Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not wanting contact after my estranged mother's death?

75 replies

ForUmberOtter · 04/07/2026 07:24

This is a long one, so apologies in advance.
I'm in my late 30s happily married with young children of my own, and I've been estranged from my parents since I was about 25. I still have some contact with my three older brothers, but it's fairly low-key.

A few days ago one of my brothers rang to tell me Mum had died.

I messaged my dad to say I was sorry for his loss. He replied saying he'd like to see me.
The problem is... I don't want to.

In fact, if I'm being completely honest, I'm not even sure I want to go to the funeral.
The backstory is this.

I didn't grow up in what most people would call a normal family. We were not and are still not rich in cash more so assets and name not saying they’re struggling but they’re not cash rich but do own everything they have as it’s been in the family for generations. We weren't just comfortably off. My family own an estate that's been in the family for generations. The house I grew up in parts of it date back to 13th century. There was always a huge emphasis on family history, tradition, reputation and doing things "properly". I know that probably sounds ridiculous to a lot of people, but it was simply normal to me growing up.

I went to St Andrews, where there were plenty of people from similar backgrounds, and that's where I met my now husband.
He came from a perfectly lovely family, but a completely different world to mine. His parents both worked, my parents did not work, they did odd bits ie write for random things but never actually had jobs or went to work they were born always home growing up my father spent his time in local politics supporting his friends who were local politicians that sort of thing, played polo, attended horse races etc. DHs family they were comfortably middle class, but there were no country estates, or centuries of family expectations hanging over them. They were warm, welcoming and refreshingly normal.

I fell in love with him.

My parents were less enthusiastic.

At first they dismissed it as a university romance that would obviously fizzle out. Then the comments started. They'd tell me it wouldn't last, that I was making a mistake, that I'd regret throwing my future away. They never seemed interested in whether he made me happy. It was always about whether he was "suitable". They’d rather I married a rich boy from a similar background to me and just got on with life that way.

Nobody ever explicitly said, "He's not wealthy enough," but it didn't need saying. It was obvious. He simply wasn't from the sort of background they'd imagined for me.
Over time I realised there was nothing he could ever do to be accepted because the issue wasn't really him as a person. It was what he represented. I'd stepped away from the life they'd planned for me.

Eventually I stopped trying to convince them.
There wasn't one enormous row where everyone stormed out. It was more that I reached the point where every visit left me upset, every phone call became another conversation about how I was ruining my life, and I simply couldn't do it anymore.
So I chose my relationship.
And yes, in doing so, I chose a life without my parents.

Years later, we're still together. We've built a wonderful life, we've raised children, and the relationship everyone confidently predicted would collapse has turned out to be the best thing that's ever happened to me.
I've also spent time in therapy.

For a long time I carried huge amounts of guilt. I wondered whether I'd overreacted or whether I should have tried harder. Therapy helped me accept that sometimes you can love people but still recognise that having them in your life isn't healthy.

The strange thing is, I don't feel angry anymore.I don't spend my life thinking about them.I don't wish them ill. I don’t want their money or anything. I've simply moved on.

So when my brother rang to tell me Mum had died, I was sad in a strange sort of way. Not because we'd not had a relationship these past years we hadn't but because any tiny possibility that things might one day be different disappeared with that phone call.

I sent Dad a brief message because I genuinely am sorry he's lost his wife. They have always kept contact ie birthdays, they’ve always sent a text etc.
But now he wants to see me.

And I genuinely don't know why.
We've missed Christmases, my wedding, pregnancies, the births of grandchildren... all those opportunities came and went. Nobody ever picked up the phone and said, "Can we try again?"
Now, suddenly, because Mum has died, it feels like everyone expects the past to disappear.
It hasn't.

Part of me thinks I'd only be going to the funeral because it's what's expected of a daughter, not because it reflects the reality of our relationship.

My husband has said he'll support whatever I decide. He's never once encouraged or discouraged contact over the years. My brothers think I should at least meet Dad because I'll never have another opportunity.
Maybe they're right.

Or maybe I've already done my grieving over the family I lost years ago.

AIBU for not wanting to see my dad or even attend the funeral? Has anyone been through something similar and regretted staying away, or regretted going?

OP posts:
AgeingGoth · 04/07/2026 07:34

Honestly, I think I’d go to the funeral to say goodbye as that’s how I’d feel but wouldn’t push any further relationship with my father. But it’s how you feel that matters here. Are you still seeing your therapist currently? If you are, this is a good thing to run through with them and discuss what your boundaries are for this scenario.

MrSchubertWhiskers · 04/07/2026 07:42

I haven't been through this, no, but I will say no one can tell you that your feelings are unreasonable. In fact, they seem entirely understandable.

