Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my son shouldn't share a room with his cousin?

79 replies

Sophiehoney · Yesterday 21:32

My husband's sister has two kids the exact same age as my kids, but opposite genders.
They live about two and a half hours away so we see them regularly but not that often. Usually during the Easter, Summer and Christmas Holidays, so about 3 times a year. They stay in MIL's holiday caravan in a nearby site.
The kids and adults all get on great.
This year, DH suggested to them that the kids have a sleepover at ours while they are here, which would be fun for the kids and would give them a night to go out. This was enthusiastically accepted by kids and adults. He has said they can either sleep indoors, sharing bedrooms with our kids or camp in the garden in tents if it stays nice.
I'm very happy with this accept the thing is, DH thinks it would be fine for the two 13 year olds, of opposite genders, to share a bedroom or tent. I'm really uncomfortable with this and think it's a bad idea. I've suggested that the two younger ones share and the older two sleep apart, maybe one on the sofa or something.
DH thinks I'm being weird and paranoid and that they're cousins so it's fine, and I'd be spoiling their fun, but I just think it's inappropriate.
DH says he doesn't know how he's supposed to suggest this to his sister and BIL.
AIBU?

OP posts:
BabblingBiddy · Today 04:00

Sophiehoney · Yesterday 22:24

One boy, one girl, in one room, both 13

Your said you have 2 DC each, so there has to be more than 1 girl and 1 boy.
How old and what sex are they all? I'd personally say all girls together. And all boys together. Unless the others are babies/toddlers and likely to wake in the night.

That's how all our family camping trips/sleepovers/holidays have always been arranged.

Chickadee26 · Today 04:14

Girls together and boys together.

Bridesmaidorexfriend · Today 04:45

firstofallimadelight · Yesterday 21:50

Remember that post a few months ago about the cousins that slept together in their teens?

it’s probably fine but if it makes you uncomfortable do girls in one room boys in another.

First thing I thought of.

I also wouldn’t be comfortable and it’s honestly icky and gross that you have to question whether it’s appropriate but I think it really does protect everyone to just split them up based on gender. Girls tent/boys tent etc

WhatTheHellsGoingOn · Today 05:19

Let me guess - you have the teenaged boy? I’d find it really odd that your husband would suggest his daughter share a room with a boy that age. It’s so naive for him not to have a clue how inappropriate and potentially harmful this is

sashh · Today 05:53

I wouldn't put them in a room together.

But I would allow all four to share a room.

BravasPatatas · Today 06:01

bitmiffed26 · Yesterday 22:52

I have a nephew who is 14, my daughters are 12 and 8.
his bedroom is huge. He has a sofa bed in there, as well as his own double bed.
sometimes when my children sleep over at my sisters house they will sleep on the sofa bed, sometimes he doesn’t want them in his room and they’ll sleep in the spare room.
my girls would always choose to share his room if they could though.
no changing in front of each other takes place, it wouldn’t regardless of sex.
it has never once crossed my mind to think anything other than it being a cousin sleepover.
we are an incredibly close family, and see each other weekly.

But that’s both your daughters together sharing with him, isn’t it? Not one teenage daughter sharing with one teenage male cousin.

anotherdaytosmile · Today 06:06

JemimaTiggywinkles · Yesterday 23:33

We all take risks constantly. I had a friend who died in a car crash when we were teens but I don’t use that as a reason why no teenager should ever go in a car. My uncle drowned when he was 18 but as a child my mum still allowed me to swim in the sea. You can’t let the potential of a tragic outcome rob you of all the good things in life.

Those are unforeseen tragedies and I’m so sorry you experienced this. However, this is foreseen and can be managed with boundaries

Inmyuggs · Today 06:10

User1839423790 · Yesterday 21:43

It’s not appropriate. I was sexually assaulted by my cousin at a similar age in my own home. You need to protect your children and your DH will just have to suck it up.

But not everyone is out to sexually assult others.
Ask the kids.
I think living with that mentality isnt healthy.

Toddlergrumps · Today 06:22

My SIL does a cousin sleep over every 6 months (DH one of 6), mainly to give her siblings a break (DN is 17 and pretty independent now but loves a sleepover). DS (2YO) went to his first last month and we stayed nearby, he loved it!
She puts blow up mattresses /camp beds on the floor in the living room and all the cousins sleep downstairs. They watch films and have snacks. I know last time SIL slept downstairs with them so DS could join in, he had a fab time (one of the few times he’s slept through the night - apparently did 8-8 😬). Cousins ranged at the last one from 2-17 but before DS it was 5-17 (there are 7 of them).

purplepuffa · Today 06:37

dancingdeidre · Yesterday 21:47

I think you should say no and spare the cousins the embarrassment of having to say they aren't happy. . Either put siblings together or same sex cousins, or even put the 4 of them in a big tent. But not the teenagers together.

This.

I used to sleep in the same room as my cousin as a kid but we were close from babies and saw each other several times a week so it was more like a sibling.

These guys only see each other 3 times a year. I think at 13 that is a not a close enough relationship to share opposite sex bedrooms. They should be separate.

user1492757084 · Today 06:37

I'd be fine with that.

I would have useful conversation to the two - about where they would each like to have their private space to dress and have private time, given that they are older and more modest.

Therefore allocated space alone and shared space.

Remind your son to be respectful of his cousin having alone time in the bathroom and when she needs to change.... just the same as the respect he welcomes for his own self now that he is older.
.

Sassylovesbooks · Today 07:16

Girls together in one room and boys in the other, regardless of their age. Unless you have a massive gap in ages. I wouldn't ask the 13 year olds what they'd like to do. They may say yes, because they don't want to appear 'mean' towards their cousin, when in reality they'd rather not share.

Overthehillmum63 · Today 07:24

MyDarlingWhatIfYouFly · Yesterday 21:37

I think the opinion of both 13yr olds is important to take into account. If they are both comfortable and they are not getting changed around each other then I wouldn’t worry.

My 12 year old would never share a room or tent with any of his female cousins and he’s very clear on that.

I think we should all listen to your 12 year old, of course it’s not appropriate for them to share a room. I’m astonished anyone even needs advice on this!

ShiftySquirrel · Today 07:28

Ask the children. If one of them is uncomfortable split them up.

Mine mostly stopped sharing with opposite sex cousins/friends around that age - but occasionally all four still crash in one room, usually the one with the telly/computer games... (3 girls/1 boy).

Goditsmemargaret · Today 07:29

Separate them.

It's rare for something sexual to occur between cousins but it happens. In fact there was a thread about this very thing a few weeks ago. The OP's DH slept with his cousin as a teen and they thought at the time they were in love, forbidden love obviously.

lessglittermoremud · Today 07:58

I think if you ask them, they’ll say no anyway. There is 0 chance my 13 year old boy would be comfortable in that situation, he would share with a male younger cousin at a push, but he’s going through that hulking silent stage where the thought of spending time in close proximity to another human is a big ask 🥴
Put all 4 in together like a big sleep over, or do same sex sleeping arrangements.

ACR7 · Today 07:59

Depends on how well they know each other and their relationship. I had a male cousin similar age and we grew up together. We would share if we stayed at nannas at same time. We used to have a real laugh. Absolutely no issue at all. I had other cousins I wasn’t close to and would not have been comfortable at all sharing a room with them.

RoseOliviaAu · Today 08:04

Theyre cousins and it’s for one night…

FourSevenFour · Today 08:05

Sounds that you will complicate their friendships because of some artificial fear.

LightlyRoamingOcelots · Today 08:08

There's no point having a sleepover and then being in separate bedrooms. However I wouldn't have just 2 kids of opposite sex in a room just the two of them over the age of 11. They should be all in one room for the sleepover, with as many inflatable mattresses as needed

mylifeisexams · Today 08:17

Why can’t the same sex cousins share, I don’t get that. So if you have a 13 yo girl and they have a (say) 10 yo girl surely the girls room together. It’s weird to put the 13 yos together just because they’re the same age.

We have similar and we always do the above. But ours have grown up together and are like siblings, and at grandparents house they all sleep together in one big room (age 14-16 now).

Sinescure · Today 08:24

Yeah I wouldn't put the female cousin in that position because she may be uncomfortable with it but not feel she can say so.

Sinescure · Today 08:27

Bridesmaidorexfriend · Today 04:45

First thing I thought of.

I also wouldn’t be comfortable and it’s honestly icky and gross that you have to question whether it’s appropriate but I think it really does protect everyone to just split them up based on gender. Girls tent/boys tent etc

I don't think it's icky and gross. They're just a bit too old regardless of remote possibilities of bad things happening. They are old enough to have reached puberty and it's the adults' job to protect them and teach them boundaries around privacy even if it doesn't seem strictly necessary yet. Think OP's DH is being a bit clueless tbh.

ImogenBrocklehurst · Today 08:27

I would have shared with my cousin at the same age, but we were, and still are, close. Depends on the relationship and how they feel about it.

OnlyOneAdda · Today 08:30

You haven’t said how old the younger children are - usually a sleepover is more fun if everyone is in together.