Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Is Kier Starmer a liar?

401 replies

catspyjamas1 · 20/04/2026 19:34

Is Kier Starmer a liar - yes or no?

It's a simple question. I can't see this on the trending threads, so asking the question.

YABU: He reliant on civil servants to share information and is in the clear, he didn't know what he didn't know.
YANBU: He's the Prime Minister. Who happens to get briefings and knew.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
BIossomtoes · Yesterday 07:35

Fortunately there’s another three years before a general election. It’s an eternity in politics.

Shedmistress · Yesterday 07:41

1dayatatime · 20/04/2026 23:44

No one is questioning whether Mandelson failed the security vetting. No one is questioning whether Mandelson was a questionable and high risk appointment- he was after all known as "The Prince of Darkness ".

What is unclear is whether Sir Keir was informed Mandelson had failed the security vetting or not.

Sir Keir says that he was not and that the results were deliberately withheld from him. Unless there is a paper trial or evidence to the contrary then I don't know how anyone can prove that Sir Keir is lying.

You think they put the mitigations in place behind the PM's back?

MushMonster · Yesterday 07:43

Starmer knew who Mandelson was when he appointed him. To an ambassador position. He knew about his links to Epstein. He knew about his past dodgy behaviour. He only appointed Mandelson because he is his mate. Mandelson has zero graces that made him suitable for this post. Zero. Actually, Mandelson should not be allowed anywhere near government.
Now, he was finger chosen and announced before any due process. And Starmer is making a civil servant pay for it with his job. The very same people he put under pressure by hand picking Mandelson. Not a minister, not the process, not the PM. It has been a civil servant. Well, that tells us who Starmer is. And that is not someone focused on the working people, is he?
I think Starmer should take full responsibility of his actions.
Starting by looking in the mirror. Do we want a PM that would choose a dodgy character as an advisor and mate? Remember, we had that with Johnson and the stupid Cummings man.
There are plenty of hard working, respectable, cultured people in UK that Starmer could promote. Instead of this shitty circle of his.

Attenboroughsmistress · Yesterday 07:58

Nope he isn’t and I frankly couldn’t give a flying fuck about the Mandelson affair with all that is going on in the world. Let Keir get on with governing.

I saw Labour are introducing changes to energy pricing to decouple it from gas prices - how about our public discourse focus on discussions about how to get that policy right?

TurnipsAndParsnips · Yesterday 08:04

I think the senior civil servants involved are arrogant enough not to flag this with the PM. But the appointment had also been announced so there would have been the pressure to make it happen. I would also be a bit surprised if Lammy didn’t know.

ProudAmberTurtle · Yesterday 08:05

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 07:35

Fortunately there’s another three years before a general election. It’s an eternity in politics.

But it's Labour MPs who will determine Starmer's future, and they're very worried about their own

EasternStandard · Yesterday 08:05

TurnipsAndParsnips · Yesterday 08:04

I think the senior civil servants involved are arrogant enough not to flag this with the PM. But the appointment had also been announced so there would have been the pressure to make it happen. I would also be a bit surprised if Lammy didn’t know.

The scapegoated CS will put his case today. I doubt it’s arrogance from them, more the PM and co for pushing through a poor candidate no matter what.

TurnipsAndParsnips · Yesterday 08:05

I also think that Mandelson was picked as someone who could deal with Trump, not because he was mates with Keir.

TurnipsAndParsnips · Yesterday 08:07

Labour will get rid of Starmer after the May local elections, as they will be able to blame their piss poor performance on him.

anotheranonanon · Yesterday 08:09

Labour out in force. Anyone else would be long gone. They haven’t got anyone else to appoint is the issue so he hangs on.

godmum56 · Yesterday 08:13

Attenboroughsmistress · Yesterday 07:58

Nope he isn’t and I frankly couldn’t give a flying fuck about the Mandelson affair with all that is going on in the world. Let Keir get on with governing.

I saw Labour are introducing changes to energy pricing to decouple it from gas prices - how about our public discourse focus on discussions about how to get that policy right?

so he can make more egregious mistakes like this one.

catspyjamas1 · Yesterday 08:16

TurnipsAndParsnips · Yesterday 08:05

I also think that Mandelson was picked as someone who could deal with Trump, not because he was mates with Keir.

Maybe but the previous ambassador was doing well and like by Trump apparently.

OP posts:
Pacificsunshine · Yesterday 08:16

TeenagersAngst · Yesterday 06:43

I think you mean Olly Robbins.

And possibly a ‘fait accompli’?

Yes, that is what I mean. Very kind of you to correct my spelling. Let’s see what Olly says today. I believe this is what he is likely to say, or at least heavily imply.

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:17

ProudAmberTurtle · Yesterday 08:05

But it's Labour MPs who will determine Starmer's future, and they're very worried about their own

What’s that got to do with the entirely irrelevant poll you’re crowing about?

godmum56 · Yesterday 08:18

I said when KS was picked for PM that he was the "rebound PM" like the rebound boyfriend....might look good initially but chosen in haste and never going to be a long term prospect. The trouble is that I don't see any better prospect in the labour party....If I had to bet though I'd have a modest flutter on Wes Streeting.

MushMonster · Yesterday 08:18

catspyjamas1 · Yesterday 08:16

Maybe but the previous ambassador was doing well and like by Trump apparently.

Exactly! There was nothing wrong with the previous ambassador and all sorts of wrong with Mandelson.

PinkPonyAnonymous · Yesterday 08:18

He is a liar.

He also drink drives and hit a cyclist once while doing it.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 08:18

catspyjamas1 · Yesterday 08:16

Maybe but the previous ambassador was doing well and like by Trump apparently.

Yep it was more about Starmer / McSweeney and Mandelson

godmum56 · Yesterday 08:21

PinkPonyAnonymous · Yesterday 08:18

He is a liar.

He also drink drives and hit a cyclist once while doing it.

can't comment on whether he had been drinking but the bit about the cyclist is true. Have you got any proff about the drink driving?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-54701336

Sir Keir Starmer

Sir Keir Starmer involved in road collision with cyclist

Police are investigating the incident, which saw a cyclist taken to hospital.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-54701336

OnceUponATimed · Yesterday 08:21

MNLurker1345 · 20/04/2026 22:13

No, Starmer has superseded her!

Really? Or how about the men took us to brexit to save their own political skins (Cameron and Johnson).
They have ruined this country more than any other politicians in my long life.

ProudAmberTurtle · Yesterday 08:23

BIossomtoes · Yesterday 08:17

What’s that got to do with the entirely irrelevant poll you’re crowing about?

Labour dropping to a new historic low in a poll is all the Labour MPs actually care about.

And that's why Starmer is toast

Pacificsunshine · Yesterday 08:23

PinkPonyAnonymous · Yesterday 08:18

He is a liar.

He also drink drives and hit a cyclist once while doing it.

sorry, was asking for a reference and see that one appeared. I am very surprised. I am not a fan, but this really surprises me.

CautiousLurker2 · Yesterday 08:24

All politicians are liars, I’m afraid. The days of anyone putting country before party, or their party before their personal career are decades gone. If, indeed, they ever existed.

PinkPonyAnonymous · Yesterday 08:25

godmum56 · Yesterday 08:21

can't comment on whether he had been drinking but the bit about the cyclist is true. Have you got any proff about the drink driving?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-54701336

I don’t have proof but he was playing 5 a side, then went to a pub for a few hours (not necessarily drinking obviously), then hit a cyclist, then didn’t wait for the police to attend the scene, went home and turned up hours later to be breathalysed. Highly suspicious. I’m sure he’s never done it again.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 08:26

ProudAmberTurtle · Yesterday 08:23

Labour dropping to a new historic low in a poll is all the Labour MPs actually care about.

And that's why Starmer is toast

The local elections will be the voting version of the poll, and they’ll react to historic lows.