Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think some people on here are way too obsessed with not being seen as racist?

327 replies

BadWordlePlayer · Yesterday 08:49

I’m posting in AIBU because this has been niggling at me for a while with the tone of so many threads lately, but it's really blown up following the bodycam footage of the Henry Nowak case.

There seem to be loads of posts these days where people are basically showing off how not racist they are, or how much they hate racists or the 'far right', or jumping in to call something racist at the slightest thing. It feels performative, like they’re desperate to signal their virtue and make sure everyone knows they’re on the “right” side. I get that racism is bad, obviously, but it sometimes feels like it’s taken over to the point where common sense goes out the window.

Henry Nowak shows how dangerous this mindset is. This poor 18-year-old student was stabbed multiple times by Vickrum Digwa, who then lied to the police claiming Henry had racially abused him. The officers took that accusation at face value, handcuffed Henry while he was lying there bleeding out and saying he couldn’t breathe, and didn’t treat him as the victim urgently enough. He died in police custody essentially. The mindset of those officers sounds exactly like the over-the-top “must not be perceived as racist” attitude you see in some threads here. They sidelined a dying boy because of a racism claim (which turned out to be a complete lie). That’s not just sad — it’s dangerous.

This isn't a left wing / right wing post and I’m not saying racism doesn’t exist or that we shouldn’t call it out when it’s real. I also hate the phrase "virtue signalling", but I can't think of a better one than it. This constant virtue-signalling and knee-jerk reactions make situations like Henry’s more likely, not less. People (including police) become so paralysed by the fear of getting it wrong on race that they get it horrifically wrong on everything else.

Am I being unreasonable? Or has anyone else noticed this shift on MN and in general?

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 16:21

Corianda · Yesterday 16:10

The woman imprisoned for her racist tweet was ludicrous and demonstrated a two tier justice system imv

also what isn’t said is that the countries that many immigrants come from are extremely corrupt - it doesn’t bode well if you bring huge numbers into the country. I’m sure it’s part of the reasons our immigrants want to move here and don’t want to move back

The incident referred to as the Irish George Floyd last week was horrendous. A man from the Congo was pinned down by security guards in Dublin, he died, it’s awful and unnecessary. There has been protesting all week, a witch doctor carried out voodoo spells on the store and wishing all the customers will die, this weekend, a young black boy was murdered only 21 years old. A club promoter at a rap event, the same protestors won’t acknowledge this, in fact the club is promoting the next event without a whisper on the young boy because it was black lads fighting a black lad, same way when a black man committed a serious offence against a white person, there is uproar, the division is crazy.
At the same time as the crushing incident, a white man was robbed and murdered by two immigrants, it didn’t get the same outcry. Politicians in the street screaming about racism etc. it was silent for the white man murdered by two teenagers who recorded it and put it on twitter.

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 16:29

And people also forget racist stereotypes are not the same for every ethnicity. If the perpetrator had been a Black man it’s likely they would have been quick to believe the victim. So let’s not spin a tale that police are these racial justice warriors ffs.
100% agree with this.
Had he been black the police would have done things very differently.

LakieLady · Yesterday 16:45

Corianda · Yesterday 16:10

The woman imprisoned for her racist tweet was ludicrous and demonstrated a two tier justice system imv

also what isn’t said is that the countries that many immigrants come from are extremely corrupt - it doesn’t bode well if you bring huge numbers into the country. I’m sure it’s part of the reasons our immigrants want to move here and don’t want to move back

Are you referring to Lucy Connolly's tweet at the time of the Southport riots?

She pleaded guilty and her appeal against the sentence was turned down, which seems to suggest that the sentence wasn't excessive.

The judge's sentencing remarks are published here

Lucy Connolly: sentencing

I've read them, and the sentencing guidelines for the offence here

Incitement sentencing guidelines

and it seems clear to me that her offence fits 1A and the judge gave appropriate consideration to all factors in arriving at the sentence.

I'd be interested to hear where you think he went wrong and how that is an example of "two-tier" justice.

https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/R-v-Lucy-Connolly.pdf

HRTQueen · Yesterday 16:50

oh yes I don't see colour brigade and I need to tell everyone are all over social media and forums

yet many of them are very aware when someone is Jewish funny that

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 16:56

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 15:48

The Reform bots are back, it seems.

The only bot is you because you don't believe anyone could have a different view. It's very telling the poster/s who keeps referring to the victim by his surname.

LakieLady · Yesterday 17:04

Thepeopleversuswork · Yesterday 13:29

What are you talking about?

The so-called “silent majority” is shouting from the rooftops at the moment. It hasn’t been as fashionable to be racist as it was in the days of Enoch Powell.

I wonder how many of the current crop of racists will be able to quote from the Aeneid though?

RingoJuice · Yesterday 17:09

Well if being thought of as a racist leads you to bleed out after asking for help … I can understand why. People seem afraid, like they will be hurt or something if seen as a racist.

I am called a racist here all the damn time though for the most innocuous shit, I don’t care. Whatever it takes to take the bite out of this phrase. Shouldn’t matter anymore if you are called a racist for pointing out obvious things

RingoJuice · Yesterday 17:10

HRTQueen · Yesterday 16:50

oh yes I don't see colour brigade and I need to tell everyone are all over social media and forums

yet many of them are very aware when someone is Jewish funny that

Very few groups it is acceptable to hate and Jews are included in that.