Perhaps you can find out from your brothers why your dad wants to see you. I tend to find that I don't regret decisions I've made, even if they don't work out, if I made them based on the best knowledge I had at the time.

Flowers
Starsnrainbows · 04/07/2026 07:45

YANBU! Your parents sound awful. Snobbery at its finest! For what its worth, I think you've married very well! You're still together and have a wonderful life. Whether you attend the funeral or not is up to you. It may give you closure or it could open up old wounds.

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 04/07/2026 07:45

Was your mum the driver in the dislike of dh?
is the invite to the funeral for you all, or just you?

its hard as it does come across as them being performative with the invite to save face from having to explain why you’re not there.

Snorlaxo · 04/07/2026 07:47

I’m estranged from my parents too and I’ve had the conversation with my brother about the hypothetical funeral situation.

I have been honest and said that I’ve grieved the situation and wouldn’t want to attend the funeral. There’s no need to inform me and that if he (my brother) wants anything from me (other than my attendance at the funeral) then he can contact me. We have other siblings who would attend the funeral too.

My problem with attending would be the expectation that one appearance would lead to pressure for more appearances and I have no desire for reconciliation as I accepted the way things are long ago. I wouldn’t want to waste time updating the surviving parent on what I’ve been up to over the years or inflict them on my lovely adult kids who had a very different childhood to me. They aren’t curious about their grandparents and accept my explanation about why I am NC. There is just too much pain and no awareness about how their attitudes and words have affected me over the years. I accept it and won’t fight that or be made to feel guilty for not pretending that everything is fine and that that the person who passed away deserves fake stories about how great they are.

saraclara · 04/07/2026 08:00

And I genuinely don't know why.
We've missed Christmases, my wedding, pregnancies, the births of grandchildren... all those opportunities came and went. Nobody ever picked up the phone and said, "Can we try again?"

Virtually everyone who posts on Mumsnet about being NC with their parents actively doesn't want family members to pick up the phone and try to rekindle the relationship. And any hapless parent who posts here from the other perspective is robustly told to leave their child alone and to respect that they don't want to hear from them.
Your post indicates that they can't win.

Personally I'd go. You don't indicate the time scale, but your siblings have presumably matured and night be very different people now.
You don't indicate any serious abuse and the NC was purely over their (awful) response to your choice of partner. So I'd go and incidentally show them how wrong they were about your relationship.

BMW58 · 04/07/2026 08:04

Cynical me wonders if your Dad and brothers have an eye on future care as Dad gets older......
Your Mum has gone but there's still a woman in the family......

I'd want to ask Why NOW?

Rubyslipperswitch · 04/07/2026 08:08

I have been no contact with my toxic mother for years now and have no intention of either going to her funeral when she dies or to have any contact again with her side of the family.

I am so much happier and at peace with the constant drama. My parents were abusive and neglectful when I was a child and I still often have nightmares about them. My childhood/teenage years had an incredibly damaging influence on my physical and mental health.

I have come to realise as an adult that because you are related to someone does not automatically mean that you will love them or want/need to have them in your life.

So trust your instincts and don't let anyone guilt trip you into any kind of contact if this is not what you want.

CarpetofBluebells · 04/07/2026 08:10

Personally I'd go to the funeral and talk to your dad. But I'd also have a therapist appointment booked for the next day!

If you decide not to go you cannot get the moment back and it's possible that at some point down the line you'll regret it.

Seventynineisthenew79 · 04/07/2026 08:14

Do you see any other members of that family? Aunts, cousins etc? If you don’t go to the funeral, will you care about their judgement of you afterwards?

BigWig78 · 04/07/2026 08:15

Oh gosh it’s very hard so for that reason I have said YANBU as any decision you make is okay. So perhaps if you can fit it in, return to your counsellor and go over your options to figure out what YOU want to do. And that’s it.
I think I’d err on not going as it would feel performative and maybe hearing the nice things about her when she couldn’t extend that quality towards me or my family would be galling- and I don’t feel a funeral is the place for negative feelings towards the deceased so I’d rather not be there. But if it gives you some kind of closure then for you that is okay as you’re not me and I’m thankfully not in your situation.
Take care of yourself and keep talking as and when you need to. And if you don’t then that’s fine too- she might not be much of a loss as she wasn’t really in your life.

