02

Eviebeans · 07/08/2026 17:56

No because if you house him now there is no pathway for him to move on to independent living

That, I think. It's tough, but once he's out of the system, he won't get back in again.

At this point he will be getting LA accommodation, and reasonably promptly. If he comes home to you and it doesn't work out, he'll go right to the bottom of the housing list, without the priority status that he has now. It could be many years before he has somewhere to live away from you.

My only concern would be who he'd be sharing a house or hostel with. If he's only recently come off drugs, he might find it hard not to be influenced by others.

ohsotired2022 · 07/08/2026 18:32

Yes.
I would as it sounds like he has really turned things around.
I would be really clear with him though that if the old behaviours reemerge then he can’t stay.
I would look for him to have an ND / ID assessment

PashaMinaMio · 07/08/2026 18:37

No I would mot let him home again.

Worrieddancemum · 07/08/2026 18:38

No 100 times over. They can support him to access housing association property where he will be classed as high need. If he comes home he will never get housed via the council as he won’t be a priority

WhatsHerNameThingummy · 07/08/2026 18:39

I have no relevant experience but I’d consider how much better life has been for my other kids. If things are much better without him, I wouldn’t take the risk of having him back. I would however take a keen and close interest in his hostel accommodation and let him come over for dinner say four times a week and perhaps stay weekends - if he can prove he stays clean and respectful he can return

Pizzard · 07/08/2026 18:41

His SW hasn't mentioned him moving back in I'm just thinking about it and haven't mentioned it to ds yet. I just am a bit worried in case he goes back to how he was if he does get his own flat (which I know would be very rare) or just in a hostel as he is easily influenced especially by older people and he'll likely have not turned 18 that long ago if he moves in a few weeks as he's not 18 til the end of the month

CAMHS we're involved ages and ages ago but were useless mostly due to him not engaging so nothing really was done or mentioned

I don't know about a learning difficulty but touching food that's clearly hot multiple times on different occasions doesn't sound typical its more something a young child would do. He only gets one bus because he knows the route, any other busses he won't because he says it's confusing I don't know if its linked to his dyslexia/dyscalculia though. He isnt good with money and sends a lot of it on energy drinks/ plastic collectable items and just anything really and then is short on food etc

OP posts:
BasketCaseBug · Yesterday 07:50

I wouldn't because he will get his own accommodation much easier from a hostel than from living with you. If you have him back it will be difficult to get him to leave in future.

Wingingit73 · Yesterday 19:07

No. If you allow him back you are facilitating. He has to do this but you can help and support him.

WallaceinAnderland · Yesterday 19:12

No. His violence towards you is unacceptable and you need to protect your other child.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread