Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to question the media response to the Belfast attack?

663 replies

Squirrel001 · Yesterday 08:55

Why are the media being silent on the Belfast attack?

Is the open borders narrative that important to them that they feel the need to ignore one of the most horrific attacks ever seen on a UK street?

I despair for the future of the UK. It’s grim.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:15

cardibach · Yesterday 16:14

And yet white attackers attacking people doesn’t. Odd that.

.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:15

cardibach · Yesterday 16:14

And yet white attackers attacking people doesn’t. Odd that.

It’s not odd to question why someone can do a crime this horrendous and no changes are made to the system that enables it.

MsJinks · Yesterday 16:16

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 16:06

Seriously?
I don't buy your argument that some of these men are attacking people because they are treated badly in the UK. Having protesters outside a hotel does not encourage them to start raping and murdering people.

That wasn’t my full argument - some people can’t be helped or stopped. There are bad and/or disturbed folk across the world.

However, a better approach to immigration and integration may well reduce radicalisation and reduce bitterness/hate towards others.

cardibach · Yesterday 16:17

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:15

It’s not odd to question why someone can do a crime this horrendous and no changes are made to the system that enables it.

Questioning is absolutely fine, obviously. And I’ve said somewhere - not sure if it’s this thread or another similar one - that the whole system of asylum needs to change as there’ll be increasing numbers due to climate change. What’s not ok is rioting about it

MsJinks · Yesterday 16:18

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:15

It’s not odd to question why someone can do a crime this horrendous and no changes are made to the system that enables it.

But that might be to tighten checks, not burn the entire immigration system to the ground.

The police actions of last week are being reviewed and that may result in some change to process - we don’t want every police station burned down.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:19

cardibach · Yesterday 16:17

Questioning is absolutely fine, obviously. And I’ve said somewhere - not sure if it’s this thread or another similar one - that the whole system of asylum needs to change as there’ll be increasing numbers due to climate change. What’s not ok is rioting about it

Yes I think a few want a system that allows more people shared out amongst countries, but there’s no way people will say ok to that when crimes like this happen.

smallglassbottle · Yesterday 16:21

BackToLurk · Yesterday 14:38

Would you go and live in a country that had been involved in a 35 year war?

Did you mean Northern Ireland?

I wouldn't have wanted to live in Northern Ireland during that part of history, no. I wouldn't choose to live in Honduras, Mexico, Afghanistan, Chechnya or South Africa either as I regard those as violent places. Persistently violent places don't tend to birth peaceful people. Look at what's happened to Sweden. That's what's happening to us. Spot the similarities.

Nuthatch26 · Yesterday 16:23

MsJinks · Yesterday 16:16

That wasn’t my full argument - some people can’t be helped or stopped. There are bad and/or disturbed folk across the world.

However, a better approach to immigration and integration may well reduce radicalisation and reduce bitterness/hate towards others.

Ok, if you accept that some are indeed bad and disturbed (your words), why do you want them here? I don't.
I also don't want the money I pay in tax being spent trying to teach these men not to rape and or murder.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:28

MsJinks · Yesterday 16:18

But that might be to tighten checks, not burn the entire immigration system to the ground.

The police actions of last week are being reviewed and that may result in some change to process - we don’t want every police station burned down.

What checks can be put in place for someone from Sudan? Or other countries

TooBigForMyBoots · Yesterday 16:36

DangerQuakeRhinoSnake · Yesterday 15:18

You are half a day late with this, my love.

It was already on the news. @Squirrel001 didn't fact check before starting this thread.

The why is the media doing/ not doing... is a load of shite repeated by low information, fact resistant people. I will challenge this nonsense every time I see it.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 16:37

TooBigForMyBoots · Yesterday 16:36

It was already on the news. @Squirrel001 didn't fact check before starting this thread.

The why is the media doing/ not doing... is a load of shite repeated by low information, fact resistant people. I will challenge this nonsense every time I see it.

This is post is so typical.

Weeallthewayhome · Yesterday 16:41

MsJinks · Yesterday 14:27

No one is deflecting or minimising this event. Some people are, however, using it for an anti immigration agenda - why do that?

Because it’s immigration causing it. And I say this as someone brought up in other cultures. Get your head out of the sand, please.

Weeallthewayhome · Yesterday 16:44

MsJinks · Yesterday 14:38

Concerns? A lot of it is incitement to violence - off here I mean as well though there is a bit of that here - this is way beyond a ‘concern’.

But ok - what do you want to happen to allay these ‘concerns’
All asylum seekers banned?
All refugees settled here remigrated?
A full programme of re migration for anyone not here for 15 generations?

There is no consensus even on what would allay ‘concerns’ - I’ve seen everything from focus on small boats only it seems, to some nebulous concept of having to be ‘British’.

My personal suggestion is we stop making migrants feel hated and work on integration - wild idea I expect.

Certain migrants, the stabby rapey ones, aren’t remotely interested in integration ffs.

spend some time researching and reading reports, especially from the Nordic countries, who ten years ago invested considerable resources in attempting to integrate young men from misogynistic cultures.

Prepare to be astonished that these initiatives, naive and well meaning, failed miserably,

Hence Denmark’s muscular approach to integration.

Weeallthewayhome · Yesterday 16:50

Velumental · Yesterday 14:53

And there we have it. Blatant islamaphobia. The real reason people are up in arms

Not really. An admittedly sarcastic but perfectly reasonable response to the situation weak naive liberalism has caused opening borders and ushering in young men with a cultural predisposition to sexual and physical
violence.

These cultures are incompatible with ours. Nip off to Somalia, Saudi etc and spend six months going about your business, and take your daughters while you’re at it and let us know how you get on.

I’ll hold your coat.

WhatATravesty · Yesterday 16:53

MsJinks · Yesterday 16:16

That wasn’t my full argument - some people can’t be helped or stopped. There are bad and/or disturbed folk across the world.

However, a better approach to immigration and integration may well reduce radicalisation and reduce bitterness/hate towards others.

The problem is multi faceted. A complete blindness to seeing the other side of the coin, where some refugees simply do not want to adopt British culture/language/practices, is not helpful. What can we do in these circumstances, to avoid such dreadful consequences to society? The binary all refugees are good/ bad or all British people are good/bad is just not a constructive narrative. What can we ALL do?

randomchap · Yesterday 16:55

TooBigForMyBoots · Yesterday 16:36

It was already on the news. @Squirrel001 didn't fact check before starting this thread.

The why is the media doing/ not doing... is a load of shite repeated by low information, fact resistant people. I will challenge this nonsense every time I see it.

fact resistant people is a great turn of phrase

Weeallthewayhome · Yesterday 16:56

MsJinks · Yesterday 15:08

Nothing and that was dreadful and abhorrent. There are very bad people from all sectors. You cannot stop this.

I know you will now say well they shouldn’t be here - and that would stop that one - but that is just an idea we form to make us feel safer in many ways.

But what is your idea then?
Deport all small boat arrivals?
Deport all refugees with status?
Remigrate everyone without an ancestry check going back 15 generations?
Do some nebulous ‘British values’ check?

There’s so many different views on what is ok not many would be happy. There are so many different laws and difficulties around any of the above they can’t happen anyhow.

So for me violence against hotels, rioting, it’s just not solving anything but will make it worse instead - use your vote, pressure your local MP, get active but don’t get violent.

Yup. Excellent suggestions. I’d do all of them:
Deport all small boat arrivals
Deport culturally incompatible refugees with status
Remigrate everyone with no job or means of supporting themselves and one wife
Do a pretty basic ‘British values’ check that establishes the applicant attitude to rape, misogyny, beheading, suicide bombing, stabbing. Need I go on?

Which is why I’ll vote Restore

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 16:58

MsJinks · Yesterday 16:16

That wasn’t my full argument - some people can’t be helped or stopped. There are bad and/or disturbed folk across the world.

However, a better approach to immigration and integration may well reduce radicalisation and reduce bitterness/hate towards others.

Or do some basic checks across Europe.
There was a street fight between two international protection men last year, St Anne street, Dublin. One died from a large stab wound, both the attacker and the victim had previous convictions in Europe, the victim had been deported from Italy to his home country for rape, so then he came to Ireland.
Similar a little girl killed In county Wexford, her mother had converted, her throat was cut, the attacker was a registered international protection applicant, like above, receiving a payment, he had previous convictions in the UK for rape… Can they not google these applicants or check a European database??

DontBuyAnotherBook · Yesterday 16:59

EasternStandard · Yesterday 15:15

Tbf Australians are pretty happy with their laws. No one would vote for deaths at sea again.

Ik you’d like an international system where everyone who needs to be is placed elsewhere but there’s no way we can have even more of these crimes.

Politicians are meant to prioritise safety of citizens, not the opposite.

To be fair Australia did have a beach shooting perpetrated by middle eastern men recently I believe.

percypigss · Yesterday 17:00

StillgotmyiPod · Yesterday 09:54

How do you know he's a religious fanatic?

How do you know this isn't a drug deal gone wrong?

How do you know this isn't a gang dispute?

How do you know this isn't someone seriously mentally unwell?

The above are all possibilities.

Which is why the facts have to be established before the media start reporting on them.

At the moment, the only thing anyone can say with any confidence is that there was a horrific attack.

Behave

Gloriia · Yesterday 17:02

TooBigForMyBoots · Yesterday 16:36

It was already on the news. @Squirrel001 didn't fact check before starting this thread.

The why is the media doing/ not doing... is a load of shite repeated by low information, fact resistant people. I will challenge this nonsense every time I see it.

Hardly headlines. I had the radio on and it only became high profile later on.

Theres no need fo sneer and call people 'low information fact resistant'.

MsJinks · Yesterday 17:09

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 16:58

Or do some basic checks across Europe.
There was a street fight between two international protection men last year, St Anne street, Dublin. One died from a large stab wound, both the attacker and the victim had previous convictions in Europe, the victim had been deported from Italy to his home country for rape, so then he came to Ireland.
Similar a little girl killed In county Wexford, her mother had converted, her throat was cut, the attacker was a registered international protection applicant, like above, receiving a payment, he had previous convictions in the UK for rape… Can they not google these applicants or check a European database??

No well the U.K. lost access to a lot European intel when we Brexited. Sharing agreements have only recently been reset up, or are in discussion.

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 17:12

MsJinks · Yesterday 17:09

No well the U.K. lost access to a lot European intel when we Brexited. Sharing agreements have only recently been reset up, or are in discussion.

These things happened in Ireland. They would have had access to check.

MsJinks · Yesterday 17:20

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 17:12

These things happened in Ireland. They would have had access to check.

They should have then sure - I posted this link on another thread tells us what happens https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/asylum-screening-and-routing/asylum-screening-and-routing-accessible

OonaStubbs · Yesterday 17:21

The media should report what they know, when they know it. The restrictions on reporting because of upcoming trials are outdated in this day and age, people will just report it themselves on social media anyway.