LaurieFairyCake · 04/07/2026 08:15

Snobby aristocrats who never worked ? Who showed no interest in their grandchildren at all - never met them, didn’t come to your wedding?

do whatever YOU want, any obligation ended a long time ago Flowers

Goodmorningeveryone26 · 04/07/2026 08:18

I’ve voted yanbu because your feelings aren’t unreasonable. Feelings never are really. But I do think it would be the right thing to do to see your dad. Maybe he regrets the estrangement. Is there any chance further down the line that you’ll wish you’d heard what he had to say? I find as I get older (late 40s) I’m thinking of my parents in a different way and wishing I had the chance to speak to them
again. Not in a deeply emotional way. It’s hard to explain. We did have some issues growing up but mostly resolved (to a point) by the time they died

Needanadultgapyear · 04/07/2026 08:22

What was the dynamic in the family? In mine all of this pressure to marry the right people came from my grandmother after she passed away my grandfather stopped talking about this he just took joy in his family.
Our family was a much better functioning family without her.
Could your Dad be wanting to put all this aside?

nooneliterallyspatouttheirtea · 04/07/2026 08:23

You made your choices a long time ago and they were very obviously the right choices for you. I expect you will get some sentimental posters saying you must go to the funeral. I didn't and I have no regrets. Please do whatever you need to do to preserve the peace you've created for yourself and your family.

Marwoodsbigbreak · 04/07/2026 08:24

Nope. I wouldn’t go. This is probably a combination of Keeping up Appearances and lining you up to support DF now your mother has gone.

I definitely won’t be attending my mothers funeral, although she has pre empted the “shame” of that by insisting she won’t have one.

All I will feel when my mother dies is relief that she can no longer hurt me (or other people)

Miranda65 · 04/07/2026 08:24

You don't have to do anything you don't want to do, OP. Just forget about these people, and concentrate on your life with your own family and friends.

Ilovemyfam · 04/07/2026 08:26

Is there any chance that the funeral is going to be live-streamed? We did this for my Dad’s funeral to allow overseas attendance.

You could contact brother to ask for a link and then could attend without the pressure of being there and meeting Dad.

I have read through your post. I’m not sure that I would want to meet up with Dad.

Miranda65 · 04/07/2026 08:27

Rubyslipperswitch · 04/07/2026 08:08

I have been no contact with my toxic mother for years now and have no intention of either going to her funeral when she dies or to have any contact again with her side of the family.

I am so much happier and at peace with the constant drama. My parents were abusive and neglectful when I was a child and I still often have nightmares about them. My childhood/teenage years had an incredibly damaging influence on my physical and mental health.

I have come to realise as an adult that because you are related to someone does not automatically mean that you will love them or want/need to have them in your life.

So trust your instincts and don't let anyone guilt trip you into any kind of contact if this is not what you want.

100% this. A genetic relationship is no guarantee of liking, or loving, a person. It is just random biology.

Thebinisrightthere · 04/07/2026 08:30

I definitely wouldn't go. I can't think of a single reason to go

Luckyforsome23 · 04/07/2026 08:30

It is painful to be at a funeral when your experience of the deceased is very different to the assumptions of everyone else there. However I would speak to your Dad if only to show him that you have made a good life for yourself.

Haffdonga · 04/07/2026 08:32

Nobody ever picked up the phone and said can we try again

But isn't that exactly what your dad's doing right now?

I'm so sorry for your loss. Grief in a complicated estrangement situation can be even more difficult to deal with.

While your parents sound narrow minded and old-fashioned, the snippets of information you share about them don't make them sound abusive or unloving. Was there love and care in your childhood?

Your dad is presumably reeling and taking stock of his own life and relationships now your mum has very sadly died. Your parents don't sound like the sort of people ever to have apologised or admitted they were wrong to behave the way they did, but could it be that there is still something left between you and your family worth giving him a second chance?

Ilovemyfam · 04/07/2026 08:34

I didn’t express the virtual attendance the way I meant. What I was envisioning was that OP could watch it only if she wanted. She could watch the first five minutes and switch off if she wanted. She doesn’t have to do it in real time. It is all on her terms.

In fact if I were brothers I would be arranging for virtual attendance - and messaging OP “here is a link to the funeral in case you don’t feel up to attending in person”.

Muffsies · 04/07/2026 08:35

Maybe it was your mother that was the insitgator of the rift, now she's gone your father wants to rebuild a relationship? Or possibly, now he's lost his companion and carer he wants to see if he can replace her with you? Do you think you could be the dutiful daughter after all the time he has neglected you and your family?

I have known families like yours (i was a middle class kid in an historic private school that had some aristocratic families), they are all about duties and fulfilling roles, maintaining the status, etc. Kids are just extensions of themselves, not people in their own right. I doubt that your father will have changed tbh, and if he has, he'll have to do better than just bidding you to attend a funeral out of a sense of propriety.

PreachyPie · 04/07/2026 08:38

Why mot meet up quietly with your dad and see how the land lies?
I think just going to the funeral, without meeting him first would be too much....far too many other people around to deal with.
Meeting him alone now might give you the answers you need ......he might deeply regret how you were treated and want to build a relationship. On the other hand, he might be a total arse! The only way to know for sure is to see him.