Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not wanting contact after my estranged mother's death?

75 replies

ForUmberOtter · 04/07/2026 07:24

This is a long one, so apologies in advance.
I'm in my late 30s happily married with young children of my own, and I've been estranged from my parents since I was about 25. I still have some contact with my three older brothers, but it's fairly low-key.

A few days ago one of my brothers rang to tell me Mum had died.

I messaged my dad to say I was sorry for his loss. He replied saying he'd like to see me.
The problem is... I don't want to.

In fact, if I'm being completely honest, I'm not even sure I want to go to the funeral.
The backstory is this.

I didn't grow up in what most people would call a normal family. We were not and are still not rich in cash more so assets and name not saying they’re struggling but they’re not cash rich but do own everything they have as it’s been in the family for generations. We weren't just comfortably off. My family own an estate that's been in the family for generations. The house I grew up in parts of it date back to 13th century. There was always a huge emphasis on family history, tradition, reputation and doing things "properly". I know that probably sounds ridiculous to a lot of people, but it was simply normal to me growing up.

I went to St Andrews, where there were plenty of people from similar backgrounds, and that's where I met my now husband.
He came from a perfectly lovely family, but a completely different world to mine. His parents both worked, my parents did not work, they did odd bits ie write for random things but never actually had jobs or went to work they were born always home growing up my father spent his time in local politics supporting his friends who were local politicians that sort of thing, played polo, attended horse races etc. DHs family they were comfortably middle class, but there were no country estates, or centuries of family expectations hanging over them. They were warm, welcoming and refreshingly normal.

I fell in love with him.

My parents were less enthusiastic.

At first they dismissed it as a university romance that would obviously fizzle out. Then the comments started. They'd tell me it wouldn't last, that I was making a mistake, that I'd regret throwing my future away. They never seemed interested in whether he made me happy. It was always about whether he was "suitable". They’d rather I married a rich boy from a similar background to me and just got on with life that way.

Nobody ever explicitly said, "He's not wealthy enough," but it didn't need saying. It was obvious. He simply wasn't from the sort of background they'd imagined for me.
Over time I realised there was nothing he could ever do to be accepted because the issue wasn't really him as a person. It was what he represented. I'd stepped away from the life they'd planned for me.

Eventually I stopped trying to convince them.
There wasn't one enormous row where everyone stormed out. It was more that I reached the point where every visit left me upset, every phone call became another conversation about how I was ruining my life, and I simply couldn't do it anymore.
So I chose my relationship.
And yes, in doing so, I chose a life without my parents.

Years later, we're still together. We've built a wonderful life, we've raised children, and the relationship everyone confidently predicted would collapse has turned out to be the best thing that's ever happened to me.
I've also spent time in therapy.

For a long time I carried huge amounts of guilt. I wondered whether I'd overreacted or whether I should have tried harder. Therapy helped me accept that sometimes you can love people but still recognise that having them in your life isn't healthy.

The strange thing is, I don't feel angry anymore.I don't spend my life thinking about them.I don't wish them ill. I don’t want their money or anything. I've simply moved on.

So when my brother rang to tell me Mum had died, I was sad in a strange sort of way. Not because we'd not had a relationship these past years we hadn't but because any tiny possibility that things might one day be different disappeared with that phone call.

I sent Dad a brief message because I genuinely am sorry he's lost his wife. They have always kept contact ie birthdays, they’ve always sent a text etc.
But now he wants to see me.

And I genuinely don't know why.
We've missed Christmases, my wedding, pregnancies, the births of grandchildren... all those opportunities came and went. Nobody ever picked up the phone and said, "Can we try again?"
Now, suddenly, because Mum has died, it feels like everyone expects the past to disappear.
It hasn't.

Part of me thinks I'd only be going to the funeral because it's what's expected of a daughter, not because it reflects the reality of our relationship.

My husband has said he'll support whatever I decide. He's never once encouraged or discouraged contact over the years. My brothers think I should at least meet Dad because I'll never have another opportunity.
Maybe they're right.

Or maybe I've already done my grieving over the family I lost years ago.

AIBU for not wanting to see my dad or even attend the funeral? Has anyone been through something similar and regretted staying away, or regretted going?

OP posts:
nooneliterallyspatouttheirtea · 04/07/2026 08:40

Please bear in mind @ForUmberOtter that many of these replies urging you to be fair, come from posters with no experience of and no idea about why family estrangement is necessary.

RandomMess · 04/07/2026 08:40

I didn’t go to my Mum’s funeral and I was thankful that there was a medical reason why I couldn’t. I don’t regret it and won’t be going to my Dad’s either when the time comes.

usererror99 · 04/07/2026 08:40

At the end of the day they are your parents - she wasn’t Your dad’s wife she was your mother the woman who birthed and raised you. Clearly they were a product of their upbringing and yet you have punished them for it

Gardenisablooming · 04/07/2026 08:51

Imo it would shine him in a bad light if you didn't show at the funeral. He hasn't wanted to see you or your dc before. .I am nc with my dps..I won't be showing up for them dead or alive.