JaneFondue · Yesterday 17:15

I note several posts calling anyone non-white " foreign" in the wake of this murder.

No. Digwa was British. So yes, some people manage to be racist just fine.

Thepeopleversuswork · Yesterday 17:17

LakieLady · Yesterday 17:04

I wonder how many of the current crop of racists will be able to quote from the Aeneid though?

Grateful for small mercies etc. The less educated our racists are, the better.

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:20

JaneFondue · Yesterday 17:15

I note several posts calling anyone non-white " foreign" in the wake of this murder.

No. Digwa was British. So yes, some people manage to be racist just fine.

Including a Sikh family who cared nothing for the life of a white boy.

JHound · Yesterday 17:21

EmeraldShamrock000 · Yesterday 16:29

And people also forget racist stereotypes are not the same for every ethnicity. If the perpetrator had been a Black man it’s likely they would have been quick to believe the victim. So let’s not spin a tale that police are these racial justice warriors ffs.
100% agree with this.
Had he been black the police would have done things very differently.

Oh yes. That’s why I said personally the man being Sikh may have influenced the officer given their “Model Minority” status.

A black perpetrator would simply be seen as a gang member and the police would not have hesitated to cuff him.

JaneFondue · Yesterday 17:22

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:20

Including a Sikh family who cared nothing for the life of a white boy.

Yes. As I have said numerous times. Though I do not think they would have cared for him whatever race he was because they were psychopaths.

HRTQueen · Yesterday 17:22

RingoJuice · Yesterday 17:10

Very few groups it is acceptable to hate and Jews are included in that.

oh please there is plenty of hate about have you missed the growing antisemitism in this country especially on the so called kind left

they can be seen even when they think they can't

JHound · Yesterday 17:22

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:20

Including a Sikh family who cared nothing for the life of a white boy.

I have not watched any video is their evidence that this was a racially motivated crime?

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:23

Thepeopleversuswork · Yesterday 17:17

Grateful for small mercies etc. The less educated our racists are, the better.

Their thoughts and opinions are hammering you at the opinion polls. A lot of whom are educated. Among everything else, I wouldn't be quite as sneery given the disturbing video footage that has affected anyone with compassion. Coming on this thread being sanctimonious doesn't make you any better than those you are taking the piss out of.

JaneFondue · Yesterday 17:24

JHound · Yesterday 17:22

I have not watched any video is their evidence that this was a racially motivated crime?

No.

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:25

JHound · Yesterday 17:22

I have not watched any video is their evidence that this was a racially motivated crime?

There's evidence they didn't value his life and automatically played the race card. Wonder what their BS would have been had Henry been Sikh.

JHound · Yesterday 17:25

Dweetfidilove · Yesterday 15:46

There has always existed a pervasion of racism throughout the criminal justice system, and ethnic minority groups have always been portrayed as as more 'crime prone' than others; so the government has been resistant to treating knife crime in London as a public health matter.

Most people recognise that knife crime is not a racialised issue, but one predominantly based on socioeconomic issues. That applies in London as much as it does in the North East.

People are clamouring about two-tier policing and I'm happy they are now aware this issue.
Pretending it's an issue that sees white people being overpoliced, however, is what makes their argument ridiculous. There are no statistics that supports this at all.

People are clamouring about two-tier policing and I'm happy they are now aware this issue.
Pretending it's an issue that sees white people being overpoliced, however, is what makes their argument ridiculous. There are no statistics that supports this at all

Thank. You.

JHound · Yesterday 17:27

Horch · Yesterday 15:55

It's creating an environment of hypocrisy, fear and virtue-signalling. The contention of this thread is that this ultimately distorts behaviour and leads to the police putting an disproportionate focus on racism in some circumstances.

So - none? (If police put an overfocus on racism stop and search rates would be the opposite of what they are.)

GreenCandleWax · Yesterday 17:31

Brenzaida · Yesterday 09:09

By your logic, everyone should go back to old-fashioned racism so the police would have correctly arrested the brown guy in the turban first in this incident?

No. The police should have kept an open and impartial mind when investigating. The fact that they didn't is what OP is complaining about. The police in this case were not big enough to do what was right - they just did the unthinking, knee-jerk "can't be seen as racist" thing. I am not racist, and it doesn't bother me if I am wrongly called racist because for example I might criticise the behaviour of someone non-white. Who cares if someone thinks you are racist? If you are not, you are not.

JHound · Yesterday 17:36

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:25

There's evidence they didn't value his life and automatically played the race card. Wonder what their BS would have been had Henry been Sikh.

That wasn’t my question.

LuckyHazelFox · Yesterday 17:42

JHound · Yesterday 17:36

That wasn’t my question.

Well it's my answer. This isn't about a racially motivated crime. It's about a racially motivated defence.

JHound · Yesterday 17:43

Corianda · Yesterday 16:10

The woman imprisoned for her racist tweet was ludicrous and demonstrated a two tier justice system imv

also what isn’t said is that the countries that many immigrants come from are extremely corrupt - it doesn’t bode well if you bring huge numbers into the country. I’m sure it’s part of the reasons our immigrants want to move here and don’t want to move back

What does immigration have to do with this story?

BadWordlePlayer · Yesterday 17:43

I can't be alone in thinking, whenever I read someone tell me how decent they are because they are not racist, or that they're anti racist (whatever that means)..

'I bet you're the most racist person you know'

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread