Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel like I'm not my partner's true love

320 replies

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 10:40

Posting from outside of the UK, I hope that's not an issue... Anyways, I'm 30 years old, a FTM (baby is 19 months old), and have been with my partner (29 years old) for 5 years now. Our relationship has been good for the most part, despite our rocky beginnings. I mention the way our relationship started because, being totally honest, this may be the main reason for some of what I'm about to describe. We met on a dating app when he was still in a relationship with his ex. I didn't know when we met but found out very quickly and decided to carry on seeing him anyways. Not proud of it to be clear. They broke up eventually after six years together.

From day 1 I have felt like I found 'my person' in him. He's smart, ambitious, handsome, has a lot of values and interests I share. Along with our baby we have built a beautiful life together. And yet despite all of the good things I can't describe the way I feel the lack of... intimacy (?) from his side. I don't mean purely in the physical sense. It's more like something I'm missing from him? I've thought a lot about this over the years and the only thing I can come up with is a feeling of him being reluctant. It doesn't feel like he's curious about me at all, or at least, not anymore. He doesn't put in effort to get me to open up or understand where I'm coming from when we're going through something. For example, I went through a rough patch with my mental health after my mom passed last year, and have honestly been needing quite a bit of support emotionally. I've tried to talk to him about this but he doesn't really engage or understand. Or bother to ask me what I'm experiencing. It's like he doesn't care enough to put in effort. And I've always felt like, for true love, you put in work and effort. I know I have...

I suppose his ex comes in here as well. She's been a bit of a third factor in our relationship since the start. The first year and a half of our relationship was filled with ups and downs as he clearly hadn't moved on from one relationship and was already starting a new one. We did work through that, he went completely no contact, and for a while it worked. Until about a year ago, shortly after I gave birth. We hti another rocky patch, one thing lead to another, and by his own confession to me he started slipping and making 'contact'. Meaning saving her social media pictures to his phone and DMing her when he drinks, begging her to take him back, asking for nudes. He showed me the messages he sent and they were....... not good.

Now, I've chosen to trust him and his word because he was transparent about it and seemed sincerely apologetic, and so far he has kept his promise to me and our child. But combined with his general reluctant attitude towards me sometimes, it just makes me feel more and more unwanted. I've expressed that I'd like to get married soon since we've been together for 5 years, had a baby, and are financially stable. Even though I try my hardest not to come off desperate (which is really difficult when you've dreamt of your "happy ever after"), he dismisses the idea anytime I bring it up and says that there's no rush. Knowing full well he proposed to her at one point. She rejected him but still. It hurts.

Sometimes I feel like what we have has all been in my head, built up and imagined because I want him so badly to be my happy ending. Does he even want this, does he want me, or does he want her? What am I missing? What does she have? This is all very hard to write to be honest. Makes it too real. But I don't have any friends or family to talk about this with irl, so reaching out here felt like my only option to get some perspectives on this and see if anyone can relate. Thank you in advance.

OP posts:
ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:33

GreyCarpet · 03/03/2026 12:30

Why? Does it make you feel uncomfortable to look in the mirror?

Fwiw, I think you should leave him too. You need to see and accept that this is not a good man and your happily every after does not exist within him.

If you don't like 'the energy' - do better and find a different energy for yourself.

Edited

It makes me feel uncomfortable, yes. I know I 'ruined' or at least played a part in the end of a relationship and in some terrible stuff for his ex. She had issues after the relationship came to an end and yes, I do blame myself for this. As well as him. I can't make it right, though. There's nothing I can do for her. So do I need to see repeated time and again that I did an awful thing out of selfishness? No.

OP posts:
TinyCottageGirl · 03/03/2026 12:33

Sorry OP he sounds in love wih his ex, or at least probably not in love with you? Definitely not a trust worthy person, I wouldn't stay with him

ThatCyanCat · 03/03/2026 12:33

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:15

I went through a string of loser boyfriends who I never really connected with and only dated to 'date'. It felt very different with him. And the explanation he gave me - they'd bee growing apart, he was planning on breaking up but had to find the right time because things were tough for her - made sense to me, at the time.
I'm not proud of it, either, having been cheated on myself. I've wanted to reach out to her and apologize for years as I know the kind of toll it has on a woman's self esteem and belief in love.

While it obviously wasn't a stellar thing for you to do, she was his girlfriend, not yours, so only he has anything for which to apologise. At any rate, she probably wouldn't think you were very sorry if you're still with him and have a child together. Same goes for him, of course, but it seems that she's forgiven him anyway if she's accepting contact like that from him.

He is not going to change, so bear that in mind moving forward. If he really is a great dad then he'll always support his child financially and emotionally.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2026 12:35

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:30

I didn't say I deserve sympathy. It was bad for me to do such a thing, as I have said. I can't take it back, or turn back time, and I've said myself it feels like Karma. Coming right back to me. I just don't have to see it repeated here in every other comment. I get it. I really do.

I think you get it too Op, and don't need that aspect rubbed in further.

And you are right, you need to find a way to move on from a mistake.

But maybe do that by trying not to make another. You need to really look hard at this situation to see if for what it is. Maybe try reading this thread and envisaging a different guy and a different Op to see objectively how obvious it is that this relationship is a hiding to nothing for you.

GhoulWithADragonTattoo · 03/03/2026 12:35

If anyone has a sole mate it’s your partner and his ex. You need to cut your losses and leave.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

TinyCottageGirl · 03/03/2026 12:33

Sorry OP he sounds in love wih his ex, or at least probably not in love with you? Definitely not a trust worthy person, I wouldn't stay with him

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

OP posts:
Endofyear · 03/03/2026 12:36

Sounds like he's still got feelings for her. If you stay with him, you'll always be wondering if he's been in touch with her again.

Trusttheawesomeness · 03/03/2026 12:36

ThatCyanCat · 03/03/2026 12:33

While it obviously wasn't a stellar thing for you to do, she was his girlfriend, not yours, so only he has anything for which to apologise. At any rate, she probably wouldn't think you were very sorry if you're still with him and have a child together. Same goes for him, of course, but it seems that she's forgiven him anyway if she's accepting contact like that from him.

He is not going to change, so bear that in mind moving forward. If he really is a great dad then he'll always support his child financially and emotionally.

Accepting contact like that from him? How much of a misogynist do you have to be to blame a totally innocent woman for a man sending her an unsolicited video of himself wanking. You’re actually trying to put some blame onto this woman? Disgusting. Absolutely disgusting.

The OP found out really early on that this guy had a girlfriend and she merrily carried on having an affair. The only people at fault here are the OP and her loser boyfriend. Now it’s OP’s turn to get cheated on.

Dunglowing · 03/03/2026 12:37

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 11:02

Someone asked, I feel I should say he is an amazing dad. The best. He takes on a lot of care and did exhaust himself when I was dealing with my mom passing - I know bare minimum or whatever. But I can't imagine a better, more doting father. Genuinely.

The best Dads prioritise, protect and ensure the stability of the family unit for their child.

The core step is cherishing the child’s mother and investing in their partnership as parents.

He isn’t doing this.

It’s not hard to be a doting dad to a cute baby - it’s like having a puppy - nature built them to be compelling.

His cock is more important than his child. These are his actions speaking.

Trusttheawesomeness · 03/03/2026 12:37

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

Was he living with you before the accidental pregnancy? Or did he move in because of that?

Namechangerage · 03/03/2026 12:38

Asking for nudes?! How gross

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 03/03/2026 12:38

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

But he isn't ever going to put you first.

He has always put himself first and he will continue to do so. Not you. Not your child. Not his ex.

Do you really want to live like this?

TinyCottageGirl · 03/03/2026 12:39

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:02

In a nutshell, she told him she had had a terrible time trying to move on from things and wanted him to leave her alone. Asked if he hadn't hurt her enough, he had to hurt me and a child now, too. Then blocked him.

She sounds like she truly is trying to move on from this. Possibly could've been a miscarriage and they didn't tell family - that's why his sister hasn't said anything?
I do think if she wanted him back it sounds like she could have him, and that's horrible feeling for you. I would leave him

Tableforjoan · 03/03/2026 12:39

He lives with you and has a baby with you but still wants her and possibly others.

His love like or want for her is stronger and bigger than your 5 years together.

For your own sanity leave the arsehole.

Calliopespa · 03/03/2026 12:39

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

This is reminding me of my little cousin dressing up her kitten and trying to push it round in a pram pretending it is a human baby.

She desperately wants a baby sister. Instead she has a cat that hates the game.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:41

Trusttheawesomeness · 03/03/2026 12:36

Accepting contact like that from him? How much of a misogynist do you have to be to blame a totally innocent woman for a man sending her an unsolicited video of himself wanking. You’re actually trying to put some blame onto this woman? Disgusting. Absolutely disgusting.

The OP found out really early on that this guy had a girlfriend and she merrily carried on having an affair. The only people at fault here are the OP and her loser boyfriend. Now it’s OP’s turn to get cheated on.

The first time any contact with her happened, we had been together for about a yeara t that point, it was consensual back and forth between them. He sent her messages, one thing led to another, he sent a photo, she sent a photo back then he said he shouldn't since he was seeing me. She blocked him after that. To unblock him a while later, I believe.
We worked through it. I believe he has convinced himself she has stayed single all this time for him. Minding her reaction now I think that's not the case, but the video didn't come out of nowhere. She was receptive to that sort of stuff then.

OP posts:
Beachtastic · 03/03/2026 12:41

He sounds like the sort of person who is used to hedging his bets, and maybe the responsibility of becoming a parent is makiing him feel wistful for an earlier time that was relatively carefree.

Sending her a video of him wanking is something I couldn't move past, although top marks to him for confessing right away.

Whatever is going on for him, he certainly sounds unreliable and emotionally immature in countless ways, I'm afraid, OP - sorry.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:42

Trusttheawesomeness · 03/03/2026 12:37

Was he living with you before the accidental pregnancy? Or did he move in because of that?

We had already been living together for a bit.

OP posts:
MyTrivia · 03/03/2026 12:43

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

You’re not listening to anyone.

What you should be doing is putting your daughter first.

Do you not think that she deserves better than to grow up watching her mother be repeatedly disrespected? She will learn that it’s ok for men to treat women this way and use it as a blueprint for her own relationships.

Catza · 03/03/2026 12:43

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 11:02

Someone asked, I feel I should say he is an amazing dad. The best. He takes on a lot of care and did exhaust himself when I was dealing with my mom passing - I know bare minimum or whatever. But I can't imagine a better, more doting father. Genuinely.

You don't need to imagine a better one. Nobody is taking his paternal rights away and he can continue being an amazing dad during his agreed contact time.

peachgreen · 03/03/2026 12:43

I'm more understanding than most when it comes to "overlap" in relationships. I absolutely get that sometimes, even when you're not intending it to happen, you can fall for someone else when you're in a relationship.

But... that's not what actually happened here, is it? He was on a dating site, actively looking to have an affair. He's not a good man who fell in love unexpectedly, he's a wilfully cheating scumbag who was willing to put his own sexual desires ahead of anything else. And for what? Just to be pining over his ex years later? What an absolute waste of space.

This not a man you want to be with. He's no prize. Get out now before you waste any more time on him, and have some therapy to boost your self esteem before you start dating so you never settle for such dregs again.

Trusttheawesomeness · 03/03/2026 12:44

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:41

The first time any contact with her happened, we had been together for about a yeara t that point, it was consensual back and forth between them. He sent her messages, one thing led to another, he sent a photo, she sent a photo back then he said he shouldn't since he was seeing me. She blocked him after that. To unblock him a while later, I believe.
We worked through it. I believe he has convinced himself she has stayed single all this time for him. Minding her reaction now I think that's not the case, but the video didn't come out of nowhere. She was receptive to that sort of stuff then.

But she did not ask for a video of him wanting several years after he left her for his bit on the side.

Back to you though; he cheated on you after an only a short time together and you forgave that? Now you’ve forgiven this time too?

Again, good luck.

Megifer · 03/03/2026 12:44

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

He demonstrated its more important because he sent her a video of him wanking and asked her to go back to him. He cant just turn off the feeling that he'd rather be with her.

So if you stay with him, then you will have to accept that quite simply, you'll never be as important to him as she is, unfortunately.

Fivelegged · 03/03/2026 12:45

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

Well, she wasn't interesting enough or 'first love' enough to stop him shagging you on the side when he was actually in a relationship with her, so I wouldn't get over-romantic about the whole first love/teenage sweethearts thing. He was having sex with you when he was in a relationship with her. Now he's in an unsatisfactory relationship with you, he's sending her wanking videos and begging her to take him back. If he dumped you and got back together with her, he'd almost certainly start shagging someone else on the side.

Maybe stop romanticising his Special Bond with the ex, and just acknowledge that he's a common-or-garden serial cheat who's just not that into you, rather than some deeply feeling man torn between two loves? That may sound brutal, but it's to stop you deluding yourself that this relationship has legs.

toottoot3 · 03/03/2026 12:46

That sounds really hard to live with, my insecurities have made me feel vulnerable during my long marriage but that was my projection, not his behaviour.
Your partner is actively showing you how he feels, listen to him and yourself