NameChangeAgain48 · 04/07/2026 08:54

I'd go to the funeral and see your dad. I'd do it for myself. I wouldn't take the children . Going doesn't mean you need to rekindle the relationship.

I was estranged from my family for a long time. Mum was diagnosed with a terminal illness and I was tracked down with a message asking me to visit tge hospital. Facing death make people reevaluate things. Mum had major surgery and is still alive today. Originally they gave ger 3 months. We actually have a positive relationship now. Im still guarded but for tge mist part its okay.

Ladybyrd · 04/07/2026 08:56

I think I wouldn’t go to the funeral but I would tell him you’re willing to hear him out, even if not in person. The fact that he’s allowed all those years to go by without an apology or acknowledgment doesn’t bode well, but your mother was also part of that picture. Perhaps he wants to make amends - perhaps he doesn’t - but the not knowing would bother me.

That said, it still took you reaching out first. So yes, I’d say you’re willing to listen to what he has to say - if he can communicate by text, he can say it there. And he wants to see you - does he want to visit or are you being summoned? I can’t say I’d be willing to go too far out of my way but I would hear him out, keeping my expectations low.

Cherrysoup · 04/07/2026 08:58

I agree with pp that seeing your dad at the funeral may be too emotionally charged, so a quiet meet up prior to attending, if that’s what you want, might be best.

If, however, you decide against meeting, as you seem to be saying now, then that’s entirely your decision. I think their behaviour was really awful. Your dad can’t expect anything of you after years of almost no contact.

Waynettaaa · 04/07/2026 09:02

My parents are long gone (who I was close to), but NC with my siblings.

I have no intention of going to any of their funerals and I have requested that my DH does not invite them to mine (not that I'd know 🤣, but I'm 100% sure he'd be respectful of my wishes).

It was still you having to reach out, now that your mother has died. I would not attend her funeral, or give your father the time of day, if it were me.

Ace42 · 04/07/2026 09:07

As someone who was also estranged from both parents who have both since died, you don't have to do anything you don't want to. I chose to go to my mother's funeral but as next of kin to my dad, I didn't even arrange a funeral. He had an unattended cremation. Some family and friends of family have judged me for it but I have my reasons and my brother was in exactly the same mindset as me around it all. I do not regret it, I don't feel sad (except for what I never had in the first place) and I feel no responsibility to appease anyone else. You get one life.

LlynTegid · 04/07/2026 09:07

I think you should consider how your brothers might feel if you did not attend the funeral. Would other people say family friends start asking why, would they have to talk about your estrangement?

You might still choose not to go.

Purplecatshopaholic · 04/07/2026 09:08

If this was me, I wouldn’t see him, and I wouldn’t go to the funeral. I just would not want the associated hassle, guilt trip, etc when I have built a happy life. They could have tried to make up with you, and it doesn’t sound like they bothered, so why start now? They likely want something (and, sorry, but as the only daughter it might be future-caring-related. Fuck that!) Just my views op. I’m sorry you don’t have the parents you deserve, and I’m glad you are happy despite that.

canklesmctacotits · 04/07/2026 09:10

I was estranged from my family for eerily similar reasons to you. I’m older than you, and further down the line.

I think the therapy you’ve had centered your feelings at the time. It probably helped you move forward, feel like you were in control
of your life, helped you make a decision about your future. It’s great your life is stable and you have a loving husband and children.

The therapy wasn’t, however, the sort of wisdom/counsel/advice that sees a whole lifetime and puts things into perspective. (It rarely is.) In my experience of how these relationships - parents versus partner versus grandchildren - pan out, you’re really at the beginning of what will hopefully be decades of relationships. You’re only in your 30s, your children are young still. But you’re still not able to manage the people in your life, hence this post. You still have things to work through and you always will because these are the most important relationships of a person’s life.

You’ll do what you want to do but I will just say life is long, you only have one set of parents. They don’t need to be super close to you, and the relationship doesn’t need to be intimate. But parents are the foundation of our lives, good or bad. Amazing if they’re good; hard work and bad luck if not.

It’s entirely possible to do right by yourself and hedge for your future without betraying the choices you’ve made. Referring to your mum to your dad as “your wife” in circumstances such as yours sounds an awful lot like very effective therapy that you went all in on. It doesn’t sound like a healthy long-term perspective for a woman in her 30s whose only gripe with her parents is that they didn’t/don’t approve of her partner. Like I said, I say this to someone who went through the same thing. There’s more to these relationships than that. Our parents don’t have to approve of our choices, and they don’t have to accept them either. Not approving and not accepting doesn’t mean excommunication to eternity, not attending your own mother’s funeral if only to support your brothers and surviving parent and not regret having done so when you’re out of the whirlwind of young children and have time to think again.

