Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel like I'm not my partner's true love

320 replies

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 10:40

Posting from outside of the UK, I hope that's not an issue... Anyways, I'm 30 years old, a FTM (baby is 19 months old), and have been with my partner (29 years old) for 5 years now. Our relationship has been good for the most part, despite our rocky beginnings. I mention the way our relationship started because, being totally honest, this may be the main reason for some of what I'm about to describe. We met on a dating app when he was still in a relationship with his ex. I didn't know when we met but found out very quickly and decided to carry on seeing him anyways. Not proud of it to be clear. They broke up eventually after six years together.

From day 1 I have felt like I found 'my person' in him. He's smart, ambitious, handsome, has a lot of values and interests I share. Along with our baby we have built a beautiful life together. And yet despite all of the good things I can't describe the way I feel the lack of... intimacy (?) from his side. I don't mean purely in the physical sense. It's more like something I'm missing from him? I've thought a lot about this over the years and the only thing I can come up with is a feeling of him being reluctant. It doesn't feel like he's curious about me at all, or at least, not anymore. He doesn't put in effort to get me to open up or understand where I'm coming from when we're going through something. For example, I went through a rough patch with my mental health after my mom passed last year, and have honestly been needing quite a bit of support emotionally. I've tried to talk to him about this but he doesn't really engage or understand. Or bother to ask me what I'm experiencing. It's like he doesn't care enough to put in effort. And I've always felt like, for true love, you put in work and effort. I know I have...

I suppose his ex comes in here as well. She's been a bit of a third factor in our relationship since the start. The first year and a half of our relationship was filled with ups and downs as he clearly hadn't moved on from one relationship and was already starting a new one. We did work through that, he went completely no contact, and for a while it worked. Until about a year ago, shortly after I gave birth. We hti another rocky patch, one thing lead to another, and by his own confession to me he started slipping and making 'contact'. Meaning saving her social media pictures to his phone and DMing her when he drinks, begging her to take him back, asking for nudes. He showed me the messages he sent and they were....... not good.

Now, I've chosen to trust him and his word because he was transparent about it and seemed sincerely apologetic, and so far he has kept his promise to me and our child. But combined with his general reluctant attitude towards me sometimes, it just makes me feel more and more unwanted. I've expressed that I'd like to get married soon since we've been together for 5 years, had a baby, and are financially stable. Even though I try my hardest not to come off desperate (which is really difficult when you've dreamt of your "happy ever after"), he dismisses the idea anytime I bring it up and says that there's no rush. Knowing full well he proposed to her at one point. She rejected him but still. It hurts.

Sometimes I feel like what we have has all been in my head, built up and imagined because I want him so badly to be my happy ending. Does he even want this, does he want me, or does he want her? What am I missing? What does she have? This is all very hard to write to be honest. Makes it too real. But I don't have any friends or family to talk about this with irl, so reaching out here felt like my only option to get some perspectives on this and see if anyone can relate. Thank you in advance.

OP posts:
TheBestThingthatAlmostHappened · 03/03/2026 14:52

So you willingly entered into a relationship with someone who was actively seeking an affair partner whilst with the person who they'd been with since childhood. He lied to the face of someone he'd grown up with rather than being honest with her and has continued to mess with her head since then.

And now you've come to Mumsnet to see if we can figure out why it might be that he's appearing emotionally immature and unable to create an honest and open connection with a woman.

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 14:58

TheBestThingthatAlmostHappened · 03/03/2026 14:52

So you willingly entered into a relationship with someone who was actively seeking an affair partner whilst with the person who they'd been with since childhood. He lied to the face of someone he'd grown up with rather than being honest with her and has continued to mess with her head since then.

And now you've come to Mumsnet to see if we can figure out why it might be that he's appearing emotionally immature and unable to create an honest and open connection with a woman.

Thanks for the summary. Proud of you for being able to read the post!

OP posts:
Tableforjoan · 03/03/2026 14:59

Your dressing up and moulding yourself on his ex.

Thats not healthy for you at all. You are trying to be her and get his heart by morphing into her but you’ll never be her. Her mannerisms, the quirks, her personality, their memories. You’ll just be a fake her.

Look at your daughter. Now read what you’ve written as if it was her saying all this stuff. What would you want her to do.

Hoppinggreen · 03/03/2026 14:59

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 14:58

Thanks for the summary. Proud of you for being able to read the post!

I am assuming you are not proud of yourself though

TheBestThingthatAlmostHappened · 03/03/2026 15:01

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 14:58

Thanks for the summary. Proud of you for being able to read the post!

If you haven't managed to figure out why you've asked a really stupid question from reading that then I'd worry less about being proud of other people and more about being ashamed of yourself. And your useless excuse of a man.

TheBlueKoala · 03/03/2026 15:02

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 14:35

Opinions on trial separation?