SamphiretheTervosaur · 04/07/2026 09:11

DSis and I are in the same emotional position

I probably would prefer not to attend the funerals of our parents. She will because it's the 'right thing/closure etc'

I don't care. But will probably acquiesce for her sake

I am trying not to resent that in advance...

PermanentTemporary · 04/07/2026 09:13

I don’t think any outcome is unreasonable so I haven’t voted. I would leave the funeral out of it. I definitely wouldn’t go to that. Funerals are important to me but I wouldn’t expect someone who is estranged from me (I have a couple of those) to be there, as a pp said it’s not the place for that.

But yes, a meeting with your dad - perhaps. It clearly would be a generous gesture on your part so it’s really whether the potential negatives for you outweigh that.

Nannyfannybanny · 04/07/2026 09:16

DH, toxic bullying mother,who walked out on her dks,he was 7, went off with another man. Ruined his life. There was no therapy in 1963, no one realised kids needed it
Didn't see her for almost 20 years. Always HER way, she ruined our wedding, then my DSs wedding,lots of lies. He decided to go nc almost 18 years ago, plus with the siblings,who never had a good word to say about her,yet took her side. She died last year,he was going to go to the funeral, our DD had stayed in touch and was going. Not me, because apparently everything was MY fault, but he was told he wouldn't be welcome. His DF who got custody,died 40 years ago. She ruined his life, major serious mental health issues and phobias, some of which continue to this day, over 60 years later. Sending 💐

TinyGingerCat · 04/07/2026 09:25

Only you can guess why he wants to see you and only you can know if you can cope with what he had to say and how the funeral will affect you. I think I’d either say no to both, or yes to speaking to your dad, and then making a decision about whether to attend your mum’s funeral. I’m estranged from one sibling (and ant peace with that) and this has effectively killed the relationship with the other and made my relationship with my mum extremely fragile. I’m 20 years older than you and it hangs over you in ways I hadn’t anticipated. If I had my time again I would have just quietly quit the relationship so it wasn’t so obvious (no one had a huge row but my mum was aware of the disagreement and holds me responsible). Meeting your dad might be a disaster, it might not, but no one on here can predict the outcome.

TheeNotoriousPIG · 04/07/2026 09:25

I would not go. I have found that, if there is a family event that I strongly do not want to go to, I regret going (when I was younger, it was because I was made to go; now that I'm older, my family prefer to guilt-trip me). Having realised that a lot of it is for the sake of Keeping Up Appearances, and family members' attempts to forge relationships that aren't there, I will not be giving in so easily in the future.

If you don't think that you would regret not going to the funeral and/or having contact with your dad, don't go. Don't get involved, and don't let anyone guilt-trip you into going.

If you do decide to get in contact with your dad, I would firstly be asking, "Why now, after all of this time, and everything that he has missed out on in my life?"

fireandlightening · 04/07/2026 09:38

I would go to the funeral and meet my dad, if I were you. Everyone is a product of their circumstances/upbringing. You've broken away from that. They couldn't and haven't. And, as an adult who has a good life, and have found a way out of the constraints of your childhood, you can recognise them, appreciate that they did the best for you that they could, whether that was right or not, but look past it and move on. They thought their way would make you happy, it wasn't for you. You forged your own path. But it isn't like they were neglectful or abusive as parents. It doesn't have to be a big teary reunion, but it could be a chance to have a relationship that is more boundaried and honest.

nooneliterallyspatouttheirtea · 04/07/2026 09:45

canklesmctacotits · 04/07/2026 09:10

I was estranged from my family for eerily similar reasons to you. I’m older than you, and further down the line.

I think the therapy you’ve had centered your feelings at the time. It probably helped you move forward, feel like you were in control
of your life, helped you make a decision about your future. It’s great your life is stable and you have a loving husband and children.

The therapy wasn’t, however, the sort of wisdom/counsel/advice that sees a whole lifetime and puts things into perspective. (It rarely is.) In my experience of how these relationships - parents versus partner versus grandchildren - pan out, you’re really at the beginning of what will hopefully be decades of relationships. You’re only in your 30s, your children are young still. But you’re still not able to manage the people in your life, hence this post. You still have things to work through and you always will because these are the most important relationships of a person’s life.

You’ll do what you want to do but I will just say life is long, you only have one set of parents. They don’t need to be super close to you, and the relationship doesn’t need to be intimate. But parents are the foundation of our lives, good or bad. Amazing if they’re good; hard work and bad luck if not.