He will be happy because that way he can justify being a cheating bastard.

Seriously OP, your relationship sounds dead. You are trying to look like his ex to please him- that's horrible. But he has already moved on in his head as you have noticed. He is no longer in love with you- actions (or non actions) speak louder than words.

I would suggest that you seek therapy because there must be a reason for that you think that you are worth so little. Most women with confidence and selfrespect would put an end to this charade. That you are not and still trying to find ways to please him is quite worrisome.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 03/03/2026 15:03

Tableforjoan · 03/03/2026 14:59

Your dressing up and moulding yourself on his ex.

Thats not healthy for you at all. You are trying to be her and get his heart by morphing into her but you’ll never be her. Her mannerisms, the quirks, her personality, their memories. You’ll just be a fake her.

Look at your daughter. Now read what you’ve written as if it was her saying all this stuff. What would you want her to do.

Worst thing you can do is try to be like her! My step grandma dyed her hair blonde in order to look like his first wife (my nana). Then my nana and grandad would dance at parties where step grandma was and you could see she was jealous.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 03/03/2026 15:05

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 14:35

Opinions on trial separation?

Did you read my post? Friend of mine when she had a trial separation he met someone else, had a baby with them then went back to my friend, then cheated on both of them at the same time. Do you really want that? Bet your boyfriend would love to have you both in competition for him. Does he have a golden cock?!

LemonPenguin · 03/03/2026 15:09

He was begging to get back with her and asking her to send nudes. This isn’t about ‘forgiveness’- it’s about valuing your own worth- you and your baby deserve so much better. It isn’t going to get better OP, in fact it will just get harder. Either you leave him now, or believe me- he will leave you in 10 years and you’ll feel so much more bitter about it then.

ZoeCM · 03/03/2026 15:11

You say you share a lot of the same "values". What do you mean by this? It really doesn't sound as though either of you are particularly principled people!

Was the pregnancy a "contraception failure" intended to keep the two of you together?

The part about you trying to look like his ex is just depressing.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 03/03/2026 15:12

ZoeCM · 03/03/2026 15:11

You say you share a lot of the same "values". What do you mean by this? It really doesn't sound as though either of you are particularly principled people!

Was the pregnancy a "contraception failure" intended to keep the two of you together?

The part about you trying to look like his ex is just depressing.

Maybe OP thought the pregnancy would keep him. Which as we all know rarely works out.

BippidyBoppety · 03/03/2026 15:13

Please do not show him this post. You are showing him your insecurities laid out - what in the World do you hope to achieve by this! Madness.

Why not go through the responses, take out the bits that speak to you - make notes to refer to and talk to him sensibly. On the last few pages people have referred to the "Pick Me" dance - it's exactly what you are doing. You are obsessed with this guys first girlfriend (please be a grown up and stop with the "first love" nonsense). It's not about her, it's about how he makes you feel.

I think I'm going to unfollow this thread because we are 12 pages in, you've had some excellent advice from people, and you are still banging on about it being a problem with the old girlfriend. The problem is him.

canisquaeso · 03/03/2026 15:14

ZoeCM · 03/03/2026 15:11

You say you share a lot of the same "values". What do you mean by this? It really doesn't sound as though either of you are particularly principled people!

Was the pregnancy a "contraception failure" intended to keep the two of you together?

The part about you trying to look like his ex is just depressing.

Yeah this reeks of trying to “keep a man” at all costs

Baby, styling herself like the ex…. yikes all around, really.

ZoeCM · 03/03/2026 15:14

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 14:58

Thanks for the summary. Proud of you for being able to read the post!

Can you really not read between the lines here?

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 15:15

BippidyBoppety · 03/03/2026 15:13

Please do not show him this post. You are showing him your insecurities laid out - what in the World do you hope to achieve by this! Madness.

Why not go through the responses, take out the bits that speak to you - make notes to refer to and talk to him sensibly. On the last few pages people have referred to the "Pick Me" dance - it's exactly what you are doing. You are obsessed with this guys first girlfriend (please be a grown up and stop with the "first love" nonsense). It's not about her, it's about how he makes you feel.

I think I'm going to unfollow this thread because we are 12 pages in, you've had some excellent advice from people, and you are still banging on about it being a problem with the old girlfriend. The problem is him.

Thank you for this. I'm going to log out and update when I can. Thanks for the advice everyone. I'll have to make my own decisions from here.

OP posts:
scottishgirl69 · 03/03/2026 15:15

He was begging her to take him back. It's not just the wanking. It's this. He was also seeing you both at the same time at the beginning - it's little wonder he thinks he can treat you as he pleases. He's awful.

What a creep. What a vulgar disgusting creep. He would have left you and your baby if she had said yes to going back to him

GreyCarpet · 03/03/2026 15:17

Re the trial separation.

I actually think it's a good idea.

Not because I think you might or should reconcile but because it will do a few things.

It will put an emotional and physical distance between you and him.

I think the likelihood of him changing how he feels about you is infinitesimal.

I think the likelihood of him remaining faithful to you is even less.

As is the possibility of him doing Amy kind of self reflection or growth.

BUT

I do think that distance would give you sometime to recalibrate and see yourself as you are because a pp is right, if you are modifying yourself to resemble her, then it won't work. Because you're not her. And you will lose yourself in the process.

It will give you chance to settle a bit emotionally and calm your nervous system. Away from the anxiety, you will hopefully find some peace.

You will also have to have strict boundaries around it. No checking his SM or 'last seen' on WA. No messages because you miss him or just want to check he's ok or see what he's up to.

I'd even suggest you are the one to move out (although tricky with a child!) So that you're not surrounded by reminders of him.

Maybe take a month. Book in some weekly therapy if you can. See your friends. Focus on work. Do a free course through the OU or something similar to keep you occupied.

Think about who you are, what you want out of life and what you want your future to look like. What colour do you want your hair to be? Stop trying to be her and rediscover yourself.

Keep posting here!

Tbh, if you did all of this, I strongly suspect that you'd read back over this thread in a month's time and wonder what the hell you were thinking.

You're obviously young. Don't waste your life on this man.

PrettyPickle · 03/03/2026 15:17

@ForSpryPeachWasp I think you deserve to be loved and feel loved without thinking there is a part locked away and not yours, no matter how good a Father he is.

DistanceCall · 03/03/2026 15:23

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

This is never going to happen, not with this man. It's never going to happen.

You only have one life, OP. Don't waste it on someone who doesn't deserve it.

andthat · 03/03/2026 15:28

Of course you’re not your partners ‘one true love’ @ForSpryPeachWasp

He sends nudes to his ex.

You know this.

HoskinsChoice · 03/03/2026 15:33

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:53

??? Why would I not work? I make more than he does. Rude person

Because, as literally everyone else is saying, there is absolutely no future in this relationship. He's cheated before, he's cheating now and he will cheat in the future. It is totally baffling as to why you are trying so hard to keep him therefore I wondered if you are reliant on him for money. As that's not the case, it's even more baffling.

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 03/03/2026 15:35

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 03/03/2026 10:47

Once a cheater almost always a cheater. Jo’s behaviour afterwards is appalling too.

This is not always the case.

ainsleysanob · 03/03/2026 15:38

ForSpryPeachWasp · 03/03/2026 12:36

I just need him to love me and put me first at all times. He can love her, still in a way. They say a man never forgets his first love and I am fine with that. With her having a place in his heart. I can accept that.
I can't accept this 'place' being more important than his relationship with me. He had a child with me. He lives together with me. Not her.

Edited

A child you’ve already said wasn’t planned.

His penis is more important than his relationship with you. He has shown you that. Wake up or you will end up like I did with a mental health condition, in therapy and an inability to trust anyone, ever.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 03/03/2026 15:44

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 03/03/2026 15:35

This is not always the case.

Maybe not always but a lot of times this is true.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 03/03/2026 15:46

GreyCarpet · 03/03/2026 15:17

Re the trial separation.

I actually think it's a good idea.

Not because I think you might or should reconcile but because it will do a few things.

It will put an emotional and physical distance between you and him.

I think the likelihood of him changing how he feels about you is infinitesimal.

I think the likelihood of him remaining faithful to you is even less.

As is the possibility of him doing Amy kind of self reflection or growth.

BUT

I do think that distance would give you sometime to recalibrate and see yourself as you are because a pp is right, if you are modifying yourself to resemble her, then it won't work. Because you're not her. And you will lose yourself in the process.

It will give you chance to settle a bit emotionally and calm your nervous system. Away from the anxiety, you will hopefully find some peace.

You will also have to have strict boundaries around it. No checking his SM or 'last seen' on WA. No messages because you miss him or just want to check he's ok or see what he's up to.

I'd even suggest you are the one to move out (although tricky with a child!) So that you're not surrounded by reminders of him.

Maybe take a month. Book in some weekly therapy if you can. See your friends. Focus on work. Do a free course through the OU or something similar to keep you occupied.

Think about who you are, what you want out of life and what you want your future to look like. What colour do you want your hair to be? Stop trying to be her and rediscover yourself.

Keep posting here!

Tbh, if you did all of this, I strongly suspect that you'd read back over this thread in a month's time and wonder what the hell you were thinking.

You're obviously young. Don't waste your life on this man.

I agree. At 30 no way was I mature and I put up with a lot of shit from men. Best thing ever was to be single for a bit in my early 30s.

Swipe left for the next trending thread