It’s entirely possible to do right by yourself and hedge for your future without betraying the choices you’ve made. Referring to your mum to your dad as “your wife” in circumstances such as yours sounds an awful lot like very effective therapy that you went all in on. It doesn’t sound like a healthy long-term perspective for a woman in her 30s whose only gripe with her parents is that they didn’t/don’t approve of her partner. Like I said, I say this to someone who went through the same thing. There’s more to these relationships than that. Our parents don’t have to approve of our choices, and they don’t have to accept them either. Not approving and not accepting doesn’t mean excommunication to eternity, not attending your own mother’s funeral if only to support your brothers and surviving parent and not regret having done so when you’re out of the whirlwind of young children and have time to think again.

Oh dear. So patronising. Bingo for 'you only get one set of parents'

Attenboroughsmistress · 04/07/2026 09:45

It must have been so awful feeling like your parents were willing to lose you for the sake of their own snobbery around your choice of husband. Especially when you had your own children, to feel that bond and know that your parents were apparently fine with breaking their bond with you, never knowing their grandchildren etc. I can totally understand not wanting to go to the funeral, especially if you feel like you’re giving them a “win” for appearances sake when you don’t feel like they deserve it.

On balance, I would meet with your dad, just to give him a chance to mend some old hurts. It’s unlikely he can cause more damage than he has already done is it? And I think you would regret / always wonder otherwise. Better to just get it done and close the chapter in your mind.

Maybe now that both Princes of the Realm have married commoners, and a commoner will be Queen one day, he has realised that their views were outdated and has regrets!

Maybe it was your mother driving it. I often find it is the women in the family who hold up the snobbery the most, particularly if they themselves have socially climbed, because they are more insecure in their position.

Zanatdy · 04/07/2026 09:50

I’d go, and then up to you what happens next, if anything.

whippersnapper55 · 04/07/2026 11:37

OP it's completely your decision if you see your dad and/or go to the funeral. No-one else can tell you what's right or wrong. There are lots of opinions here but no-one has been in your shoes, had your upbringing or parents.

So whatever feels right for you is ok. If you don't want to see him, be honest with your dad that it's not something you want to do. You don't owe him anything and you may well feel that you don't want to disrupt the life you've built for yourself. Go with your gut instinct and look after yourself 💐

Ladybyrd · 04/07/2026 12:57

canklesmctacotits · 04/07/2026 09:10

I was estranged from my family for eerily similar reasons to you. I’m older than you, and further down the line.

I think the therapy you’ve had centered your feelings at the time. It probably helped you move forward, feel like you were in control
of your life, helped you make a decision about your future. It’s great your life is stable and you have a loving husband and children.

The therapy wasn’t, however, the sort of wisdom/counsel/advice that sees a whole lifetime and puts things into perspective. (It rarely is.) In my experience of how these relationships - parents versus partner versus grandchildren - pan out, you’re really at the beginning of what will hopefully be decades of relationships. You’re only in your 30s, your children are young still. But you’re still not able to manage the people in your life, hence this post. You still have things to work through and you always will because these are the most important relationships of a person’s life.

You’ll do what you want to do but I will just say life is long, you only have one set of parents. They don’t need to be super close to you, and the relationship doesn’t need to be intimate. But parents are the foundation of our lives, good or bad. Amazing if they’re good; hard work and bad luck if not.

It’s entirely possible to do right by yourself and hedge for your future without betraying the choices you’ve made. Referring to your mum to your dad as “your wife” in circumstances such as yours sounds an awful lot like very effective therapy that you went all in on. It doesn’t sound like a healthy long-term perspective for a woman in her 30s whose only gripe with her parents is that they didn’t/don’t approve of her partner. Like I said, I say this to someone who went through the same thing. There’s more to these relationships than that. Our parents don’t have to approve of our choices, and they don’t have to accept them either. Not approving and not accepting doesn’t mean excommunication to eternity, not attending your own mother’s funeral if only to support your brothers and surviving parent and not regret having done so when you’re out of the whirlwind of young children and have time to think again.

Forgive me, but you really don’t sound like someone who has been through that at all. By denying her choice of partner, they also deny her children, her whole life.

If you can’t talk about your immediate family to them, if they’re not interested in that, what have you got left? The weather?

So you have to keep up a perfomatory relationship, cowtowing to people who behave despicably. Why? For them? For appearances? Because it certainly doesn’t sound good for you or your own family.

Netcurtainnelly · 04/07/2026 13:03

Perhaps you shouldn't have text.

saraclara · 04/07/2026 13:45

nooneliterallyspatouttheirtea · 04/07/2026 08:40

Please bear in mind @ForUmberOtter that many of these replies urging you to be fair, come from posters with no experience of and no idea about why family estrangement is necessary.

Not all family estrangements are the same as each other. In some cases I'd be screaming 'don't even dream of going' and in others I'd encourage thinking around it.

Those of us with abusive or toxic families/parents tend to assume that other people's experiences are/were the same as ours. But it's way more complex and nuanced than that.